Mason Street Grill
Check out our current counter menu at: http://www.masonstreetgrill.com/specials-and-events/chefs-counter
We love to celebrate special occasions and our private dining rooms are just the right size for business meetings and social gatherings. Let us make something special for you.
Come in and make yourself comfortable. We’ll take care of the rest!
Book your next event with us
We had a wonderful time at the Mason Street Grill! Our server, Heather, was attentive and helpful for the entire meal. We enjoyed their Sunday Night Dinner which consisted of 3 courses. The salad had a delicious horseradish-type dressing and the butternut squash soup was enlivened with a hint of curry. The steaks were cooked to perfection. Finally, their carrot cake and chocolate cake offerings for desert were a perfect ending. This superb meal was complimented by the decor. The Pfister Hotel has a unique reputation as a haunted hotel. You could definitely feel an eerie vibe throughout the building. We had a perfectly wonderful evening.
Great food and service! Highly recommend!
We come for dinner about every 2 months and have always had a great experience. This past Sun. was no exception. Our server was Dan, who was oustanding!! We have recommended the restaurant to friends/family and have brought some with on past occasions.
Family get together....we had a great evening. Elizabeth was fabulous and we absolutely love her. Thank you!!
Thank you to Grady and Steve for making my son's 19th birthday special.
My first visit was awesome. I enjoyed every thing from the drinks, food and the service. It was my b'day outing and the chocolate mousse n fruit was very tantalizing, the server brought it out and it was so elegantly served to me. I will definitely be going back.
Great experience, wonderful staff and very attentive. Went for a business lunch and will be back.
I've been to Mason Street Grill about a half dozen times this year, and it has been great each time. The menu is not adventurous, but has a nice variety of all-American choices. I usually have meat dishes, and always share the trio of sides. On this particular night I had the bone-in strip, which I liked much better than the too-marbled bone-in ribeye on my last visit. Service was excellent as always--friendly, knowledgeable and prompt. My wife loves the carrot cake
Great food. Great service. Loved the atmosphere. And our waitress Alexa was amazing.
Great service, exceptional food, and our waitress was great. Overall great place to done, will definitely be coming back.
I had asked for the corner on the counter and for exactly what I wanted. Our server was Lydia and she made the dinner even better than it was. There were four of us and she split salads in half and provided separate plates. The food was absolutely wonderful and two of the managers stopped to check on us as well. Two of us had Halibut, one person had ribs and one was not as hungry so she had crab cakes. Our plates were clean.
During dinner I mentioned it was our anniversary in two days and she brought our one dessert that we ordered split in 4’s. It was a wonderful meal.
My husband and I enjoyed an evening of appetizers. The fried clams were delicious, they came out hot and not chewy! I love that their Caesar salad has anchovies, you don’t often find that anymore. I wish I could remember our waitresses name, She was excellent! Attentive with out being intrusive.
Celebrating our anniversary
Our server, Richard, was great as always. The Steakhouse salad is my regular go to.
Great food but waited way too long for food to arrive after ordering.
My wife and I had a terrific experience. Our waiter (John) was superb, very attentive and gave us wonderful wine and food recommendations. I highly recommend the rib-eye steak, one of their signatures dishes.
Mason Street Grill, what happened?
You where my favorite and I always strongly recommended you, but this time it was much different.
The server while polite was not attentive to us and our needs, having not checked back with us after ordering and only once more after the food arrived.
The Mason Street Chop salad always awesome in the past, had way too much dressing and a lot of wilted lettuce?
I ordered my Filet as always with no sauce and well... it was slightly better than average and was cooked a lot closer to well done than medium as I asked, your little butter or oil rub was also missing?
We looked forward to some of what I call the best caramelized brussel sprouts in the world (I know you don't always have them) and what we received was some flash steamed and cooked spouts that where hard and not tasty at all, much less never caramelized ?
The beer was cold and the wine very good, however for my $200 I felt sadly disappointed.
I love the feel of this place. Food was very good. The only reason for 4 stars instead of 5 for food was our asparagus was over salted. Steak was perfect!
Great steak house with classic cocktails. Steaks were well cooked, well seasoned, and well portioned. Service was great and the venue was inviting. Will definitely return. Maybe next time I'll grab a seat in the bar and listen to the live music.
The food and the service the ambience the evening all spectacular
Great service and amazing cake for my birthday.
Everything was perfect. The whole experience was wonderful. The server was great. I loved the food.
Excellent as usual. The waitstaff is so well-trained and professional. My petite fillet was perfect.
Service was outstanding. Water and French fries were top shelf. Cutlery got the job done. Nothing else to add
This place never disappoints. It isn’t cheap but I always feel like I get my money’s worth. It has become a family treat for our family. Steaks always cooked perfectly. Service typically has some great recommendations on compliments, sides and apps. Wine selection one of the best in MKE.
Though the service and plate presentations were very nice, the 4 seafood options that we ordered were all overcooked. $40 for 3 medium scallops on succotash was outrageous. Desserts were mediocre. We won't be back.
The manager and our waitress were awesome. I can’t wait to go back.
Birthday for my next dirt neighbor’s Mom. Food and service was excellent as ALWAYS!!! My favorite steakhouse in Milwaukee.
Terrific food and service
Great for a romantic evening
Great food and service. My wife and I strongly recommend.
Wonderful food great service
Very expensive meal - but terrific quality and excellent service.
Outside dining was very noisy.
Love everything about this place.
We were celebrating our 40th anniversary that night. We each had the grill salad and a crab cake while sharing a bottle of J chardonnay. Our waitress was friendly and knowledgeable. They surprised us with a celebratory dessert.
The only problem was the fruit fly in my glass of wine which I had at the bar. When my guests arrived we ordered a bottle of wine which solved the problem
The wings were amazing. I would go back just for them. The bone in dry aged ribeye was good. We got it topped with the bleu cheese “crust.” It was good, but definitely way too much. The steak was drowning in it and almost completely masked the amazing dry aged flavor. I just wish we would have got it on the side. Asparagus was ok. Nothing fancy at all and almost too salty to eat. We aren’t from the area, so we would probably try a different restaurant if we were back in town. Definitely would go back if we lived in the area.
Grady was a wonderful server. We were celebrating a special occasion and he made mention of it right away. I have never eaten an entire steak before this evening. The steak melted in my mouth. We will certainly be coming back here for another wonderful evening.
Excellent place to take your significant other. Loved the outside dining
Exceptional and attentive server Everyone from the valet person to the gentleman that pours the water were extremely helpful, friendly, and respectful. We had a great night.