Another fantastic meal at Mama’s
A five star experience! Great ambiance, staff, and food. A new favorite for us both!
They placed us right next to a large group with small children who were basically playing next to our table; plenty of other empty tables nearby that were empty. I guess we should have asked to be moved, but still, think they should have known. Service was slow and forgot to get us drinks several times. I got the steak that was overcooked. Food was just ok for the price you are paying. I would not recommend.
Lives up to the reputation! I rarely give 5 starts but this one is truly a 5-star restaurant. Very pricey but the food is exquisite!
One of the finest dining experiences I’ve ever had. Service was outstanding, location is amazing and food was unreal.
While I loved the environment and the service, I unfortunately did not see the value in the price. I had the stuffed Mahi-mahi and my husband had a different fish that was very bland for his taste. The stuffed mahi-mahi was pretty good when I drenched it in the surrounding sauce. His complaint was mostly the lack of flavor in the fish and uncooked vegetables. We also ordered a drink, which was unflavorful for all the fruit it claimed to have and not worth the price. We came here on our last meal of our trip as a treat and honestly preferred other restaurants around the island.
Amazing service and food!!
52 wedding anniversary. Service was excellent, there was even a place card in table wishing us a happy anniversary with our names, that set the tone for the evening. The manager came to table to greet us. The food and appetizers was so good. Such a wonderful evening spent at Mama’s. Loved it!
Great food, great service.
Fantastic! ! I was so pleased to find you still open as I haven't been back to Maui in over a decade.
The food is exceptional, the view spectacular....truly one of the most beautiful places in the world!
Get a table in front for the view get there early to enjoy the bar and walk the grounds
Exemplary service, wonderful food, beautiful views, great ambience. Our server was incredibly professional, and could not have been kinder and more accommodating about my food allergies. The pacing of the meal was flawless, the drinks were great, the fish we had was sublime. All of this comes at a price (this is a big-ticket meal!), but for special occasion dining and celebration of any kind, it felt worth the price! Hope to return to Mama's when my bank account permits!
FABULOUS experience. Food, service (Rodney), ambience, view...excellent! Very pricey but worth every cent. Owner greeted us at our table. Waterfront!!
Mama’s has become the highlight of our recent trips to Maui. It is one of my favorite restaurants in the world. Try it. You will fall in love!
Amazing experience. The food was delicious, service was great, and the feel of the restaurant was nice. The prices are steep, but worth it. Would definitely recommend for a special occasion.
Favorite restaurant on Maui! I would be so sad to visit Maui and not go to Mama’s Fish House. Amazing fish dishes and delicious desserts.
Dinner was as good as the reviews say
It is! Beautiful ambiance, incredible service, and delicious food! Wonderful experience!
Fabulous meal celebrating our son’s 18th birthday! Food, service, ambiance was all perfect. Love Mamas!
Excellent food and atmosphere!! We lived it. The service was great as well
Excellent food and service
A must for seafood.
Fabulous meal and service, but very pricey. Will return, but not frequently
Food was amazing. The service was even better. We were made to feel welcome. Everyone was friendly. Our server shared stories with us. 100% recommend when in Maui
My husband and I celebrated our anniversary at Mama's. It was a perfect evening! Service was impeccable and food was delicious.
The atmosphere is spot-on. We loved this restaurant and if we ever visit Maui again will surely be making reservations at Mama's.
Amazing service and yummy food make this destination a must if in Maui.
Loved our dinner! Must eat here if you come to Maui!
Unbelievable experience! From the free valet parking, the hostesses,the waiters, food servers and busboys everything was perfect. Not to mention the food which was equally unforgettable.
My expectation was that we would have great food and be hustled in and out however, we were never rushed and were made to feel Welcome by our Server Jessica and this became a truly great dining experience. I will never make a trip back to Maui without reservations at Mama's Fish House. Do yourself a favor and make a reservation!
Fantastic food, great service, wonderful ambiance, beautiful views.....very expensive, but they know what they’re doing!
Devin was the best waiter ever, food was superb!
Love this place! Definitely make reservations no matter when you go! It was my daughters 9th birthday and they catered to her! It was and always is amazing!!
My absolute favorite place to eat and enjoy the beautiful scenery in Maui!!
Great food. Service wasn’t as good as other tomes I’ve been here
The setting is gorgeous, allow time to soak it in before and/or after your meal. The service is amazing, we called when we realized we'd be 15 minutes late and they still honored our reservation and made it a really special occasion for us with thoughtful touches to acknowledge our anniversary. The food and drinks were delicious and beautifully presented.
Food was very good but you’re paying for the ambience/experience, which is nice but may not be worth it to you. We spent $300 after tip for 2 people. That includes 4 glasses of wine, the sashimi appetizer (RECOMMEND), lobster soup, ahi salad and one of the fish mains. All was delicious and food quality was a step up from other restaurants we tried and I would recommend for a fine dining experience
Everyone has to dine at Mama’s once during thwie stay on Maui. Note I say dine vs eat-it is a TRUE dining experience....the house specialty-seafood stuffed fish-has been a long standing staple and I can understand why. My friend got the steak and it was cooked perfectly. The mushroom soup starter was perfection. Our waiter was spot on, took the time to explain everything and made recommendations. Even the valets were more than helpful. Overall a wonderful experience. Pricey but worth every penny not only for the food but for the entire experience
Wonderful food, beverages and service. A must when visiting Maui.
Most amazing fish I have ever had. Beautiful views of the ocean and great customer service!
Took a while to get our server but the bar staff was awesome. Bit pricey on the cocktails but whatever have you seen the view? Food was phenomenal. Main course of ONO was absolutely amazing. One of the best pieces of fish I’ve ever encountered. Again, not cheap but if you have an amazing partner to experience it with, well worth the price. Will come again next time in Paia, Maui.