Although I enjoyed the Rueben sandwich, the fish and chips my husband ordered wasn't the best. The fish was a bit greasy and not the mild flavor I am used in with Cod for this type of meal. The noise level was a bit high as well even though I asked for a quiet location. Not the best choice for us.
Overall experience was great. We are going to be return diners.
I ordered sautéed spinach which was extremely salty. Two in the party ordered the $23 beef tips and shrimp special, both said the beef was tough and they pushed it off to the side. We had hoped that new cook and management would make it better but we likely won't be back as the food was nothing special.
Waitress was a bit on the haughty side.
Great Irish pub- great craic. Friendly staff, great food. We’ll be back.
Love this energy here, great wait staff, food was excellent. Very accommodating... Will always come back. Will always recommend
Fun evening celebrating an anniversary. Staff was friendly, crowd was large but noise level was surprisingly low.
always enjoyable.great food,great service, great atmosphere
John and Dixie and their team never cease to amaze me for the quality of food, wine and beer, service and ambience at Mcgees! After over a decade of going there, it just keeps getting better and better! If you do not live locally, they make it worth a short drive! Here's to another decade!
Great service and good food.
We found this place by accident but were pleasantly surprised upon arrival. The building was amazing, server was fantastic and food exceeded expectations. We will definitely be back!
Great ambience. Nice decor. Good food. The ceiling mural in the entrance hall is beautiful.
Very good restaurant, will definitely be visiting again.
We enjoyed the atmosphere and food very much.
The service was also very good.
We wanted to hear all Celtic music, both live and piped in. I understood from the waitress that they try to please everyone, as they had a wide variety of music. However, this is a Scots-Irish pub and people should expect Celtic music there or go somewhere else!
Shane did a good job for having only been at the restaurant for a week or so. Took some time to get going, but would definitely go back.
The Beer Cheese Soup was fabulous. Worth the trip on its own. Good flavor on the burgers, fish, and sides, but they lost a lot of heat between the kitchen and the table.
We went on a lazy Saturday. Loved the atmosphere of the restaurant. The bartender said that they had been in the building for 21 years (it was built in the 30's).
If in Anderson, plan a visit!!
We came to their eclipse party all the way from Pennsylvania and it was excellent. The food was fantastic and the staff couldn't have been nicer. They even started giving out free beer as the eclipse approached. We met the owner and he's was so warm and welcoming .
I was surprised that McGees was not full with plenty of tables available at noon on a Saturday.
Food was good, service was excellent. I was given the impression through Open Table that reservations were limited. Not true.
A group of 8 friends met for dinner and to see Seven Nations play live. The restaurant was very busy but that just gave us a chance to chat and visit with one another. The bar was VERY crowded and I think there was only one bartender so drink service was a bit slow. Our server Cathy (not sure if it was with a C or a K) was handling several tables and even with our large group, she was attentive and friendly. Everyone enjoyed their food and the folks who got the fish and chips were particularly impressed with the quality, quantity, and freshness of the fish. The corned beef and cabbage were also delicious. One of our party had the Reuben sandwich and commented on the bread being toasted but not grilled. Still, there were only a couple of to-go boxes filled. Seven Nations played for a bit over an hour and was as good then, if not better than they were when I followed them 20 years ago. A great time was had by all and we will go back.
Authentic Celtic pub feel. Great entertainment. Food is beyond pub grub, and is delicious.
Long time customer. Very disappointed. Won't go back to eat.
our waitress was friendly and helpful with great recommendations from the menu. Overall, a nice, place.
We love Mcgees for all occasions. The food and service are excellent. Wish they would bring back the Irish stew with braised lamb shank.
Spent New Year's Eve with dear friends here. Outstanding on all levels!
Good food with some different choices. Good location.
McGee's has demonstrated by its longevity to be a downtown eating establishment survivor, providing a solid pub menu accented with several higher end selections such as salmon, steak, and specialty dishes. Food is consistently good to very good for a price point of $ to $. They have a small but welcoming bar space and serve a wide diversity of beers, wines, and whiskeys. Their live musical entertainment primarily on the weekends is always exceptional favoring Celtic genres but not without exceptions ie bluegrass, blues folk, etc. The groups ate announced well in advance and seating as well as standing room is often a premium.
