Mario's - Staten Island
Restaurants you may also like
The Stone House at Clove Lakes - NY
Lorenzo's Restaurant, Bar & Caberet - Hilton Garden Inn - SI
A La Carte & Family-Style Dining. 2 parking lots. Elevator, Full bar. Second floor catering room, La Collina. Take out / Delivery.
We dine at Mario's once a week, and are always quite satisfied. Great pasta dishes, wild salmon, salads, soups, and Lombardo pizza.
We are huge fans of Mario, Carlos, and Christina.
This place was outstanding!! Food and service are top notch.
This restaurant was great! So many healthy and gluten free options which were easily noted on the menu! Loved it. Good portions. Nice quiet ambiance. Will be back!
Excellent food and service! Carlos is amazing waiter. Makes our night out always pleasurable. The place is very warm and comfortable. Great for family events and dinners. One of the best Italian places on the Island.
Took my wife here for our 20th anniversary and it was also near the painting class I booked. The food was amazing from appetizer to the delish deserts. I would definitely come back again staff where wonderful. Thank you for making my anniversary dinner special
Delicious meals. Comfortable seating. Beautiful atmosphere. Excellent wait staff.
The Branzino was fresh and so delicious. My nephew loved the crispy pizza and the meatballs over polenta. The meatballs were flavorful and softly perfect. And a great martini. My new favorite Staten Island restaurant.
We enjoyed another nice evening at Mario's. A Sunday evening in August was a lot quieter than our previous visits, but there was a nice crowd. The service is great, always willing to help, and our meals were delicious. Hope they have enjoy paint and eat dinner soon.
Family style menu not worth by price by quality and quantity
Service was great
Service was attentive and friendly. There was one error with our order. We ordered two appetizers and they forgot one. We split the other one and had enough to eat with the entrees, so we told them to forget about the appetizer. We asked them to remove it from the bill, which they did. The entrees were very tasty and the ambiance was very pleasant, although we would have preferred the noise level a little lower to facilitate conversation. However, we were there at peak dinner time, so I suppose it is to be expected. Overall, as in the past, we were very pleased and will continue to patronize Mario's Restaurant.
Great restaurant out of this world food. Excellent service upscaled Italian love this place look forward to going again. Thank you Mario for making my first year anniversary a memorable one!
Enjoy the new family style menu and vegetarian options. Special watermelon feta salad was great.
Excellent food! Great ambiance.
Excellent place!! All around fantastic!
By far our favorite restaurant on the Island! The food is always incredible and the service is even better! Carlos is the absolute best waiter & we request him every time!
Delicious fresh food and excellent service. Try it. You won’t be disappointed.
What a wonderful evening! Had never been to Mario's, but will surely return. We had the cast iron eggplant appetizer. It was delicious. The tomato sauce was amazing! House salad had tasty dressing and the shrimp I added was a nice treat. Pasta was great, as was the pizza. Service was impeccable, as the staff came to change utensils at each course and all were extremely friendly and seemed to really care about our satisfaction! Love this place!
Great guy, great food, great service.
Will keep returning
Very lovely establishment. Friendly staff and pretty décor. Food was authentic and fresh. Would return and also recommend !
Love the food!!!!!
The food was well seasoned and balanced. Often Italian restaurants are a little heavy handed with the garlic, oregano and spices but Mario's has it down to perfection. I would definitely recommend this restaurant. We ordered the seafood dish, salmon, eggplant Parmesan & chicken Marsala and we were all extremely happy with our meals. For desert we ordered the chocolate profiteroles with hot bananas and it was perfection.
As usual, the food was excellent. Our food came out pipping hot and quickly too. Try their calamari. It was delicious. The menu has changed due to the fact that Mario'a now has serves family style.
Luncheon special is a great deal. Choice of any salad or soup, choice of pizza , any sandwich or penne vodka sauce, and coffee And delicious zeppole for dessert. Service as always was perfect. Carlos is a very good waiter. We were able to sit and talk without being rushed out.
Four of us went to Mario’s for dinner on a Tuesday evening. We enjoyed every aspect of the experience and are looking forward to dining there again soon.
Great as always! Celebrated a birthday with 11 ppl and all around everything was superb! Thanks to Chef Mario and his staff for a wonderful dining experience...
Delicious food as always and and great choices.
Mario's has a very good choice of foods and service is very good.
From the available parking on the roof of this establishment (no street parking)to the friendly wait staff and amazing food (including lots of Gluten free options), this place has become one of my favorites so far in Staten Island.
Good service. Food consistently good.
So great to have something new on Staten Island. Food service drinks. It was all great Mario’s has become a new favorite for us! Give them a try you won’t be disappointed
They have updated the menu to include family style dinner with beer and wine. This provides a great value if you want a lot of food and drink
Highly recommend! Food is amazing and service is excellent!!
I booked on open table, but when I got there they didn't have our reservation. They sat us in bar area which was better than nothing, but the wait for food was really long. Food was very good..but would have preferred to be seated in dining area. It was Saturday night, so guess it's a very popular night. Will try again in a weeknight.
Excellent service from Rob. Lamb chops received raves as did the seafood Orreganato and the branzino. Have never had a bad meal here.
We ordered from the family style menu, the food was delicious and there was plenty of food to take home!! We will be back to try a different family style menu!
They should have a private room for parties bigger than 12
We have eaten here a number of times. We have never been disappointed. The warm beet salad that we shared was plentiful, fresh tasting and delicious. My seafood oreganato was a huge success. Shrimp,clams and calamari prepared with toasted bread crumbs. Excellent. My husband had the broiled branzino in a delicious sauce. Not a single complaint.
Always a pleasure to dine at Marios. The cocktails are great, the food is delicious and the restaurant staff is always welcoming & friendly. We enjoy talking to Carlos and look forward to our next visit. Tommy & Sue
Mario's was incredible! My family and I went for my mom's birthday and did the family style option. Great price for a delicious and filling meal, especially if you like to have a cocktail! They were very accommodating to my open table reservation, asking to put us at a round table. We sat on the corner at a round table able to enjoy conversation and the coziness of the restaurant!
As an appetizer, I had small stuffed artichokes. Delicious and different. The warmed beet salad was huge and tasty. I had the duck special. Highly recommend this if available. The bronzino with a delicate sauce was excellent. Too full for dessert. Maybe next time.
Mario's - Staten Island offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (718) 979-1075.
Mario's - Staten Island is rated 4.5 stars by 165 OpenTable diners.