Food here is better than any restaurant in Chicago, Ribeye is our favorite!
I didn't give 5 stars, because 3 of us ordered filet and two of the steaks were not prepared correctly. The restaurant fixed the mistake and went above and beyond. Lobster was amazing. Service was top notch. I expected some sort of potato with the surf and turf. Mushy greens underneath gave the filet an earthy taste which I was not a fan of.
The lobster and scallops were phenomenal my husband had the filet and he said it was outstanding
Service was great from the start, as it was our first time Scot walked us through the menu and the specials and made sure we knew what was available and how everything was prepared. The food was great as well. Sea Bass and Scallops were cooked to perfection!
My friends and I make sure we make space in our schedule to break away from a convention we have been attending every March since 2010. Great food with fantastic music playing at the perfect volume to enjoy and still engage in quiet conversation. Make a reservation and enjoy!
We have the best time ever, every time
This is one of my favorite restaurants in the Geneva Lake area. However, my last experience had just a few glitches. Our very pricey lamb chops were tough and chewy with very few bites without grizzle. My sister ordered them also and she had the same problem. Also, I made my reservation a week or more in advance and we were seated right next to the front door on a cold night. So everytime someone came in or out, which was every few minutes, we were hit with a blast of arctic air! So not to pleasant But still my favorite place to go. I just won't order lamb and ask not to be put next to front door.
Had a friend and business partner in from out of town. There are few creative and upscale cuisine offering locations in Walworth County, let alone Lake Geneva. Ambiance fits well for both a romantic evening out or showing a friend a good time. Prices for the entrees are still a little steep, but barely. Worth a visit.
Absolutely and wonderfully delicious! Will definitely return without hesitation.
Nice diverse menu with many good choices. Delicious sea bass. Portions are generous. Service was helpful for my special request-- much appreciated!
Fantastic menu with great flavor no matter what you order. I do suggest the chef selection to try it all! Service and attention are equal to 5 star metro restaurants in lathe markets.
Always Great !
My husband and I were looking to try something new to celebrate our first year anniversary and found Medusa online. It looked cozy and romantic and the menu was appealing so we made our reservation. When we arrived we were not disappointed. The food was delightful and the service was fantastic! We will definitely go back. We've already spread the word to others.
I made a reservation but they placed us in the back room. The lightning was terrible, our table was in the corner and no one else was in our section. Both fish entrees we ordered were very dry.
Anyting Chef Gregory prepares is magnificent! It doesn't matter what you order, it will be perfect. The food is always seasoned beautifully, his soups are to die for. Be sure to order the Chef's Choice and let him choose for you. It's the best! The drinks are fantastic. It's easily the best food in Lake Geneva.
Excellent food, service & atmosphere! The food was prepared perfectly and tasted amazing.
The service is top notch! The food is excellent, if you want a great meal and a great glass of wine in Lake Geneva this is one of my top 3 picks!
This place is obviously popular. We had a 5:15 reservation and by 6:00 the place was packed, with the noise level escalating accordingly. Would have expected more Mediterranean style entrees, so although disappointed in that area what we did have ( risotto, rainbow trout, lobster) was excellent. Table for four where we were seated stuck out in the way of the entrance, with the cold air blowing in every few minutes as the place filled up. Somewhat pricey. Service kind of slow.
We love Medusa and have celebrated our last 4 Valentine dinners here. We feel the portions are right and everything is always so tasty. We always have exceptional service too. This is one of our very favorite places. We drive 50 minutes to enjoy an evening at Medusa.
We have been to Medusa's many times and each and every time our meals have been excellently prepared and served. Meat, seafood, sides, soups, appetizers, everything is superb. This is one of our most favorite restaurants. Whether you are visiting or live near the Lake Geneva area you should put this on your list of 'go to' restaurants.
Excellent food and service!
Good food, good service. Not the romantic environment it looked like online. More of a group atmosphere.
Once again, Medusa was a fabulous choice! We enjoyed the baby octopus app, lamb with Greek sauce, trout and lobster — all were prepared with excellent attention to detail and balanced seasoning. Our server was attentive and the vibe was casual and relaxed. Can’t wait to come back for the spring menu specials!
Was awesome ...
Waiter was a bit dull, not very enthusiastist. Food was excellent.
Outstanding meal, have never been disappointed when eating here. It's so good we always find ourselves talking about it the next day.
Back room is much quieter than front of house. 4 of us were once again very pleased with everything. Chef Greg has it really together!
We have been to Medusa on several occasions and it never disappoints. The Chef's Choice - Meat/Seafood is a MUST HAVE. We brought 4 other people and Medusa now has 4 additional fans. Love Love Love this place.
Fantastic restaurant if you are looking for some Mediterranean cuisine that is always fresh and authentic.
We have come to celebrate our Anniversary for many years with this being our 43rd. The Chef Greg is outstanding with his cooking and hospitality. In fact he greeted us with the biggest smile and hug, which made our Anniversary that more special. We travel from Milwaukee to dine here.
Don't wait to book your reservations. A Thursday night in February and I don't think there was an empty table in the place. We had the Chef's Choice Family Style and had an abundance of food. Lobster, chicken, kabobs, Italian sausage... great for a guy who can not make up mind- why choose, let Chef Greg!
I am a LOCAL- and this is a HIDDEN GEM!! I have been going to Medusa's for years- have NEVER EVER had a bad meal. The food is extraordinary! Their SPECIALS BOARD offers a variety of meats and seafood you WILL NOT be disappointed in. THe RIBEYE and the LAMB CHOPS are 2 of my very favorites and the Pork Loin Marsala is the best I have ever eaten. The chefs Brussel Sprouts ( in which I have always disliked Brissel Sprouts) turned me into a lover of them just in his preparation.
The staff is FAMILY- personable- and always enjoyable to dine among them. My favorite seat is sitting at the bar. On weekends they have additional rear dining space that is a little more intimate and quiet to enjoy if you are ON A DATE. 5 STARS ALWAYS.
Not as good as on previous visits. Ordered calamari for appetizer - NOT GOOD. Large chunks that were tough to chew with a mediocre sauce. Salmon and lobster were very good - steaks not so much. Should be more flavorful and tender for the prices they charge. Service was good - wine selection good. Food has noticably dropped in quality. Hoping we just hit an off night.
Only Negative is limited seating for four people. Are only choices, and it was empty when we arrived, were one of two tables both near the entryway. If it had been a freezing, windy night, this would have been horrible. Food is always great and we love coming here. And we have been seated in other parts of the restaurant with four. We usually come for a special occasion because it is not a cheap place. I would still recommend this place for its food and service.
Great place but a little pricey for what you get. Like atmosphere
Chief and he’s staff never let me down. Great food and great service I’ll be back soon , thanks for a great night
Best food in Lake Geneva area. Grate music
Spot on meals!!!!
The food is simply exceptional. The lobster tail was so much better than what I had in Maine. You would not believe that vegetables could taste this good. Best food in town by far. It's not cheap, but it's worth every penny. Interesting also was the kitchen cam, focused on one of the stoves. You may see your meal being created.
This came highly recommended by locals and it did not disappoint. We had an amazing meal with great service! Can not wat to dine there again!
I enjoy Medusa. Service excellent. The food tries to do a bit too much - conflicting flavors when you purchase everything separately. Albeit everything tasted good individually. Really really expensive entrees.
More of a place for an appetizer and a bottle of wine.