Lexington Square Cafe
Please Call For Reservations as Space is Limited.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Red Cabbage Slaw, Avocado, Radish, Cumin Citrus Aioli, Pico de Gallo, Queso Fresco
Pan Roasted Halibut
Lobster Corn Risotto, Lobster Vin Blanc
Mother's Day Menus & Specials
Join us for Mother's Day. We have a special ala carte menu to suit everyone's needs!
The ambiance is good , the menu is not as good as it used to be: I used to be able to substitute foods if I wanted, I was not able to do that this time.
They did an amazing job it’s spreading out the tables and the food was excellent
Haven't been there in years, probably won't be back for several more. Overall, pricey for a "meh" experience. Also, I tripped on the poorly maintained slate steps leading to the restaurant. Was much better "back in the day."
The food was wonderful. Service very poor. Evidently the restaurant was understaffed when we were there. Took forever for a waiter to even take our drink order. Even longer to take our food order. Our appetizers came and still no drinks! My Chardonnay came but it was a Sauvignon blanc. I am sensitive to sauv blanc taste. I couldn’t find waitstaff to switch so I drank it though I didn’t enjoy it. I finally got the correct drink second time around. Took forever to get our entrees and even longer to get table cleared and the check. Food and ambiance great so my husband and I made the best of it.
Went with family and it was great. Food was very very good.
My friend Jane and I thoroughly enjoyed her lovely Birthday lunch at Lexington Square Cafe! The staff was so professional and courteous. We sat outside as it was a beautiful day. I loved the Fish Taco’s and Jane loved her salad with grilled chicken. She also loved her Birthday chocolate cake dessert! Thank you so much!
Service always great here. Friendly and professional
Halibut and risotto special never disappoints
The food and service had always been consistent, and this time was no exception. Our waitress was professional and friendly and we enjoyed eating outdoors.
Rather disappointed with the service.
Great local restaurant with food for every palate. Kids love it, ambiance is nice, outdoor dining with the heat lamps is wonderful, and service is always top notch. Don't let the lackluster curb appeal scare you away. This place is a gem!
Delightful fine dining experience. They were attentive
Girls night out - it was very nice - not too loud so we could have a conversation. The food was very good - recommend the Salmon with Asian noodles and pork dumplings. The service was outstanding - would go back again.
This place has always been a standard for a great dinner, business meals and family/ friends “get togethers”. I’m looking forward ti when we get past the restrictions and people are gathering again. This is the place to be to celebrate .
Great food. Great service. Always a pleasure Ro be there
Its been a while for us dining @ LSC. My wife and i were completely with the quality of the meals, service was excellent and we we seated on time. it was one of the better experiences in recent memory.
thank you Lexington Square Cafe for a wonderful experience.
Everything was delicious. Tables were Covid-friendly spaced.
Haven’t been in a long time and it was delicious! Salmon was perfect! Manager and wait staff were friendly and attentive. We really enjoyed meal
Staff followed all COVID protocols. Felt safe with proper distancing between tables. Food was superb amazing specials for Valentine’s Day! A nice pour of wine per glass. We are never disappointed!!
As usual staff and food amazing
excellent spacing between tables - service and food was excellent
Always a tasteful meal and wonderful waitstaff
Engaging, intelligent, focused staff.
Five star meals.
Better value than other steak houses but the steak was not aged. However it was perfectly cooked and served.
Menu is little dated and has not changed. Service was prompt and friendly.
It wasn’t great. Food was just ok. Used to frequent there for work gatherings, but seems that it has since changed
Great job providing delicious food and great service outdoors in a lovely setting and safely distances from others.
Lexington’s halibut with lobster risotto is amazing
Staff always attentive and friendly
Safety preparations and spacing all great
Very quiet because of Covid, quite enjoyable. Will go again.
Onion soup not tasty a a clump of cheese that wasn’t melted
Flatbread pizza just okay. Flatbread not tasty
I think this place needs to work harder on the quality of its dishes, given its prices
Seasonal oysters a treat. We had a quiet afternoon with excellent food.
Grandpa birthday. Has babies with us.
Delicious food and excellent service. All wait staff was attentive and very knowledgeable about different entrees
I may have to go back as I had heard good things about this place. The service was excellent, the space is charming and clean. The noise level was like a jet taking off. Hard to hear with the music and noise-level of diners. I had the brunch smoked salmon platter and it tasted fine, but there was barely a teaspoon of capers, a smidge of cream cheese and not very much smoked salmon. The potato latkes were very good though. My companion had the chopped salad and enjoyed it very much. The bloody mary I had was just the right balance of tang and pepper. So I will try it again.
We had a lovely evening with friends as we were seated at a quiet table in the front corner by the windows. Food was well prepared and delicious!
Our waiter was attentive and the food was very good. Despite being crowded, we were able to carry on a conversation without shouting or missing anything. It's rare these days to find a restaurant with such good acoustics.
When my husband wants a burger Lexington is his preference. Done just the way he likes (perfect temperature) he was super happy. I like the salmon club. It comes with salad and is served on multigrain bread with avocado. It’s terrific. Would give 4.5 stars if that was an option.
Food as good as always, very attentive but non-intrusive service, we were able to chat at length.
My husband and I had dinner here on Saturday with 7PM reservations. We were greeted and sat immediately. The service was wonderful with experienced wait staff. The food was wonderful. We started with Lobster spring rolls for an appetizer. I had the Halibut special which was amazing and my husband had tuna. Both dishes were beautifully presented and tasted amazing. For dessert we shared a delicious raspberry chocolate mousse. The place was very busy but we did not feel rushed. It was a little loud but we could have a conversation. Over all its a 2 thumbs up.
Never disappoints. We love it!! The staff is amazing and very attentive. The ambience is wonderful and the food is absolutely amazing. Mom is looking forward to coming make with her friend.
Lexington Square Cafe offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (914) 244-3663.
Lexington Square Cafe is rated 4.5 stars by 1102 OpenTable diners.
Lexington Square Cafe does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.lexingtonsquarecafe.com/gift-cards.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.