Restaurants near Paper Mill Playhouse

Wow wow wow!! Eataly makes you feel like you are right in ITALY! The customer service is warm and inviting- Asia waa our waitress she was knowledgeable and friendly. The food was 10/10 pizza delicious! Pasta dishes fresh and flavorful! Wine was very nice compliment to the food dishes. Was even able to get got water to warm my baby's bottle. Charlie on the floor was excellent- full of Italian food knowledge, friendly, warm, funny! Will definitely come back for the delicious food, cozy atmosphere and excellent service provided by the staff.

Food and service were excellent. The staff was very accommodating. We've eaten here a number of times and have always been pleased.

A Moonshine experience is always a pleasurable experience. Signature cocktails are always on point, and the menu selections are not only delicious, but have a little something for a variety of palettes. Always my number 1 go to when I am in the area

As always, excellent food AND service. We dine here often and it IS our favorite place top dine. Will be back again soon.

We had a lovely night , waiter always keeps us laughing and the scenery is beautiful w/ play night excitement