Great service and very good food
Fourth time and by far the worst experience. Everything just seemed off from the beginning.
We enjoyed a delicious meal at Matteo's Osteria on our last night in Maui. We had patio seating, which was less noisy than inside, and very comfortable, though no ocean views at this eatery. Our server, Brooklyn, was friendly but not overbearing. Made great suggestions. We split a caprese salad (wonderful!) Husband had the lasagna and I had the Pappardelle with lamb. We were not disappointed!!!! We finished off our St. Patrick's Day meal with Irish Coffee. After 11 nights of lovely fresh Hawaiian fish and fruits, this was a nice change and prepared us to return to our stateside routines. We will definitely recommend Matteo's to our friends who travel to Maui.
Food is delicious but pasta portions are very small. Everyone in my party was still hungry after our main course.
Food is excellent and so is the service. Probably the best fresh tuna I ever had.
Best lasagna I have ever had. Everything was great..will be back in our next visit to Maui.
We eat inside where it was EXTREMELY NOISEY. Outside may have been less noisey. The calamari was excellent and the main meals that we had were very good but, ... the portions were skimpy. If it hadn’t been so noisey we may have enjoyed our meal and given a higher overall rating.
Great wine selection, good food and great service
Sehr gutes Essen. Der Service war hervorragend und sehr zuvorkommend. Reservation empfelenswert.
Wonderful food and great service.
Service is consistently friendly, and the waiter was well versed in the menu items. The is one restaurant that I always visit when in Wailea.
Very good place great service and great food. We are somewhat boring people so we ordered lasagna but it was absolutely to die for the best lasagna I think I've ever had. Especially of your cheese lover. Everything else was top notch as well including the service.
The food was authentic Italian with a personal twist. The service was incredible!
Matteo’s is delightful and my favorite restaurant on Maui. I’d recommend it to anyone.
Noticed this Osteria when visiting another business near their location. They are well off the beaten path. We then researched them on the net and liked what we saw.
Overall experience was quite pleasing, we will be returning on our next Maui trip (July 2019).
This is good classic Italian food. The outdoor seating is much better than the indoor. The focaccia bread is fresh. They traditionally serve with hummus. I asked for olive oil which goes much better. We tried a number of dishes. The favorite was the Fettuccine Frute di Mare.
Amazing, as always. Delicious food, crafted beverages, wonderful service.
Was very disappointed. Matteo’s had been recommended to us and we were very much looking forward to our dinner. Initially, there was some confusion about our reservation. We were seated outside on deck. That was fine. However the waitress, Brooklyn, was not out there much at all. It seemed she had only 2 tables out there at the time. Food was served to us, she did not come to see if we enjoyed it. Showed up at end to aske if we wanted dessert and then again with bill.
Food was adequate, nothing special for the price.....will not revisit nor recommend to friends.
I would give a higher ranking if the noise level wasn't so high. Was indoors this time and have tried several locations inside - doesn't seem to make much difference. Of course it's worse when they are full and there are large tables celebrating special events. Outside is somewhat better.
The food wasn't as described while it was tasty I expected something else. Waitress seemed disgusted we didn't all order appetizers and salads before dinner. They put 4 of us by a loud large group and there was another quieter table open. Might not go back.
Terribly noisy with very loud people, too cold also!
The most amazing food and service on the island. Matteo and his crew never fail to provide an exemplary dining experience. Pay attention to the daily specials, they are both inventive and delicious.
outstanding as always.. consistently delicious specials and wonderful attentive service.
Flavorful, fresh food. Nice energy and atmosphere.
Yes - great staff and great food. Outdoor area is great
Would highly recommend Matteo's, great ambiance, really friendly staff, fast efficient service. The food was very good. Met with Matteo for a moment while leaving, this is a passionate professional restaurateur who takes great pride in his food and his restaurant, you will not be disappointed! Great value also!
Very nice atmospheric, great selection of Italian dishes. Our server, Brooklyn, was informative, intelligent and very perception. Made the entry experience amazing. We have been telling our friends!
Overall was a very nice evening
We loved Matteos! We dined with our young children early in the evening. They were incredibly accommodating and the service was generally outstanding. Our meals were served promptly and the food was really fresh and delicious. We would definitely recommend this restaurant and will return.
Great time as always with Russell. Missed the filet mignon. Steak salad was okay although didn’t seem like dinner.
Food was great and the Service was good and enjoyable
Arrived at 5:30 and special was gone. Very disappointed.
Booked reservations through OpenTable, noted that it was our anniversary and didn't have a single mention of it the entire night. Very disappointed
Love this place
I would have given a 5-star rating based on service, and my family members’ outstanding pasta dishes and all our salads, but unfortunately my cioppino was so disappointing. One piece of not-fresh mahi in a bland tomato soup with a few shrimp. I left the fish u eaten and
waiter and wait staff were attentive and so knowledgeable. Great suggestions for food and wine! Really enjoyed the charcuterie board, roasted beet salad, lasagna and seafood ink pasta! Wonderful!!
Average meal for $200. Meatball apps good but barely warm. Salad overdressed. Expected better
The pasta at Matteo’s is consistently delicious. I had the special crab ravioli and it was so good. Sitting out on the patio is very pleasant and a fun dining experience. Great value for you money!
We loved it. My gluten free partner found many great alternatives (settled on the pizza) and the rest of our party enjoyed the pasta dishes. Wonderful spot
Food was great. Service was mediocre. Nice place overall and would go back