My husband and I liked Matteo’s very much. It was our first time and found the ambiance and food to our liking. Service was fine except we would’ve liked if our waiter would’ve explain the various pricing on the dishes. He failed to do that so we asked after we had already placed the order. Also, parking can be an issue, although they offer valet parking. Other than that, we were pleased with our visit and would consider returning again.
A lot of food but expensive
Great service and meal was amazing!
Great food, wonderful service, great location, thank goodness for the valets
Excellent food, beautifully prepared. They were good about correcting error in portion. Veal dish should have been larger for price paid. And pasta for two could have fed 6-8. Delicious food, I'll be back.
consistent; accommodating - always enjoy for a neighborhood restaurant
Having eaten there several times with good food no issues, we were very unhappy with our dining experience overall. We brought two guests, who are quite food knowledgeable, and we encountered poor, sloppy, rude and clumsy service. Not only that, my wife returned a pasta dish that was served as soupy glop, obviously improperly prepared. I have eaten this many, many times both in my Grandmothers kitchen and many restaurants in the US and Europe, and I have never encountered this texture before. It was as if they didn't bother to drain the pasta.
We returned the dish and expected them to subtract it from the bill, WHICH THEY DID NOT DO!
No apologies, no offer of any considerations, like an after dinner drink to salvage the spoiled evening. After we complained, they reluctantly subtracted the dish from the menu.
Needless to say we will not come back.
The food was amazing!!!!! Loved the sauté calamari in a spicy red sauce. Salmon was delish and one of my favorite was the gluten free brownie. Brian was very nice and made sure we were satisfied with our choices.
service was great!!! i highly suggest you do not go during prime dinner time. food was yummy perfect for a date
Restaurant totally renovated and done extremely well.
Family style or individual - a plus.
Love it! Lobster bisque is exquisite! My wife said it was like you know what in her mouth. The service was top-notch, very attentive my water glass was always full my silverware was changed and my server was always accessible. This hidden gem blew me away and I’m a huge foodie and not easy to please. Parking is terrible even with Valet there was a wait but would not deter me from coming back again and again. Class act all the way!
Food was excellent, staff was friendly and very attentive. Overall we were very happy with our choice and we'll definitely be back. Great place.
We loved our meal! We have not been to Matteo’s in so long. We were very impressed with service as well as the food! We will definitely be back!!
Matteo’s is always a great place to eat. Food was delicious, waiter and other staff werebfriendly and helpful, etc
The food was delicious as usual. They kindly accommodated our requests and catered to us as royalty. This is why we regularly have Matteo's on our regular dining list. They keep the music at a level so even people sitting across from you can hear, since the point of the evening is fine food, wine and conversation. We easily met all our goals tonight and look forward to our next visit.
Very tasty dishes and quality service. Can't wait to go back.
We were disappointed that they stopped serving the restaurant week menu at 7pm. The food and cocktails were delicious!
Very mediocre experience. The food was delicious, but other than that I was not impressed. It took a half hour to order and receive our drinks ( which was a bottle of wine), and our server was not accommodating when we asked for recommendations on the menu. I do not think I will return to Matteos of Roslyn.
Great food great service, really nice portions for restaurant week!
The Matteo’s restaurant week menu was great value; awesome selection and portions ! The restaurant is beautiful itself. The service was a little slow; not sure if it was due to the busyness of restaurant week but it felt like a lot of time has passed between each time the waitress checked our table even though she was very sweet. We were there from 7:10 - 9:30. Overall, would add this to a list of staple places to dine. Food was delicious
Food was incredible! Definitely recommend!
Groupon made the meal a great bargain. Food was good. Service good. Price excellent.
Second time at the restaurant. Was sat at table at end of bar. Service subpar. Was served by bar staff who were unable to wait table effectively because
First time dining at this location. Service and food wee impeccable. Looking forward to dining here in the near future with friends and family
Been to Matteo's many times. Had my daughter's reversal dinner there. We have recommended it to several friends and family.
We tried many different dishes and haven't been dissatisfied, everything was delicious.
We've been impressed with the service as well, sooo it's become our favorite local restaurant .
We had a ball! Our waiter Brian was fantastic and Vanessa the bartender was too. We went on a Saturday night and the place was crowded and they never rushed us. I would definitely recommend this place.
The waiter was awful. Granted we were taking a long time to order, but the customer is ALWAYS right. He was rolling his eyes and making faces. He was very controversial and seemed like he couldn’t be bothered. The food was fine, but not as good as usual. The salad did not have the same flavor as it usually does. The main meals were fine.
The chef came to our rescue in the end.
It will be a while before we venture back there.
So I ate at roslyn location after I ate Huntington. The Roslyn location is authentic and original and everything was phenomenal. Huntington is definitely a little nicer but the service was not as fine-tuned as the Roslyn location. The Roslyn location also had some great specials which we did not find at the Huntington location. I think the Roslyn location should put in a pizza oven like Huntington that was definitely a nice touch and just for someone eating at the bar it’s a great idea. Overall our experience at the Roslyn location was great and will continue to go back. We will probably give the Huntington location some time to work out there kinks with the service mostly.
Found this gem on radio 102.7 contest. I did not win but still came. All the classics done well and professional and attentive service! Prices were cheap for all that food! Mike the Chef/boss was very accommodating and help us meet our dietary restrictions. Sophie was a sweetheart. Will continue to return !
First visit at this Matteo location. Looking forward to going again with friends and family
Loved every moment here. Great service! Best Italian food. Keyboard player on Thursday night a great touch!
Classic, northern Italian. Huge portions. Family style. Diverse, vast menu.
Awesome dinner, great service, very nice decor, will go back again and again!
This is hands-down the best Italian restaurant in Long Island! We have been coming here for years and the food is always spot on! Some copycats opened up down the block called 388 and the food and service is subpar. There is absolutely no connection which people think. There is only one original and we are loyal to Mateo‘s. If you are in the area and looking for a great dinner with great service in a really beautiful setting this is the place to go. We will be back next week for another great meal!
Matteos was excellent. It was a 2 hour drive I would do again. Our service was phenomenal top notch! Make sure you go hungry! We called all our friends who go down the Island and told them it is a must to stop and eat here! Only 2 blocks of L.I.E. Everything is homemade and the price was fantastic.
consistent in service, quality and ambience - a good neighborhood restaurant
Really good. Only ding were overdressed salads. On the side next time. Their take on a cannoli was different and yummy!
This was our first visit to this restaurant. It is a typical Roslyn area restaurant which some may consider this discription a prejoritive. Perhaps. The menu is large with many traditional Italian dishes and some specials. The dishes are offered in two portions regular and family size. We found our dishes nicely prepared but lacked any exceptionalism . We had early reservations and by the time we were ready to leave the restaurant became quite crowded and noisy. I would give the place another try but not on a Saturday night
This was my second time at this restaurant the ambiance was jus amazing. This is my children and I favorite Italian Restaurant. Food was so delicious. Service was impeccable. I recommend this to everyone.
Good food, attentive staff. Piano player on Thursday evenings.