Stopped for lunch before Wicked. It appeared that they were short of help, so the service was slow (it took 3 visits to the table just to deliver our drinks) , but also among the most unfriendly I have ever received. While my salad was decent (although the cheese was fried), my friend’s cobb salad looked to be made with lettuce past its prime. My other friend was served the special Irish breakfast without the baked beans that were to be included. We felt badly for the waitress to some extent, and weren’t complaining, but we cannot recommend this restaurant.

Perfect place for a before or after theatre bite. Attentive staff, lots of choices of entrees and appetizers to fit your mood or a picky guest. Can’t go wrong at this pleasant midtown spot. Best Guinness this side of the Atlantic!

Great service, food was slightly better than traditional pub grub. The house beers were good, a nice touch.

Spacious and welcoming! McHale's is a fitting resting spot for travelers and locals, alike! Stick to basics on menu & on tap for best value.

Service was phenomenal, food was ok -- very limited menu, even for a bar. But we came here for a quick pre-show meal and the waitress was fast, efficient and extremely helpful. Recommend for pre-theater dinner or drinks with a large group, if you mostly prefer burgers and chicken.

We were going to the Gershwin Theatre across the street so the location was perfect. I had the spinach salad and asked for no beets which it came with. The server was good enough to comp us a glass of wine for the inconvenience. I also did not like the salad dressing which wasn’t the fault of the restaurant, just my taste buds. The other people in my party were very satisfied with their meal.

Decent, standard NYC pub fare. But an iced tea was $5. A little steep

I thought the restaurant had a nice atmosphere overall. It was a little noisy but not so much that I couldn't carry on a conversation. The service was efficient - we had more than one server checking in on us. We were going to a show and got our food promptly and had plenty of time with a 6 pm reservation on a Saturday to eat a leisurely meal. The food was okay but I felt like the menu was pretty limited. I settled a Caesar Salad to which I added shrimp which was overcooked. Well priced for the quality and service, however.

Cozy pub with a nice menu.

Dinner and a show

Food was just okay

The food is very good, and the staff are very friendly. Best shepherd's pie I've had in a really long time!!

Food was great. Waitress was fairz

Great ambiance great location if ur doing the theatres or the 5 th ave walk

Average place. Add 30-40% to the prices listed on OpenTable, they must be outdated.

Our server, Liam was AMAZING!

I’ve been to McHale’s several times but this by far was the best experience. One of their lite lagers was recommended and by far one of now top choices. I tried a specialty non-beef burger and it was fabulous! The server was friendly, knowledgeable and helpful. We definitely will continue to frequent McHale’s

Friendly, fun place with plenty of TVs

Saw the great reviews and decided to check it out but was disappointed. My friend enjoyed her buffalo mac and cheese. I ordered a bacon cheeseburger with fries. The burger had an onion flavor, and the waitress informed me the hamburgers have onion in the mix. I wish I would have known that before I ordered. The waitress was very understanding, friendly, and accommodating about the situation. I ordered a chicken parm sandwich with the sauce on the side (in case I didn't care for it). The chicken was decent but there wasn't much cheese and the bread was eh. My friend and I agreed the fries tasted like they were frozen, so I barely had any. To top it off, we ordered sodas and they didn't taste great either, but we didn't want to make a big deal about it. Wish we would have since the sodas were $5 each. I know this is NYC, but $5 is ridiculous, especially when we were there during happy hour and a beer was $6. Hope others have a better experience, but we will not go back.

Great place just off Times square and Broadway. The food was authentic and the service was excellent. Vary reasonable prices for NY. The restaurant was very clean and neet . Their house Old Fashioned was the best.

The food was a little expensive and soda did not have unlimited refills. The buffalo chicken Mac and cheese was really spicy and could not be eaten. Thought the waitress would take it off the bill and she did not, even though we told her it was too spicy for my boyfriend's daughter to eat. We were not impressed with this restaurant.

Food was bland and rushed when the place was half full at lunchtime. We have been here before and the food was top notch especially the burgers and wings. This time both were honestly not very good.

Met before show. Food was going and service was good. The prices were good for the quality especially for Manhattan. Would definitely go again

Inexpensive for NYC. Food was not special but then again, it's a pub . Service was quick and friendly. Sat at upstairs window which was nice.

Loud people swearing at the bar. The service was good.

Good value for the $$. Waitress very nice and accommodating. Mac and cheese a little bland

Our to-do place when in midtown. Does not disappoint.

Despite having reservations sat at high top table in bar-no air conditioning told dining room packed
Surly waitress could not crack a smile we will not be back

One of our favourite restaurants in New York. Great atmosphere, great food and great service.

Great place in the heart of Times Square. I made reservations to watch the USA women’s WiFi’s cup game. We had a table in the back in front if s big tv. Great atmosphere. We just appetizers, which were good. Fast friendly service.

I thought the place was good! But a bit pricey

We enjoyed our food very much and the service was prompt and friendly. My only complaint is that it was a bit noisy, but we were in the bar. I would definitely go back!

We had reservations because of time issues to see broadway show. Didn’t appear we needed them. Rarely go to New York and the food was good without the weird ingredients that most New York restaurants seem to want to add to a basic meal. Price was very reasonable for theater district. Server was very friendly.

In town for a show and McHales was nearby.

I ordered a cheeseburger which was hard as a rock. Ate as much as I could. Salad was good. In NY for the day to see the Cher Show.

Decent menu and tasty food surpassed only by the excellent service. Our waitress was attentive without being intrusive and didn't hesitate to ask the kitchen for a variation of one of the dishes we ordered. We were visiting NY from MD to take in a couple of plays. We knew nothing of McHale's except from a few reviews we read. We wanted a eatery in or close to the theater district. Couldn't have worked out better. Another pre-theater dinner at McHale's certainly will be in our plans for our next excursion

My daughters and I enjoyed a delicious lunch. Your staff was very accomodating.

It was a fun stop before heading to the theatre! Our waitress was very responsive, and the staff checked with me regarding allergies listed on my account. Great experience, recommend!

Our favorite go to spot when we are in NYC. Great food great atmosphere wonderful service

A good Irish pub.