"Caesar" dressing, parmesan
Fried Chicken Sandwich
fried chicken breast, avocado, tomatoes, lettuce, chipotle sauce, garlic aioli, crispy fries
Short Rib Pizza
cheddar caramelized onion cheese, mozzarella, parmesan, cream, garlic, red wine onions
During the reservation we were asked if it was a special occasion. We said Anniversary. Was wondering why that question is asked but nothing was acknowledged at dinner. Thank you
The food was disappointing. Of six dishes only one was satisfactory. The others were all too heavy-handed. Most too sweet, some too salty. And one sauce completely overwhelmed the delicate seafood. Kind of like bad Chinese food.
Lillys: College reunion post Covid...friends coming from New Haven, Monroe, LI and Peekskill met here and loved it!!! Will be back
Awesome food, great ambience.. a bit noisy but you tend to crave the noise and buzz after COVID!! A great evening out with friends !
I love Lilly's, the food is always consistent and its a great atmosphere!
The food was excellent. The service was very disjointed and inconsistent. There were long periods of waiting fir refills, food etc. I feel most of the issues were due to Covid staff shortages and would def go back.
Way too loud, hard to talk with people you’re dining with
Very nice place for our client dinner. Service and atmosphere were great and everyone really enjoyed their meals.
Very nice place for an early dinner, beautiful patio outside
Great food and great service. We always like coming here. We requested outdoor seating and it was ready when we arrived.
Great experience! Loved the patio- lots of shade and umbrellas, comfortable to sit outdoors.
Great wine and cocktail offering though my rose was not ice cold, it was still good!
Pizza and chicken sandwich were both delicious!
Interesting, short menu, pizza to sandwiches to small plates to pastas. Menu ample size but small.
Enjoyed selection of draft beers.
Music made lunch noisy.
The food was absolutely delicious and the service was impeccable. My friend and I agreed that that was the best food we had ever had! Love this place.
I miss Paul, it's just not the same. The food & drinks were fabulous!!!
Service was good not great. Took a while to come over and take order and never checked to see if we needed anything, had to ask to order more drinks. Once order was taken food/drinks come quickly.
It was great
The only issue was that the bus boy kept trying to take our plates before we finished. Love the outdoor seating!
Lily's is a great place for lunch or dinner - inside or out. Food is very good and I am a vegetarian. Service was great where waiters are quick, competent and very polite. It was a pleasure.
This was my second time at Lily's and it was better than the first. Their outdoor patio is beautiful and nicely spaced out. Last time, they had a tent up (but open) and this time the tent was down allowing the sunlight to increase the ambiance. The food is elevated bar food which is delicious. I am excited to try their lunch or dinner menu since their brunch menu is fantastic. And the free mimosa is good too.
Food was delicious!!! Drinks were yummy!
Celebrating my daughters Graduation from Westchester Medical Schools Speech Therapy program. Initially took us 20 min before anyone approached us for drinks, very few servers at 5pm. Clam pizza and Margherita pizzas Excellent. Mac cheese very good. Nicely decorated noise level low at that time. Overall a nice experience and would recommend. Will go again!
The food was amazing and our waiter was very nice! The back patio looked gorgeous and overall we had a great experience.
Lilly’s has well prepared, fresh food with great ambiance whether you dine inside or out on their patio. The service is always exceptional!
Best food! Great service! The outdoor tent is super cute. Can't wait to go back.
Accessible food, not overly crowded. Good cocktail menu if you’re looking for afternoon drinks and tapas.
We celebrated a friend's birthday. We so enjoyed a combo of small plate, a pasta dish a pizza and your delicious parmesan truffle fries. Always great food and service.
We sat outside under the tent and it was lovely. You're not too close to the next table so you can feel very comfortable eating at a restaurant. The wait staff was all lovely, helpful but not crowding you. The food was all delicious, and the small platters are the perfect size for sharing.
I would feel very comfortable going back again even with Covid still going on.
The small plates are delicious. We like the skirt steak, the brussel sprouts, the papas bravos, and the dates and chorizo. The pizzas are also excellent. We really like the A la Vodka pizza.
Food was great. Service was attentive. Only negative specifically for me was no changing table for a baby...
Always love going there for the ambiance and great food.
Good food and Nice ambient! Great place for a get together with friends . Totally recommend it for meeting with friends and family.
Best Popover I’ve ever had! Lily’s never disappoints!
The food was good, I especially liked the patatas bravas! The service was fast and we were able to be distant from other tables while outside on the patio.
It was cold. It took too long to put the heaters on and close the door to make the patrons more comfortable
Great local place to dine indoors or out. Fun atmosphere, great appetizers and drinks. Highly recommend.
Fun dinner. Lots of options. Could have more vegetarian options. But they were accommodating
Lively ambiance in the outdoor patio, large tent was great as opposed to next door with just umbrellas so half the table is in the burning sun.
Food was great.
The food was great, the price was right and the service was excellent. We sat inside and it was nice and quiet. We didn't have to shout to be heard.
Lilly's offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (914) 997-5600.
Lilly's is rated 4.6 stars by 986 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.