Every time I'm in the Indianapolis area I make it a point to eat at Matteo's.
Our family uses this as our "gotta do" for special events.
It was great food and service. Will recommend the place and come back again
Little disappointed they didn’t acknowledge we were there to celebrate a birthday.
This was our first time there, and just so happen to be our date night. The moment we walked in we were greeted and taken care of right away. The tables were beautifully set, the napkins were folded elegantly, and a candle was lit at each table. Our waitress greeted us right awayWas very friendly professional and has strong knowledge of The menu. The menu it self is beautifully made, was not overwhelming and did not have 1000 items, You can tell everything was carefully selected. I personally prefer this method as it allows the head chef and the kitchen team to learn every single detail about each meal to ensure the greatest quality possible, too many times restaurants feel the need to have two wide of a variety which causes the standard of what you will allow to pass through the window to drop and Is very difficult to learn every detail needed to not only ensure top quality but consistency. My fillet was Beautiful. Right away I noticed the seer so perfect I Felt like I was about to unwrap a present from the moment I made my first cut I saw a perfectly cooked rare fillet which seemed to melt away with every bite The penne pasta was deliciously cooked with a wonderful Gorgonzola cream sauce the dish my boyfriend ordered or two chicken breasts so tender that a knife was not even needed to cut. My only complaint is the reservation menu online has a date night selection, I wish along with that selection there was a separate place for “date night” with dim lights and candles. Overall incredible experience
Excellent!!! So good!!! I started with the Caesar salad, and had the special!!! Excellent!!!
This was our first trip to Matteo’s, and it will definitely NOT be our last! The food was absolutely delicious! I highly recommend the veal scallopini!! The moscato wine was superb! The service was exceptional! There’s nothing that we didn’t absolutely love about the restaurant! Come one, come all....Matteo’s is AWESOME!!! 😍
Everything about our evening at Matteo’s was just fine. Except After arriving on time we waited 20 minutes before we were seated.
As a former resident of Italy, I am a SNOB when it comes to Italian food. This was more authentic than any that I have had since coming back to the USA.
The special occasion was my sister's birthday. It was the perfect day for a drive to the delightful town square in Noblesville. The parking was very easy and the restaurant was inviting. The service was outstanding. The dinner specials were spectacular and the food was very yummy! Portion sizes were generous! Great atmosphere too.
My wife and I have been twice, and while Italian food in general is not my favorite (it's her's), Matteo's has impressed me both times I've been. The service is fantastic and knowledgeable, the ambiance was appropriate, and above all the food was great. If it weren't for Matteo's, I would have no idea that I loved eggplant! I am sure we will return.
Wonderful! We’ll be back!
Matteo's is always a pleasant experience. The staff, food, and ambiance are great whether it is a girl's night out, dinner with spouse or a business meal.
We drove two hours to visit this Restaurant asking in advance by phone to be near the entertainment. We were taken upstairs and that was thankfully corrected. Our wait to be seated and standing at your front door was approximately 20 minutes. We waited over 35 minutes to have a bottle of wine once we finally had a waiter come to greet us. When we received the wine it was placed in front of my face instead of the polite thing, having it set to the edge of the table. I was furious over the lack of training giving to your servers! They need to be timely, efficient and provided some basic etiquette service. No, I will never go back to this Restaurant for a special evening with my husband.
We've been going to Matteo's for a number of years now. The food is always fantastic, made from scratch; the service is always outstanding with a very friendly and knowledgeable staff; the prices are decent, and you can carry on a conversation fairly easily.
Have been to Matteo’s many times with my wife. This time we got there at 5:30 PM on Valentine’s Day. Started with an appetizer of Insalata Caprese which was simply amazing. My wife ordered her favorite, Spaghetti del Golfo, while I tried the Penne Norcia. To my surprise, my order came out cold, like it had just come out of the refrigerator. Even after asking to have it warmed up, it was cold in most places. Still, the waiter was great and we had a good time. We had our orders put in a take home and had it the next day for lunch.