I always enjoy dining at McGee's. Excellent service and wonderful food again this evening.
We went to McGees for a late date night. We arrived as the kitchen was closing and they were happy to seat us and take our order. Food was amazing! Great beer choices, extensive wine list, great menu. We had to try some Irish favorites and they were terrific. A cut above what we have had before from an Irish pub. We will definitely be back.
No matter what the occasion, you could not choose a better place! The food, the service, the atmosphere, is consistently impeccable and makes any occasion an outstanding dining experience ! After 11 years of going there, they continually raise the bar!
~ Karen Mogab
Food was good
Atmosphere was ok a little loud for me but I don't hear very well
Service was poor. It's was my wife's bday so a big deal for the family
My wife was literally cutting a bite of her steak when the waitress came with the check and a to go box. No complimentary piece of birthday cake. We were not even asked if we wanted dessert.
The waitress was very nice. The food was great love the atmosphere. We would definitely be coming back to this place again soon
We were very impressed with the opentable. The waitress was waiting for us and knew we had a reservation. Our waitress was very attentive and answered all of our questions and made great suggestions. The portions were very good. We will definitely return and use opentable for reservations.
We had the wrong McGee's. We went to the McGee's in Acme, Michigan - have no idea where this McGee's is located - obviously screwed up so apologies to the restaurant.
We thoroughly enjoyed our night at McGees, including playing trivia. We'll definitely come again.
The food was better than expected. We ordered appetizers, wine, beer and main dishes. Everyone ordered something different and everyone was very pleased with their dish. We went on the Saturday of Mother's Day weekend to avoid the Sunday crowds. The service was very good. Our server was new and we understood that even when she would pull in help to clarify things for us. Would definitely like to go back!
McGee's has a nice assortment of food and is family friendly. The service was fantastic. We ate the homemade Irish soda bread, honey mead chicken and blue ridge trout. All the food was prepared well and delicious. We preferred the flavor of the honey wine sauce on the chicken to the nut sauce on the trout. I would have preferred a savory herb sauce on the fish. The garlic mashed potatoes and bourbon apples were tasty too. We ordered the Bailey's Irish Creme cheesecake and chocolate bourbon pecan pie for dessert. The cheesecake was very creamy but not much Bailey's flavoring and the oatmeal crust was not good at all. The pecan pie had chocolate sauce on top and an aftertaste of bourbon with a heavy thick no flavor crust. Next time, we will skip dessert and try a glass of ice wine instead. The ambiance was a wooden working Irish bar which we enjoyed but take a light jacket or sweater to endure the cold AC.
Great food and service. Corned beef Wellington was super. Our server was very attentive. Defiantly one of our fav restaurants.
We chose McGee's Pub for our 46th anniversary dinner because we've eaten there before and we like the Celtic food and ambiance. Nicole was our server and took special care of us for our anniversary dinner. She even took our picture for us. The steak was done to perfection, and we could not get over its wonderful flavor.
We entered as a couple, but the staff made us feel as though we were dining among friends.
One of our favorite places for Sunday Brunch. Nice choices and even Mimosas and Bloody Marys. The chefs at McGee's take special time to invent "special" dishes with sauces and seasonings perfectly blended. If you're in the mood for a sandwich and craft beer or fish and chips, this is the place. I would describe it has quaint, delicious food, nice atmosphere, friendly and attentive staff. Must try it!
I understand the nightlife and summer movies on the patio are a lot of fun and I imagine pretty lively. We have to drive about 30 miles so have never tried either of those.
The food and service was excellent. Love the fish and chips and shrimp and chips. Always a pleasure to eat at McGee's Pub.
Who would thought, I've been married over hhalf my life.
Dixie, John, and their staff consistently do an awesome job! They not only set the bar but keep on raising it! Because of the quality of their food and service, not only do locals consistently come there, people drive from up to a minimum of 45 miles away to have dinner at a place this grand!