Excellent food and service. Duck breast delicious and salad was great. Definitely will return
Food and Service were great as usual. New neighbors joined us for dinner. They were looking for options to take out of town guests and had been disappointed in other options in town. They were very pleased with Madeline’s and said they were thrilled to find a good place to take out of town guests.
Awesome steaks and great service
Top notch place
I would recommend this place to anyone
We had a wonderful experience. The food was delicious, and the service exemplary. Our server was Brad, and did an awesome job on all accounts.
Get the Crying Tiger. Trust me.
Great overall dining experience the food was fantastic, will definitely be back.
First time to Madeleine’s, we went for Valentine dinner. They had a special 4 course dinner. Food was great, best meal we had had out in years. Appetizers, salad, main course and desert were all excellent. We will be back.
My husband and I enjoyed our Valentine's date. The food was excellent. It was our second time visiting and we'll certainly be back. Delicious and interesting food and cocktails, and the staff is very accommodating.
Value equation is not there. I expected more and have prepared better steaks myself. For a restaurant of this type, I was surprised that they used promotional/branded glassware. I will go elsewhere the next time I’m in Evansville.
Excellent staff. Very friendly. Great Service. Perfect place to bring that special someone. Music levels and lighting levels were perfect. Food was excellent. We ordered the duck and the Rib-eye. Great flavors, cooked to proper temperature. Would definitely recommend! We plan on coming back again for sure.
The BEST place in town! Our FAVORITE place to celebrate a special occasion or an occasional treat! The food is UNBELIEVABLE and the service is even BETTER! If we could only sit out on the patio year around!
Love the steaks! Sides and salads are unique and large enough to share. I always look forward to discovering what the special flavored butter of the day will be. The Italian lemon cake for dessert was divine. Our service was excellent and our experience most satisfying.
Anniversary dinner. Our 3rd trip back to Madeline’s. The food and presentation never disappoint!
The duck was awesome. Great atmosphere and a perfect evening.
The chicken Parm dish was fantastic. It was well prepared and pleasantly displayed. It was a beautiful and delicious plate. The sides were perfectly complimentary and the chicken shined as the best I have had in my 65 years of a foody.
Celebrated birthday and the food was great and restaurant is very nice. Waiter was attentive. Kind of pricey but worth it for special occasion
Food is great with exceptional service
I let madeleines know we were celebrating our anniversary. Table was beautifully decorated with rose petals, heart candle and red napkins folded into rosettes. Perfect evening
What a great find! Wonderful food, wonderful ambiance and great service. Worth the trip!
We were early for our reservation and were greeted with warmth, shown immediately to our table and never lacked for attention thereafter. Our server made several excellent suggestions and we were not sorry to have listened to her. We split a salad between two and could have included a third person; the entrée portions were not so large but were entirely adequate. Two of us had the 8 oz. filet which was seasoned well and perfectly cooked. The duck leg was delicious but difficult to eat on the bone. On our server's advice, we split a Madeleine's Foster which used peaches rather than bananas for the base. A terrific improvement on the original. Should concert attendance beckon us again to Evansville, we will look no further for a place to dine.
The food was excellent and the service was superb-especially Max the bartender. My portion was small but my wife’s was ok. The quality made up for quantity. I suspect there was a party upstairs that slowed service and may have influenced portion size. Nonetheless I highly recommend this restaurant for locals and visitors like us.
Fantastic service and amazing bar selection, filet with espresso rub was perfect and butternut squash ravioli wonderful as well! Will definitely visit again next time we’re in Evansville
The staff was friendly and efficient. The food was AMAZING, from appetizer to desert! It was our anniversary and they had the table sweetly decorated. We will definitely be back!
Traveling through for a conference. Great surprise find. Will definitely be back when in the area. Great food and service.
A true treasure in Evansville. Excellent food with an ever-changing menu.
