Matteo's of Roslyn
We had an Amazzing time! It was My first time being there and loved Every Minute
Thank You! 😊
Delicious food, great service and very generous portions! Will definitely go back!!
This was my first time at Matteo's and I was very pleased. The place is beautiful. Our waiter, Brian was exceptional! The food & drinks were delicious! I will definitely come back!
I have eaten there at 8 or 9 times in the past this was the first time I was disappointed we were a table of 6 ,we had to ask for bread 3 times , we know it family style and the waitress gave each person portions of the three appetizers that we ordered ,unfortunately one person was allergic to the shellfish that she served her ,so she couldn't eat the food on her dish and there was other people at the table that chose not to eat certain things we had , my recommendation would be to ask the customer which appetizers they would be having before they assume the person wants all of the above ,also we shared a desert the brownie 3 spoons with no dishes and last thing my pasta I had the nonno ragu the pasta should be mixed with the sauce not just on the top of the pasta ,rigatoni is suppose to have sauce on the inside of the pasta not just on the exterior
Its a beautiful restaurant service is great , food it really good and the plates are larger enough to share
Went for prix fix menu with hubby and I had I had stuffed mushrooms for my appetizer. They were soggy and tasteless, I then had the chicken francaise as my entrée and was very very disappointed. The only thing on the plate was 2 pieces of chicken, I didn't get any thing on the side no vegetable rice or potato. Nothing!!!! I even asked the waiter and was told that it didn't come with anything. It did not feel like I had a complete dinner. I used to love Matteo's and would take my friends there because it was one of my favorite restaurants. Never again!!
good value; nice décor, good service and food is good - neighborhood find
Went to Matteo’s for my Dad’s 80th Birthday. We had a party of 12. We ordered appetizers and pasta family style and were able to share some entrees as well. Everything was delicious and the service was very attentive. A good time was had by all!
food was very good as was the service and the ambiance.
Great on Sunday nights when they sometimes offer the LI Restaurant week menu even though it has past
Got an email that they were offering a $28.00 dinner Sunday thru Thursday. When we. Were seated they gave us the regular menu, and were then handed a menu which was from Long Island restaurant week which ended weeks ago for $29.95. The menu was nice and the food just ok. My husband is a big fan of linguine with clam sauce. It was really awful.( bland). He even requested additional garlic. Do not think we will be returning.
Great family style restaurant in a wonderful atmosphere at a good price. I was pleasantly surprised and will definitely go back.
Great food, huge portions, very noisy, even in corner table
One of the best Italian restaurants on Long Island. Great service unpretentious Italian. My wife’s from Italy and her standards are high- no other Italian restaurant in NY has meet her standards!!!
We have been a frequent guest there. Love the Ambiance ( semi formal to formal), food- Love their Burrata Chicken dishes as well as Vegetarian options
Friendly staff and comfortable seating makes it worth going back to
This was our first visit to Matteo's of Roslyn It deserves a rating of 5 stars. We will return with friends.
Best food, best staff, best ambiance.......our go to favorite place!!!
The food was amazing, the service was amazing, the restaurant has a beautiful ambiance.
We do not live in the area and saw that Matteo's was highly rated on OpenTable. Matteo's did not disappoint! The food was excellent. Our server Neil was attentive. I enjoyed the Caesar salad was perfectly dressed and the red snapper cooked to perfection.
Terrific neighborhood restaurant — consistently delicious food and good service. Will continue to dine there.
Couldn't if gotten a better table right in front of the gas fireplace. The waiter was attentive and our food was excellent. Come hungry as the portions are large.
e service was excellent, the food choices for appertizers, the main course and desert were varied and extensive. The wine list was also extensive.
The food was awful!
The bad because it’s a very nice atmosphere.
We definitely will not go back
Great food! Service friendly and did not rush you !
Matteo's of Roslyn is our "go to" restaurant. Food is outstanding, the portions are enormous, service can't be beat and staff is super friendly and efficient. Went for restaurant week and the menu is bigger than any other restaurant I've been to during this type of week. Go and you won't be disappointed!!!
Overall a good place for food and service. Our food was very tasty but should have been hot not warm. Place is all ways packed. Nice big bar and nice wine list.
it's always good, good service, pretty place and great bread, yummy
We’ve been to Mateos so many times, I can longer recall. The food is delicious, and we always order more than we can eat. We end up taking a couple of dishes home. Busy Saturday evening crowd, very loud. We were six and it was tough to talk across the round table. Really, we did not care. Fun evening with our friends. Highly recommend Mateos! 🥂👍😎👌+++++
Great food. Great ambiance & service. Will definitely be going back.
Excellent! I've been going here for years. Can't beat the food or the service. Never had a bad meal!
Always excellent. We tried the special that day of chicken pizziola....it was terrific. On Thursday there is a piano player who is very good. Portions come in various sizes and take home can provide another meal..
outstanding new years eve dinner with my family, would strongly recommend
went there for dinner on a SUNDAY night had a reservation got seated right way , had appetizer's and dinner , the pork chop special was delicious . they didn't have the fire places lit , would have been a nicer atmosphere . definitely will be back ,
The food and service were good but the noise level was unacceptably high. It was a strain to converse with the person opposite me, 3 feet away!
Matteo’s handled our party of 12 with superb service! Everyone loved the food and we could carry on a conversation without having to yell at one another or ask anyone to repeat themselves. So glad we decided to celebrate a birthday here!
We are never disappointed with the food or service at Matteos. I usually have a hard time enjoying my meal at restaurants since I'm the only gluten free member of the family. Matteos pleases all of us, and their gluten free options are not lacking in taste, texture and variety.
Came here for the first time for Christmas Day Dinner. We were pleasantly surprised. Great menu, good service, and delicious food.
We had a wonderful Christmas lunch at Matteo’s. Everything was delicious!
Food was good service was terrible the young manager seemed to have attitude who had to wait on us not happily seems they were short staffed but no attention...will stick to 388