***The safety and well-being of our staff, and guests, are our number one priority. We have implemented new health and safety protocols that go above and beyond our already strict standards, so that you can feel safe when dining with us. We look forward to serving you with safety and Aloha!
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
House Made Lasagna Pasta, Bechamel Sauce, Mozzarella & Parmigiano, Maui Cattle Co. Beef, Italian Sausage, Tomato Ragu
Choose Between Penne or Spaghetti Pasta with One Sauce. Butter, EVOO, Marinara, Pesto
White Tagliatelle, Maui Cattle Co. Beef & Italian Sausage, House Tomato Sauce, Parmigiano Reggiano
Had a lovely evening dining at Matteos, glad they are back. Food was delicious and service was excellent. Miss the old wine list and by the glass selections. I hope they bring that back.
A must visit in Maui. The best Italian on the island!
Great food, great service!
Excellent service, amazing food!
Good was really good. Great service. Great atmosphere
Wow! We made a reservation for the only time and table they had available (5pm and bar top). Was pleasantly surprised that when we arrived, we got seated at a regular dining table.
Our server (I’m so ashamed I did not get his name but I believe he was also the manager) was amazing! Very friendly, happy and helpful. The only thing better than him was our food!!!
We ordered the ahi bruschetta, Caesar salad to share, the seafood pasta and the short ribs. For beverages, I asked if they had anything with Lillikoi, he suggested the mojito- it was delicious! And the garnish (some special cherry) was fabulous!!
Would we return? YES! This was simply our best sit down restaurant meals on Maui!!!
Excellent Food and superb service. Fish preparation excellent. Fresh made pasta at the Restaurant is the best. Book early!
Great food and service as well
Always friendly and delish! Great Italian on the island! Lasagna is perfect
We loved it! Turkey meatballs were amazing and the service was fantastic! We will be coming back here!
Very nice evening at Matteos. Both the food and the service were very good. A bonus that it is an easy walk from Grand Wailea and a few of the other resorts nearby as rental cars in Maui these days are very scarce and very expensive. And with most resorts not having all of their restaurants open, off resort dining options are very much appreciated right now.
Rushed service, zero acknowledgement of special occasion. Wine special had conveniently “sold out” just before we got there, we were offered replacement at 50% increase in price! Over eager busboys aggressively clearing plates before we were done chewing our last bite. Food was average, not bad, not great.Would not go back.
My husband and I were so surprised that the restaurant had so many gluten-free accommodations.
Service by Michael was fantastic, food was very authentic and delicious. We highly recommend MATTEO’S!
I always enjoy dining here. Staff is lovely and the food is delicious.
Wonderful house made pastas and extremely friendly and helpful staff. Would definitely return!
Food was very good/ a little pricey for Italian/ excellent service for being short-handed
Amazing food, great staff and we loved the high top table and being able to watch everything! The food was the best I’ve had since traveling to Italy! Thanks for a great meal 😊
This was our first time visiting this restaurant and I have to say it was the best meal so far. We’ve been here for a week and had dinner at some really good restaurants including Mamas and Merrimans. Service was excellent as well and they have a large wine selection. My husband had the Costolette and I had the Isola. Both were fabulous.
If you love italian food and a romantic atmosphere go to Mateos
We dined at Matteo's on May 26th, 2021. The food was great. Our server Kiana was exceptional. She is very knowledgeable about the menu items as well as the wine list. We look forward to coming back.
This is a super cute restaurant near all the Wailea resorts. Lovely location, no views if you are wanting that but a beautiful patio and great atmosphere. We shared appetizers- a beef flatbread with truffle oil and Caprese salad. Both well done and tasty. The pastas were just OK. I had the bolognese- average on all accounts with a thin and runny red sauce. The carbonara (a house special that day) had excellent taste and ample toppings. The pasta itself was a little too al dente for our tastes, as in it could have been cooked 2 mins longer to reach the al dente stage. That may just be a personal pasta preference though. We took the cannolis to go for dessert and loved them. Overall a 4/5. We would go back here for sure. Good wine selection as well. Excellent service and friendly, attentive staff. We eye balled what our neighbors were having and it all looked good.
Excellent Service, consistently great food, 100 wines by the glass... Happy to have a restaurant of this level on Maui.
Delicious food! Service was okay. Nice view from patio. Would recommend for great Italian food on the island!!
$20 for a glass of wine is way to much. House specialty lasangia was greasy and served in a crock with very little noodles. We did not enjoy our main entree however the prosciutto and melone was delicious.
Food was delicious, everything we ordered was amazing! Meatballs, beet salad, gnocchi and seafood pasta ❤️
Always delicious and dependable. Great wines by the glass, excellent cocktails, the meatballs are to die for and Justin the sever is generous and helpful. Overall a great place.
Great service and really good dinner. Thank you.
Disappointing experience. Pushy waiter, bland food. For the same money had much better food at other restaurants here in Maui. No reason to come back.
Great food! Great service. One of our favorite places.
Fantastic cocktails. Our server was kind, personable, detailed, and attentive. The food was incredible, even though there was a mix-up with a pasta dish we ordered they quickly remedied it, brought us a new one, and comped it from our bill. Also gave us a complimentary dessert for the trouble. Always love matteo’s when we’re in Maui!
Recommended by a friend and it’s a lovely restaurant. Service was excellent and the food was delicious
Better service the first time we were there.
By far the best meal we’ve had on our stay on the island.
We had a fabulous evening with Kiana Z! She did a fantastic job taking care of us and made us feel so welcomed and special. We were celebrating our delayed honeymoon and she treated us to a tiramisu. Extremely attentive and food was delicious. We had the vegan brushetta and Gnocchi. Best service and food we had our entire Maui trip!
We had a wonderful experience at Matteo’s! The Gnocchi was incredible, the ambiance was lovely, and the service was quick and kind.
Such a nice surprise. Sat outside, service was great and the food was a wow! We had everything from fish to pizza and all of it was really good. Dessert of chocolate molten cake with gelato is a must.
Great Italian restaurant with daily specials
Beet salad with butter squash & goat cheese was very tasty. Big enough to share.
Daily special lamb bruschetta with goat cheese was delicious.
Fettuccine with seafood was excellent. Highly recommend.
Cioppino was tasty but little too salty for my last.
Apple tart with vanilla ice cream was just right for the sweet ending and big enough for 2
The food was delicious!
We've come to anticipate our meals at Matteo's, having enjoyed them in several years past. Sadly, this time they disappointed on several fronts:
(1) We loved coming for their happy hour, which according to our waiter, they have eliminated permanently because they're now "in demand" and don't need to "discount" their food;
(2) This newfound haughtiness was also reflected in the service we received - patronizing and condescending;
(3) We had their lasagna (which in years past was stupendous) and the braised short ribs, neither of which were very good; and
(4) Finally, they increased the pricing on their bottled wines, which are no longer worth the cost.
We were very disappointed and may not return during our upcoming visits.
MATTEO'S OSTERIA offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (808) 891-8466.
MATTEO'S OSTERIA is rated 4.7 stars by 2516 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.