This restaurant is temporarily offline. Please contact the restaurant directly or check back shortly for availability.
Food is incredible always have a great meal wait staff very attentive definitely one of our favorite restaurants
Excellent family style Italian food. Good service with attentive staff, well versed in how much food to order and they do the serving as well.
Seated on time, water refilled without asking, food delivered as ordered, 2 pens with the 2 credit cards. 4 pet peeves were all taken care of!! Very good experience at dinner at Matteo's last Saturday night. The only complaint was the waiter was too busy to serve the family style salad. 4 happy patrons. We will be back!
From the moment you walk into this fine dining establishment you are greeted by friendly, hospitable hostesses. The food is exceptional as is the service. Our waiters name was Justin - he was very friendly, knowledgeable, attentive and professional . May I add - it was Justin's SECOND night working at the restaurant! Way to go Justin! Thank you for making our dining experience one to remember! I have eaten there numerous times before and will continue to patronize this exceptional restaurant!
We were a party of 8....chopped salad was the only dish we enjoyed. Mussels smelled awful and were very dried pieces of something in a shell. We sent that dish back. Orders of Chicken Parm and Chicken Marsala were also overcooked and very salty. The worst was the Pasta Bolognese which was so salty our mouths puckered when we tasted it. That dish was also sent back. The kitchen staff & wait staff tend to cluster around the kitchen area so maybe nobody is really caring about the food and service.
The servers were knowledgeable of the food and very friendly. We never had to ask for refills and the food was all served equally.
Great time all around.
The food at Matteo’s is consistently great! Their servers were attentive to our table of 10. However the party of 30 that was arranged right next to our table truly spoiled our evening. I would make sure not to be seated in the back room.
First time at Matteos. Loved the food,service, and ambiance of the restaurant. Being a vegetarian they were very accommodating and took good care of our needs. Service was excellent. Would go there again and highly recommend this restaurant. Great neighborhood gem.
I enjoyed Saturday night family dinner at Matteo's of Roslyn. The food was delicious and the service was good. The chef came to our table to ensure the food and service was good. The wait staff was on top of things, attentive to our requests and very friendly. They got the high chairs prepared for us and kept the water glass consistently filled. The wait staff was helpful in dividing up our portions and serving us.
Very good food, ample quantity and very tasty. Family style serving, need to take that into consideration especially when only two are dining. Wish we skipped the appetizer to save room for the main course, although the app was a special and very delicious.
Food is excellent never disappoints We shared the pasta Bolognese and the veal chop Milanese
can't wait to go back
Another Great meal
Loved the food. Singer was great
Delicious as always, thank you!
Great waiter. Kitchen a bit slow. Salad took 20 minutes to come. Food was delicious though didn’t love the pasta bologese (I think it was called Nonna’s pasta) as short rib was tough
Food was very good and Brian our waiter was great.
My husband and I liked Matteo’s very much. It was our first time and found the ambiance and food to our liking. Service was fine except we would’ve liked if our waiter would’ve explain the various pricing on the dishes. He failed to do that so we asked after we had already placed the order. Also, parking can be an issue, although they offer valet parking. Other than that, we were pleased with our visit and would consider returning again.
A lot of food but expensive
Great service and meal was amazing!
Great food, wonderful service, great location, thank goodness for the valets
Excellent food, beautifully prepared. They were good about correcting error in portion. Veal dish should have been larger for price paid. And pasta for two could have fed 6-8. Delicious food, I'll be back.
consistent; accommodating - always enjoy for a neighborhood restaurant
Having eaten there several times with good food no issues, we were very unhappy with our dining experience overall. We brought two guests, who are quite food knowledgeable, and we encountered poor, sloppy, rude and clumsy service. Not only that, my wife returned a pasta dish that was served as soupy glop, obviously improperly prepared. I have eaten this many, many times both in my Grandmothers kitchen and many restaurants in the US and Europe, and I have never encountered this texture before. It was as if they didn't bother to drain the pasta.
We returned the dish and expected them to subtract it from the bill, WHICH THEY DID NOT DO!
No apologies, no offer of any considerations, like an after dinner drink to salvage the spoiled evening. After we complained, they reluctantly subtracted the dish from the menu.
Needless to say we will not come back.
The food was amazing!!!!! Loved the sauté calamari in a spicy red sauce. Salmon was delish and one of my favorite was the gluten free brownie. Brian was very nice and made sure we were satisfied with our choices.
service was great!!! i highly suggest you do not go during prime dinner time. food was yummy perfect for a date
Restaurant totally renovated and done extremely well.
Family style or individual - a plus.
Love it! Lobster bisque is exquisite! My wife said it was like you know what in her mouth. The service was top-notch, very attentive my water glass was always full my silverware was changed and my server was always accessible. This hidden gem blew me away and I’m a huge foodie and not easy to please. Parking is terrible even with Valet there was a wait but would not deter me from coming back again and again. Class act all the way!
Food was excellent, staff was friendly and very attentive. Overall we were very happy with our choice and we'll definitely be back. Great place.
We loved our meal! We have not been to Matteo’s in so long. We were very impressed with service as well as the food! We will definitely be back!!
Matteo’s is always a great place to eat. Food was delicious, waiter and other staff werebfriendly and helpful, etc
The food was delicious as usual. They kindly accommodated our requests and catered to us as royalty. This is why we regularly have Matteo's on our regular dining list. They keep the music at a level so even people sitting across from you can hear, since the point of the evening is fine food, wine and conversation. We easily met all our goals tonight and look forward to our next visit.
Very tasty dishes and quality service. Can't wait to go back.
We were disappointed that they stopped serving the restaurant week menu at 7pm. The food and cocktails were delicious!
Very mediocre experience. The food was delicious, but other than that I was not impressed. It took a half hour to order and receive our drinks ( which was a bottle of wine), and our server was not accommodating when we asked for recommendations on the menu. I do not think I will return to Matteos of Roslyn.
Great food great service, really nice portions for restaurant week!
The Matteo’s restaurant week menu was great value; awesome selection and portions ! The restaurant is beautiful itself. The service was a little slow; not sure if it was due to the busyness of restaurant week but it felt like a lot of time has passed between each time the waitress checked our table even though she was very sweet. We were there from 7:10 - 9:30. Overall, would add this to a list of staple places to dine. Food was delicious
Food was incredible! Definitely recommend!
Groupon made the meal a great bargain. Food was good. Service good. Price excellent.
Second time at the restaurant. Was sat at table at end of bar. Service subpar. Was served by bar staff who were unable to wait table effectively because
First time dining at this location. Service and food wee impeccable. Looking forward to dining here in the near future with friends and family