Restaurants near Rye Harbor

Dining here has been on our to do list for years. Food was outstanding as was the service. Such a pleasure to dine here and we will be back!

The oysters were some of the freshest and best we have had on our trip up the east coast and we have had a lot of excellent oysters. The gluten free, fried Haddock sandwich was very good. I haven’t had a fried fish since my GF diagnosis 5 years ago so it was a treat. Almost everything on the menu is or can be GF. Our server, Ann S, was attentive and friendly and handy with a Tide pen when I got a drip of sauce on my white sweater.

We love Otto’s! The pizza just can’t be beat…the atmosphere is warm and welcoming…and the wait staff is so friendly and accommodating…and do not miss Trivia on Wednesday’s hosted by Beth! We recommend Otto’s to all our friends. So, if you’re looking for good food and a relaxing atmosphere you should definitively give Otto’s a try.

Great food, but even better service. our server was amazing and very attentive.

Dinner was excellent and the staff was friendly. We sat on the patio which was fun to people watch. Our waitress Lily was attentive and made a great recommendation when I was struggling with choosing between 2 options. The homemade pasta in the lobster fettuccini was excellent. My partner had the Seafood Boil and it was very generous with fish. He was full and had enough left for lunch tomorrow. Overall an excellent experience and will definitely be back again.