Matteo's of Roslyn

food was very good service was excellent noise level was moderate wen we're their on a wednesday evening

Amazing service and food! Table was a little tight and they’re fairly big so my husband was a little too far away 😕 we usually sit next to eat other. The food was excellent though and dessert was soooo good.

Went during LI restaurant week. It was difficult to carry a conversation because we were seated next to a large party. Service was a little uneven: we waited 45 minutes for an appetizers, main course came immediately as appetizer plates were cleared. Overall pleasant meal in pleasant restaurant.

Very good service - food was good but the Chicken Scarpiello was on the thin side - more bone then meat. Chicken Marsala was excellent as was the tiramisu.

Excellent food and service.

It was wonderful!

Always a favorite with family or friends. Full and half portions are available. We enjoy family style and order Matteo’s large salad, 2 full mains and a large pasta which feeds 4 with leftovers.
Extra nice touch of waiter serving the portions from the large mains. Chicken parm a husband favorite ( who doesn’t love mozzarella cheese?- our comfort food) bring the grandkids- they all eat pasta. Shrimp oreganata, chicken scaparella , penne a la vodka all family favs. A tartufo cut in 4 is perfect when you want a taste for dessert. Other desserts delicious.
Look for that discount coupon in local papers! Great even with no discount!

My husband and I came here for a Date night during restaurant week and I have to say the service and food was excellent. We will definitely be coming back to dine here!!

Our "go to" place for great food and wonderful staff. Never disappointed.

the chicken Matteo was great just the way we like it and the salad was really good as well plenty food for the 4 of us we even had left overs for the next day . The waiter was very good as well

Excellent experience

Excellent food & Service...I loved the meals we had but way to much food.. Not complaining, Had them for lunch the next day! Yum!!!!!

Wonderful traditional Italian food with options for gourmand palates, served in an elegant, but comfortable setting. Friendly, accommodating staff. Welcoming bar seating available.

Never disappoints. Food selections, portions and service all outstanding. Can’t go wrong with anything on or off the menu.

Excellent service. Our waitress was terrific. (Samantha, I think). The food was wonderful as usual.

Food was very good. Lobster ravioli was excellent. The fish portion my girlfriend ordered was very small. Brian, our server immediately said he'd bring more and he did. He was very personable and made it easy for us.

Our usual Italian spot down the street. Excellent red sauce place. Great w kids.

The food is amazing as always and Brian is the best host and Manager and Waiter are on the planet

Dinner is always delicious ! Have been there quite a few times. Always very enjoyable.

Food is incredible always have a great meal wait staff very attentive definitely one of our favorite restaurants

Delicious food. Terrific service.

Excellent family style Italian food. Good service with attentive staff, well versed in how much food to order and they do the serving as well.

Seated on time, water refilled without asking, food delivered as ordered, 2 pens with the 2 credit cards. 4 pet peeves were all taken care of!! Very good experience at dinner at Matteo's last Saturday night. The only complaint was the waiter was too busy to serve the family style salad. 4 happy patrons. We will be back!

From the moment you walk into this fine dining establishment you are greeted by friendly, hospitable hostesses. The food is exceptional as is the service. Our waiters name was Justin - he was very friendly, knowledgeable, attentive and professional . May I add - it was Justin's SECOND night working at the restaurant! Way to go Justin! Thank you for making our dining experience one to remember! I have eaten there numerous times before and will continue to patronize this exceptional restaurant!

We were a party of 8....chopped salad was the only dish we enjoyed. Mussels smelled awful and were very dried pieces of something in a shell. We sent that dish back. Orders of Chicken Parm and Chicken Marsala were also overcooked and very salty. The worst was the Pasta Bolognese which was so salty our mouths puckered when we tasted it. That dish was also sent back. The kitchen staff & wait staff tend to cluster around the kitchen area so maybe nobody is really caring about the food and service.

The servers were knowledgeable of the food and very friendly. We never had to ask for refills and the food was all served equally.

Great time all around.

The food at Matteo’s is consistently great! Their servers were attentive to our table of 10. However the party of 30 that was arranged right next to our table truly spoiled our evening. I would make sure not to be seated in the back room.

First time at Matteos. Loved the food,service, and ambiance of the restaurant. Being a vegetarian they were very accommodating and took good care of our needs. Service was excellent. Would go there again and highly recommend this restaurant. Great neighborhood gem.

I enjoyed Saturday night family dinner at Matteo's of Roslyn. The food was delicious and the service was good. The chef came to our table to ensure the food and service was good. The wait staff was on top of things, attentive to our requests and very friendly. They got the high chairs prepared for us and kept the water glass consistently filled. The wait staff was helpful in dividing up our portions and serving us.

Very good food, ample quantity and very tasty. Family style serving, need to take that into consideration especially when only two are dining. Wish we skipped the appetizer to save room for the main course, although the app was a special and very delicious.

Food is excellent never disappoints We shared the pasta Bolognese and the veal chop Milanese
can't wait to go back

Another Great meal

Loved the food. Singer was great

Delicious as always, thank you!

Great waiter. Kitchen a bit slow. Salad took 20 minutes to come. Food was delicious though didn’t love the pasta bologese (I think it was called Nonna’s pasta) as short rib was tough

Food was very good and Brian our waiter was great.

My husband and I liked Matteo’s very much. It was our first time and found the ambiance and food to our liking. Service was fine except we would’ve liked if our waiter would’ve explain the various pricing on the dishes. He failed to do that so we asked after we had already placed the order. Also, parking can be an issue, although they offer valet parking. Other than that, we were pleased with our visit and would consider returning again.

A lot of food but expensive

Great service and meal was amazing!

Great food, wonderful service, great location, thank goodness for the valets