Matteo's is NOW open for inside dining...We were extremely comfortable and safely taken care of...The staff wore masks and gloves and tore up the menus after our ordering dinner.
Very safe and social distancing was adhered to too.

Repas visite familiale

Noise level extremely loud and it was so frenetic ferling

Second visit. Waiter too busy. Had to request menus as no one brought them when we were seated. He could not understand our order despite repetition We Consistently had to wave to get service. Another example, ordered the full eggplant lasagna Charged us $58! Had to seek out another server to get dessert menus. Not likely to return despite the food quality, which is very good.

We had a wonderful dinner outside with family including a 4 year old great service great food

The food is the best. It's the best every time we are there.

Excellent. We drive a hour to get there and it is so worth it.

Excellent food, great service, good value. Best for groups. Would definitely go again.

Excellant food great service. Shrimp and calamari dishes were perfect. We will be back

Very disappointed in the fact that we had my mom's 90th birthday at Matteo's. I called in the a.m of our reservation and spoke to a young lady who made such a big deal that confetti would be on the table. We got there no confetti. Didn't really pay attention to the detail. Everything else was very good. The little things are important on a day like this.

Thank you.

Lauren Reilly

Excellent food and family style for sharing. We have had bad servers here in the past but this time we had a female server that truly was super attentive and made everyone else seem bad. Great experience.

Food was good but extremely loud.

Excellent service, warm and welcoming staff from entrance to exit. Could not expect better service, food quantity or quality!

Seated at 6:40 pm, reservation 6 pm, kind manager finally sat us. Loved the orders, but waiter tried to rush.

Wonderful service, fabulous food- best bread and butter anywhere, lovely singer for romantic ambiance. We went for a birthday dinner and they make you feel so special. Sprinkled happy birthday and celebratory sparkles on the table, for dessert they sang and brought out a huge sparkler. Such a special evening. We would go again and again!

Everything is made fresh including the pasta great service and you never leave there hungry

Always a great meal at Matteo's. Food is consistent, service is attentive never rushed and they make an extra effort for a birthday.

Peter is the best !

The restaurant was packed with huge parties. We couldn’t get our table so decided to eat at the bar. Only two bartenders for the entire restaurant. Our dinner chicken Matteo was not very good. Chicken was very dry overcooked. We also had linguini with clam sauce the sauce was watery and had no flavor. We have eaten here before and loved it. Last night they were off their game and it was very disappointing.

Some dishes were really outstanding - baked clams and our shrimp dish, and some were good like the linguini with clam sauce, and some were just okay - bolognese and veal marsala. It was an expensive meal and I'd say the quality was not consistent. We sat outside because it was so very noisy inside.

Excellent food and service. Could not have been better.

Good food. Our waiter was very good. The restaurant is loud and the tables are very close together making it very hard for the service teams to maneuver. We were having a lovely meal but as some in our party finished, and some were STILL eating, the bus staff was cleaning around us and motioning for US to pass our plates TO THEM so that they could clean up. She was also leaning over my daughter with a stack of dirty plates, while waving for us to pass our take home dishes so she could carry it all at the same time. I’m not sure we would go back. I found this service appalling and like they were rushing you out the door. I am all for efficient service but this was not that.

Amazing food. Great service!!

Food was fabulous. Service was poor. We have been here before and had fantastic service in the past. The waiter took our order and we didn’t see him again until the end of the meal. That was too late to get the proper cutting utensils or anything else we may have wanted during the meal. It was disappointing.
Great food at a restaurant is important but so is the service and it should be consistent.

Terrible service food was fair

Service was extremely poor !
Meals never arrived

We love to visit there when in town!

We had great food and phenomenal service .. our waitress was outstanding

Great food and atmosphere Waiter was great Valet parking is very easy

I have eaten here 100’s of times. It’s the best, always!

We enjoyed our dinner and the service was wonderful . The portions are extremely large

Great food great service. Sat outside & enjoyed. Waitress was very good.

An old favorite restaurant from New York that never disappoints! The food, staff and ambience keep bringing us back.

We were invisible. Service was lacking and unattentive. Too bad such good food and such poor service

Excellent food, service and new décor makes this like a brand new Mateo's. We counted 7 Birthday celebrations, with wine and laughter. A little loud at times, keep drinking, after awhile you don't notice it !
A great evening ! Mussels in Pomodoro sauce.... EXCELLENT ! Branzino, Terrific ! Add a salad and Pasta ! A perfect meal.

great staff, Brian's the best, left full as could be
Great food, what more can i say.

My daughters bday

The food is delicious! Family sharing platters that hit the spot. We enjoyed the ambiance. The servers was extremely courteous. We enjoyed our dining experience.

Food and wine was good, service a bit slow but good friends have lots to talk about

God used to be much better. Artichoke was tasteless, Big clams not up to par, pork chops had an iodine a taste. Very disappointing.