Matteo's of Roslyn
The food never fails, always a hit with the family. Service was great.
Corn/avocado salad was excellent. Bread and butter tasted defrosted. Eggplant parm, veal scallopini and branzino were fair. Waiter was great and all special requests (ex. no salt) were followed through. The noise level was Extremely loud. We won’t go back for awhile. P.S. We took out last year and the food was horrible, including the usually excellent corn/avocado salad.
Matteos is always great food. It’s a bit loud on Saturday evenings and can be quite a scene. It never disappoints though
Hello, Food snob here! This food is amazing. Seems to get better and better each time we go. Keep it up!
Love love love this restaurant! The service was impeccable, the ambiance was lovely and the food was fresh and delicious! Will definitely return and I highly recommend!!
Beautiful restaurant, great service and amazing food. Will definitely return.
The service was outstanding and the food is good.
Always a great meal. Never disappoints
Staff goes above and beyond
food was a bit salty especially entree. Veal valdostana was not a veal voldastana
Some dishes were A bit too salty
But overall it was great
The portions are very large and are served family style.
The food is very good. But what keeps us going back to this restaurant is how it is managed. Bryan the restaurant manager does everything in his power to make sure you have a fantastic dinner and great experience from beginning to end. Also very impressed on how he remembers every customer name and favorite choice of foods and beverage.
Matteo's always has Delicious food, and great service.
Matteo's of Roslyn is a beautiful delicious Italian restaurant. Orders can be either full or half depending on the size of your party. the baked clams are amazing....service is top notch....
Second time here and loved it as much as the first time! Great people, food, and perfect ambience.
Great food, very large portions in a nice atmosphere.
Our favorite restaurant! Food and service is the best!
Great food ! 5 stars Or server was awesome also !
We definitely will be back !
Fantastic evening in every way! The food and service were impeccable.
We really enjoyed our dining experience. The waiter was excellent and the food was delicious.
Disappointing. Not terrible, but there are so many restaurants that I would recommend for good Italian before this one. Zucchini Fritti and Baked Clams were good but it was underwhelming after that. Amatriciana I can make ten times better at home and the chicken ultimo was also nothing to get excited about. One more comment on the calamari fritti = not so good. Not at all. Go to La Ginestra for the best calama on the island.
Final note on the service - which was great. Although I went early on a Saturday and it wasn’t a heavy lift for the server at that point as there were only a handful of tables, still I appreciate the attentiveness and likability.
This is a great restaurant to celebrate a special occasion. Great for large parties because of the family style service. Our waitress was awesome - Attentive, friendly and knowledgeable. Food was incredible except for stead which was a little bland. Definitely recommend the chicken Matteo and Ref Snapper!!
This place uses to be good back in the day but now average at best. Salad was limp and wet , linguine with white clam sauce not the amazing version you can get at others like la Parma and Don Pepe. Pasta was over cooked and tasteless
The baked clams were good. Chicken scarparelli was pretty good .
Overall kinda disappointing wouldn’t go back.
LOVE THE FOOD, ONE OF THE BEST ITALIAN WE TRIED, WENT WITH FAMILY, YOUNG KIDS AND TEENS EVERYONE HAD SOMTHING THEY LIKED.
Exceptional family style Italian food, with generous and well delicious portions
The service and food was really good. Highly recommend for dinner or special occasion.
Service and food were perfect.
Delicious food and great service.
Always a consistent great meal with outstanding service!
Delicious food, friendly service and nice atmosphere
The food & service is consistently very good. When you know how much to order from the menu, the food is plentiful.
This restaurant was outstanding. The only reason I gave I did not give it all 5 stars was because they offered no vegan options.
Very nice restaurant consistent good food
The veal chop dish was nicely done. My only criticism would be the concept of “burnt broccoli” as it was barely edible. I mean it was slightly cooked but super char-burnt. Maybe conventional broccoli sautéed in garlic and oil would be more of a crowd pleaser.
Small portions, food presentation terrible. New waiter acted as bartender also. No knowledge of wines. Service was ok but plates cleared too fast. Felt like they were rushing you out. Very noisy hard to have conversation at our table of 3. Felt like an expensive cafeteria. Parking difficult.
Restaurant week. Good selection.
First time for our party of 6.
The food was delicious and our server was very attentive!
Best Italian restaurant I’ve been to thus far
Always a great meal with great service
You can order delivery directly from Matteo's of Roslyn using the Order Online button.
Matteo's of Roslyn is rated 4.7 stars by 628 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.