We love Madeline's. It's expensive, but oh so worth the price! Plan to spend at least 1.5 hours here. It's slow paced which I love because I don't feel rushed to finish and get out so someone else can have my table. I told them we were celebrating a birthday and when we arrived, our table had birthday confetti all over, a ceramic cupcake on the table with a happy birthday sign, and all of our water glasses said happy birthday on them. What a nice touch! Waiter was VERY attentive, but not overbearing. I am a very picky eater, but I can always find something here that I absolutely love, which is saying a lot since their menu changes all the time. Definitely worth the splurge!
Celebrating our wedding anniversary. Wonderful service and very good food!
This is a gem! We have enjoyed two wonderful dinners here! Can't wait to go back.
Everything from service to food to selection was perfect!
This may have been a better restaurant at one time, but not now. The service was good and the environment really quite delightful. The best part of the meal was a beautifully prepared martini. The deconstructed Rangoon appetizer tasted like it was 99% cream cheese with the "crab and lobster" someplace other than on my plate. The entrée was a pork and cherries dish that was over-cooked and lacking in any real complexity. The wine list however was great and reasonably priced.
Fantastic! Wine list was amazing and the staff is incredible.
The Service was Excellent. The Wine selection was Good. The 16 oz Dry Aged Rib-eye was cooked to perfection and had great flavor. The Lobster Mac and cheese was to die for along with the Red potato Augratan.
But, the Key Lime Pie was so small I could hardly find it on the plate and for $11.00 I expected a Piece that could be shared with my wife, plus they put green lime zest all over it which was disgusting.
I do recommend Madeline's for everything they have expect for the desserts. We will return and enjoy the wonderful entree's that they have.
It was Very Good!We will definatlt be back!The Atmosphere was Beautiful and Peaceful, the service was good and friendly, and the Food was Beautiful and Delicious!!
Highly recommended. Menu changes with plenty of great choices. This place will not disappoint anyone. Great staff, wonderful food and good drinks.
Exceptional experience all around! Our first Anniversary and first time to dine here. We plan to make this an annual experience. Our new favorite for sure!
Great meal. Slow service even though restaurant was only 1/2 full. They made up for slow service by comping dessert and coffee.
This place is just awesome. We come to Evansville several times per year and ALWAYS make certain that we carve out an evening at Mad line's. Food, drink, service, are always top shelf. This past visit was truly exceptional.
Amazing blend of flavors perfectly served and unique! True gem. Greatest meal I've had in a long time.
Very good service and food... took a little longer than expected
My wife and I have dined at Madeleine's many times over the last several years. It has been one of our favorite restaurants in the Evansville area for special occasion dining--always a bit pricey, but with corresponding value. We first noticed slippage in quality of food during a visit in February 2017.
This past Saturday, however, was a complete fall from grace. My wife ordered roasted chicken; I ordered smoked lamb ribs. The roasted chicken was literally so tough on the outside that it was difficult to penetrate with a steak knife. Once "disassembled" the chicken had good flavor, but it was an ordeal to eat. The accompanying side of Peruvian mash was completely tasteless. The lamb ribs were charred, crusty--completely over done. The marinade or basting sauce showed promises of good flavor, but was so over cooked, it was hard to tell. The accompanying side of mashed yams was as tasteless as the Peruvian mash.
The service, unfortunately, measured down to the quality of the food on this occasion--completely inattentive during an evening with average size crowd (several open tables). We probably would have complained, but the service was so non-existent, and it took so long to place and receive our order, we decided to finish and move on. In all fairness, I had stated that we were relaxing and in no rush, but...
I'll never say never, regarding a return visit, but I'll want to see a string of rave reviews before we try Madeleine's again. And this is a shame, because Madeleine's has been top notch for many years. Hope the restaurant address the kitchen deficiency we experienced on Saturday.
The service was not good, the server was lacking in her job. Even when she was asking what we would like to order she was not attentive. The Kitchen was very slow , Tim should jump in and help to get them back on track. The food and the service is just not what it was in the first few years. I hate to write this review because this was my favorite place for years and I hope it returns to the standards they once had.