This was our second visit to Matteo’s. I have to say the service was better on our first visit. We came during lunch this visit and last visit we came at dinner. The food was also much better on our last visit. Me and my fiancé both actually felt ill later that day after our most recent lunch visit. I had veal, and she had Ravioli, but both felt the same. We will be back though. Our first visit was good enough to make it worth another trip.
This is our third visit to Matteo's. It's now our favorite special occasion restaurant. As "regulars" we know to order the Mateo salad (which is not on the menu) for our shared appetizer. The Matteo tortellini is what brings us back. So delicious! The staff is very friendly.
Great place for date night.
You about can't go wrong dining here. The food, especially the specials, is always very good. Unlike so many restaurants today, it is quiet.
We were celebrating a birthday, and the experience was wonderful. The food was great. The server was attentive and even made extra effort to make the dinner special for my boyfriend when she learned it was his birthday.
Great food, Excellent service, Great evening in every respect!
Excellent food at a reasonable price with great service in a fantastic atmostphere! Couldn't ask for more!
Last minute change in plans and completely forgot that people would be celebrating Valentines Day . . . we secured a reservation via Open Table. Matteo's was fantastic!! Walking thru the door is such as pleasure - polite greeting, attentive service, and wonderful smells! The service was exceptional - customized a salad for us and offered recommendations to make the meal more enjoyable than just the usual off-menu items. Excellent dinner - I opted for the Osso-bucco which I would go back for repeatedly! If you just want desert - the Tiramisu is a must! Wine list is moderate but with very good selections and . . . . did I mention the exceptional service!!!
Outstanding food and ambiance. Staff were friendly and very attentive. Highly recommend . Price met quality and atmosphere.
Excellent meal with excellent service! We would definitely go back to Matteo's.
Our 1st. Visit. And from our Greeters to being taken to our table, Everyone was so accommodating and pleasant. Our Server was so helpful in helping us make Great decisions on our Food choices. The wait was well worthy the very Tasty food which was hot and looked Great. Thanks again...
Excellent all around. Early Valentines Day dinner
This is a hidden gem! This was my first visit to Matteo’s and I was impressed! I’ve been to many of the ‘top’ Italian restaurants around and Matteo’s was so good I doubt I’ll go to any of the others again. Food, wines, service, ambiance all were top quality!
Great service and food that satisfies your taste buds.
Wonderful birthday dinner! Excellent service and dinner.
A staple in Noblesville. Very consistent and good.
What a great spot in the heart of Noblesville. Great service from real pros.
We’ve been going there for years. The new owners have substantially cut back the menu and raised prices. Food mediocre at best and my dish was undercooked. Hate this because it’s been a favorite.
Matteo's has been a staple for our family for years. The food is always good however we did have some issues at this visit. The waitress forgot an order and one entree came out cold, not lukewarm, but cold. Disappointing and not the norm.
Matteo's is one of our favorite restaurants and especially for special occasions. The fun and service is always outstanding. Everyone is so friendly and the food is AMAZING! This is a can't miss and highly recommended....OH - and don't forget the bread!!
Delicious! Adorable restaurant, fabulous food, nice cocktail/wine selection, and great service!!
Our server Miguel always provides great service.
Lovely restaurant on the Square in Noblesville. Limited Italian menu. Atmosphere was perfect and quaint. Service was excellent. Food was good, but not great. Warm bread with the meal. Not too expensive, but not cheap either.
We went with another couple for NYE. We had reservations. Our first table we were seated at was so unbearably cold.... right in front of the windows. We were quickly moved, when asked, to a spacious booth. There was a very limited menu since it was NYE. This was not noted on Open Table, nor Matteo's web site. We were excited to try food that was not offered that evening. The food was awesome, our waitress was very attentive and the restaurant is very charming. We WILL be returning!