This restaurant was highly recommended to us by a trustworthy lady! We have been coming to Montauk for years and we were very impressed with everything about Showfish - The food was interesting and not too overwhelming - The tables were lovely and private, there's a vibrant bar scene if you are...See More

This met all our expectations. Great energy and ambiance. Romantic setting near the yacht harbor and excellent service and food. The choices on the menus were creative and exciting.

Food was good thought the Flank Steak was very expensive for what you got

Food was delicious, service was friendly. Would go again.

Excellent food and service! A 10 in my opinion for everyone had a great meal! Thank you for a great experience!

They were closed for the season. They need to update their account & not allow ppl to make reservations in the off season. Ps you’re welcome for the 5 stars.

Tillie’s was excellent. I was in Montauk for a mother & daughter day . Tillie’s was our lunch stop. I had the chicken sandwich but I opted for the chicken to be grilled, the chef did an awesome job. Service was excellent. The restaurant was empty but that is expected in Montauk off season.

Wonderful dining experience with my daughters who are foodies like their Mama. Brought us back to our trip to Florence The pasta dishes were very authentic and divine as well as the gelato. Thank you Virginia Davis for the warm welcome

Food was awesome. I love the location and have gone there for years. Service was OK. They were busy so I was patient with food etc. But when I made it clear we didn’t want desert and wanted the check I felt I was being held hostage there. Overall good experience and will continue to return!

Took out Saturday night - missed the ambiance of the dining room but the food quality, service, portions and presentation were excellent. Taking out again midweek!