Lacey was our server and she made the evening extra enjoyable - warm, attentive, and professional. Still one of my fave spots in the city!!!
Everything was great, didn't feel like a crazy Times Square restaurant which is what we were hoping for! Food, drinks, and service were good! Large High-Tops make for a cool vibe and good for groups. Also the decor is great, feels like you're in an antique shop!
Discovered this cool establishment from a venue reservation blunder.
I originally looked up “Lilly’s” in Times Square on Open Table. What came up was a “Lillie’s Times Square” which I booked in a hurry. Our friend was certain it was different from the resto profile I sent him but because of the reservation we went anyway.
Once we entered, we found an intriguing and cozy Victorian themed gastropub. It felt like we were dining in an old historic building from the 1900’s while listening to 90s alternative music.
Though food and drinks were just okay to slightly above average, the place overall is worth a periodic visit.
Just an outstanding experience -- took a niece before seeing Hamilton and it was just a great start to a memorable and special day.
Because it was Sunday there was just a brunch menu and I found it limited. I asked for a simple grilled sandwich but was told they couldn’t do it. Service was quick.
Stumbled across this gem and decided to book my date night. We were so impressed. Cocktails were exquisite. Decor and ambiance were perfect. Dinner was very delicious. Definitely a nice change of pace.
I cannot wait to come back for high tea!
Perfect for brunch before a matinee and you can't beat the price! Food was good, but the service and the overloaded Victorian ambiance was fabulous. Our server, Lacey, was fast, friendly, attentive, and an absolute delight. Would absolutely go back!
Too loud for our group. Salas was DRENCHED in dressing. Good for a drink at the bar.
Met our kids for a quick bite before seeing a Broadway show. Loved the decor and enjoyed our evening!
Went here after a show on a Sunday matinee. Decor is the best part. Seats are all at high tables. Was seated promptly and service was attentive. Pub food - struggled with what to order as one of us likes to eat healthy and the options are limited. Gave up and ordered fish 'n chips. Was hot and tasty. Disappointed with the red cole slaw. Very light on pours on wine - felt like 4 oz at best. Stick with the beer.
Went to Lillie’s for my birthday. Made reservations, got there and was checked in and seated without issue. Brunch menu is nice. Entree and beverage for 18. The Bloody Mary is fantastic! I love that’s it’s not a teeny glass either. They really give you a large beer mug and the extras are great! Also had a mimosa which was good, not total orange juice like most places. The juice tasted really fresh, almost like they make in house. Idk if that’s true or not but it was great. Coffee was nice and strong. I had steak and eggs which was cooked perfectly. Fiancé had the eggs Benedict which he loved. The potatoes on the side were okay, nothing spectacular. The decor of the place is really great. One weird thing is that the all the candles on the wall sconces melted and were bent and hanging down. They were never used, just weirdly melted from the heat. Otherwise the woodwork around is incredible. The seats were extremely comfortable. I like the high seating. I didn’t get a chance to try too many beers at 1040am but they have a really awesome draft selection. Would absolutely go back for happy hour or just drinking later on. Service was also great. No complaints 😊
Other than a wobbly table, the restaurant was excellent. We got there right as it opened for our reservation, so we got seated quickly and the service was fast and the food was excellent. It's a great deal for $18.
We went here after a show. Great drinks. Nice little pub menu. The stools for the high tables were uncomfortable and rickety, but other than that the place is gorgeous and a nice atmosphere
Impressed with the wait staff. Very attentive and pleasant.
When we arrived we were immediately seated. Drink Orders were promptly taken and water glasses filled. Our orders arrived within an expected amount of time. We had a Caesar salad with chicken and a shepards pie both were very good but the Shepards pie portion was small. As others have noted the combination of the large bar and loud music make for difficult conversation. I was considering meeting friends here for lunch but will go somewhere else. Nothing against the overall experience but not a place to meet if you want to talk.
Brilliant choice for a pre theatre meal and something that I would reccomend to anyone
Cute décor and seating options. Good for groups and couples. Somewhat romantic. Gets crowded at pre-theater times, so reservations a must.
Much too noisy. I was expecting a dinner menu but it was mostly pub food. Nothing notable and the creme brule was not good.
In town from Southern California to see Bruce on Broadway. Great place for us to start our night with drinks and dinner. Great all around. Promptly seated us with reservation.
Good food, but not great, in a unique, entertaining atmosphere. Friendly but somewhat slow service. Great Times Square location, very convenient for Broadway shows. Overall, well worth it for pre-show lunch or dinner.