Mama Stortini's - Puyallup
The staff was friendly from the moment we arrived. Our waitress Amy K was extremely pleasant and attentive. It was my husbands birthday and she really made the night special. Our appetizer, zucchini sticks, came out right away and were delicious. Everyone in the family enjoyed what they ordered. We will be back soon to enjoy another great meal. Thank you to such a great staff!
The food was less than stellar and the service was very slow for an almost empty restaurant.
The happy hour menu changed and good food like Garlic Spaghetti was taken off the menu. How sad is that? There was some other food that was removed or moved to a higher price.
Other than that, it was quite enjoyable.
Food was quite good ( don't get the spaghetti , but everything else is very good ) This time I had the chicken lasagna and it was wonderful. My main complaint was the noise level. My wife and I had to lean in across the table to hear each other.
We always love visiting the Puyallup Mama Stortini's. Great atmosphere and delicious food and wonderful service. They are our "go to" favorite!
This has been one of our favorite restaurants in the area but the quality has gone down hill. They again changed their vendor for their calamari. The rings were undercooked and greasy. The crab and artichoke dip was lukewarm at best. I am so disappointed to see the changes in this restaurant. I hope we'll see an improvement in the future or we won't be back.
Great service, terrific food and all around a great night!
Food was good , my choice was a bit to garlicky where it makes it spicy, full house so noise was high but expected, server was awesome!!
Crab cakes were great. Salad good (too many onions for my taste) Ziti and Meatballs great, Wife had Chicken Marsala great. Desert overcooked creme brulee. The service was nice helpful but very rushed we received salad and app. the same time and before we finished those the dinner was delivered.
Amazing food. Great staff. look forwards on going back soon. :)))
Hostess seemed weird about us bringing our baby. And said we couldn't have a booth, which would have been better for us. Service was awkward and horrible. My fettuccine was dry and flavorless. The seafood was cooked perfectly though. My boyfriend's french dip was dry. It was my birthday dinner. We came on a Sunday. Just very disappointed, because it wasn't cheap.
Great food and attentive, knowledgable staff. Noisy because the next table over was a bridal party but they were just joyous, not obnoxious. Will return again next time we are in town.
Music always annoying
Yes, ambience very loud on Saturday night
Service was good. No wait either
We buy your coupon program. Is good deal
We drive from Buckley
My wife’s favorite restaurant
Great food. A little more expensive than others. We've been coming here for more than 20 years.
One of our favorite restaurants. Food is always delicious. Highly recommend this restaurant.
It was very loud when we got there. It looked as though there was a birthday party going on. I could barely hear the waitress. After the party ended it was great.
Great place for date night. The servers were attentive and made sure our food was to our liking.
We love Mama Stortini's! I feel compared to other restaurants it is a very good value!! Love their chicken and mushroom ravioli and my husband loves their spaghetti and meatballs.
Cabernet wine not good. Food, service very good. Recommend large dining room over smaller if you want to carry on a conversation.
Had a 20 min wait after our reservation time. Service was fast. Food tasted blan.
The food is good, but the portion sizes are very small for the price of the food. Service is fine, but not outstanding. It's a pretty restaurant.
I reserved a table 2 weeks ahead of Valentines Day, expecting to enjoy the restaurant and atmosphere, but my wife and I were seated downstairs next to an emergency exit door, in what can only be described as an overflow area, with folding chairs and too many tables packed in. I understand this is a busy night, but I had a confirmed reservation, and didn’t expect to be packed into overflow as if I just showed up expecting a table. Food and service were good, but atmosphere pretty well ruined the experience.
Overall it was a good experience. But if you’re going to charge basically $20 dollars for a plate of lasagna. It should come to your table hot, not luke warm. The only thing that saved it, was the fact it was flavorable. One other thing, the lettuce for the garden salad is sliced so “Fine” you have to eat it with a spoon....?
Me and my girlfriends food came out cold this is the only location that I've had a unpleasant experience at the staff was amazing though
I took my mom and stepdad and it was one of the nicest most clean and excellent dinning experiences that we have had in a long time. The price of the food was reasonable and above excellant. All of the staff were friendless and even though it was the first time for me to go there they made me feel as though I belonged there. I will go back and I reccomend them to every single person who reads this.
Great staff. Awesome chop chop salad. Supercservice
One of the dishes was chicken parmesan and it was well, well done and dry.
I did tell our waitress but it was still and expensive for it to be on the burnt.
Always a great experience. Had Delaney as our server again. She remembered when she served us last. That was a hectic night. Food was delicious!
The service was extremely slow, I even made a reservation and there were many many open tables. So I dont know why the service was so bad. I couldn't even get my water refilled!
Never been before. Wasn’t expecting such good food from a family style Italian place. The fresh sheet had lots of interesting items, hard to pick. Our server (Anne?) was efficient and fun!
Service was terrible. Probably won't return. yyyyyyyyyy
Our anniversary. We got married last year on this very sight! Got right in with our reservation. Waited quite awhile for our dinner. Mama Stortini staff knew it was our anniversary and we’re sorry for the wait. Dinner was great as usual. We paid for our bottle of wine and appetizers, as they comped our dinners! Always loved this place. Will continue our patronage at Mama Stortini!
Wife’s birthday it was great had a very good time
It was very clean and nice, the service was excellent and the food was worth what we paid! We will definitely be back, even the kids were impressed!
Been here several times for dates and family dinner. I’ve yet to be disappointed by any menu item and their cocktails are delicious- but maybe just a little too sweet for my preferences.
We always enjoy our experience at Mama’s in Puyallup. Nine of us celebrated New Yesrs with great drinks, excellent food (the goat cheese bruschetta is phenomenal), and wonderful service! Definitely recommend for all occasions!
We had a great time. The wait staff were very friendly and knowledgeable about the food. Our food was excellent.
We always have a good meal and pleasant waitresses.
Too noisey. Needs more kid friendly options. Otherwise very good and enjoyed our food, drinks and friends.
My wifes dinner tasted like it was made the day before. The good part of this poor dining experience was that the manager comped both of our meals when we complained about the quality of the food.