Lexington Square Cafe
Please Call For Reservations as Space is Limited.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Red Cabbage Slaw, Avocado, Radish, Cumin Citrus Aioli, Pico de Gallo, Queso Fresco
Pan Roasted Halibut
Lobster Corn Risotto, Lobster Vin Blanc
Mayonnaise, Celery, Lemon Juice, Chives, Truffle Pomme Frites
On the first Fall day, it was lovely to have an outdoor luncheon on a beautiful, summer-like day. One last lobster roll and Arnold Palmer. The woman caring for us was lovely and attentive. The food was delicious. And as one last hint of summer, we shared the key lime pie that is served with raspberry sorbet. Great experience!
Everything was great except due to the outside doors being open there were flyies.
They should cover the open doors with screens,
Good food and outdoor seating very nice. Waiter looked miserable entire time. In addition, why can’t waiters and servers wear face masks?? Would be so much safer.
Good food and very good service. Our go to restaurant in Mt Kisco.
I would love this place a whole lot more if they weren’t vegetarian hostile. In this day and age you would think this wouldn’t be a hard thing to know. There is one (1) vegetarian option on the menu. I chose that because the other option was walking out.
Beautiful outdoor patio! Buffalo Cauliflower appetizer was delish! As were entrees…tuna with soba noodles…and teriyaki salmon.
Would have appreciated knowing that the establishment does not mandate vaccines or masks for anyone and did not appreciate their sign. I am from out of town and limited options but had I realized this before dining I probably would have not given them my business.
Generous main course. Food quality very high. Service good but it slows down as it gets more crowded.
Moderate to expensive. Excellent steak and chicken dishes.
The outdoor patio is charming and perfect for our time. The food was great and the menu was perfect for brunch
Food is always phenomenal.
Wait staff is so friendly and provides excellent service.
The whole experience is always constantly perfect.
Brunch with a friend and the omelette was decent but not better than a diner omelette. A little more finesse would have been appreciated. Tasted like it was cooked in old oil or something not great. Appreciate the banana bread but would prefer something more plain like a normal bread basket.
Tea basket didn't have enough herbal choices.
Only mentioning these things because I care, thanks
Great in all ways
We had a delightful lunch on the patio.
I love Lexington Square Cafe because the food is always excellent and the service is great!
Patio is a lovely respite. Food consistently good. Excellent wait staff.
We enjoyed the ambiance, food and service. Good value and tasty dishes, although there didn't seem to be many choices for the vegetarian in our party. However, she was able to put together some things for a very lovely meal.
Lexington Square Cafe is a great dinning experience. The food and the
Service and the surrounds are perfect for a enjoyable lunch or dinner. One of my very favorite places to dine. Try it once and you will become a regular.
Visiting from California and remembered eating here about nine years ago and liking it. Everything we ordered was delicious, especially the baby back ribs (daily special menu item). Came with french fries and exceptionally good coleslaw. Good Margaritas!
The waiter didn’t refill drinks/ask if we wanted more drinks. Hamburgers came on an English muffin, which I’ve never seen unless requested.
We had calamari and buffalo cauliflower, i had crab cake sandwich, it was awesome...my friends had the tacos and other had a southwestern sa dwich....so good!
Luncheon for bday
Good food and service. I will advise reservations and get there early for parking
Our server Zachary was terrific, as were the cocktails and ambiance. The food isn't bad at all but seemed a bit misaligned with the prices.
A nice find in Mount Kisco.
Lexington Square has been a go to restaurant for my friends and me for many years. The service, quality of food, menu selection and ambience have remained consistently fine. We appreciate having a place where we know the experience will be pleasant and we are never rushed out the door.
Food was delicious, as always, as was the service!
Great place to meet for brunch. Wonderful outside seating. Friendly staff and fun menu. Definitely recommend.
The good was very good . The service was tremendous . We had not been there in a couple of years - it is now very much on our list again .
Our food was very good, albeit expensive for what we got. The small lobster roll looked awfully lonely on the plate! Staff was unmasked, which made us very uncomfortable.
Went for restaurant week which a good deal. The service was great at first and then all staff went awol. The special drinks are priced at the ridiculous charge of $16 each. So we had a beer instead. The place was empty and has lost it's electrity, too bad. On the other hand Village Social was packed. They have it going on..
Attentive and courteous staff. We were very satisfied with our meal esp that it’s restaurant week-great value!
Great Sunday Brunch menu but you can also order from the standard daily lunch menu.
As always great service
Oysters fresh and delicious
Chicken a tad overdone
Swordfish and mango salsa very tasty
Delicious food. Great service. Lovely outdoor dining. I will be back!
Food was mostly good One of the people ordered the restaurant week menu and said his steak was very “fatty” but all the other food was very good.
We were very disappointed with our meal, unfortunately. We live in the area and haven’t been to the restaurant in several years but decided to go back. We sat outside, which was very nice and it’s a comfortable and pretty patio. The service was fine. Both my husband and I were very disappointed in our meals. I had simply grilled tuna with two sides. The tuna was not hot and the brussels sprouts were cold. Sautéed spinach was good, flavorful and hot. My husband had the steak au poivre. He said that the sauce was very watery and his brussels sprouts, which were on the menu as crispy, were definitely not.
We really wanted to enjoy the meal but I have to say that it was very mediocre and therefore overpriced for what it was. Sadly we will not be going back.
This is an upscale cafe with upscale prices. That stated the food, the service, the noise level and the ambiance were very good for business meal or special occasion or if cost is not an issue.
Great outdoor seating. Very nice place. Great service. Food was really so, so. Wilted salad. Steak was just ok. Mashed potatoes were good. Prosecco was delicious. For the price and based on the reviews I was expecting the food to be better. I likely would not return nor recommend.
Lexington Square is always a good choice. Quality of the food is excellent.
Extremely reliable choice for dining with friends or family or having a small celebration.
Unclear if they are training new people, but the service was slow and inattentive, and the opinions of the meal served to our table was mixed, at best…entrees better than apps. Hopefully just one off night
Have decided to give it up. Terrible service the last 4 times I have been. Staff are untrained. Sorry, never again.
Lexington Square Cafe offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (914) 244-3663.
Lexington Square Cafe is rated 4.5 stars by 1177 OpenTable diners.
Lexington Square Cafe does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.lexingtonsquarecafe.com/gift-cards.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.