Restaurants near Atlantis Beach House by Vacation Rental Pros

Love the place and we go there every time we come to St Augustine. It has the feeling of a “locals hangout”, with a really great vibe and high end atmosphere, without breaking the bank. Service is always great and the cocktails are top!

The Columbia Restaurant is just delicious! You have to order a pitcher of table-made mojitos or sangria! An absolute must!! The Cuban bread has just the right crunch and is delicious. The 1905 salad is so flavorful and they make it right at your table. You can order it as a side salad or as your entree with turkey or shrimp. The chicken dishes and steak dishes are absolutely wonderful. Palomilla is a Cuban steak dish with the best flavor ever! If you don’t eat onion, then maybe pass on it though! Pollo Manchego is chicken breast coated with Cuban bread crumbs and manchego cheese as well as a citrusy sauce, sun dried tomatoes and fresh basil. For Tapas, the Stuffed Piquillo Peppers and the Empanadas are my favorites. The Cuban sandwich is also very good! The service is always attentive and the restaurant is just beautiful!

We have eaten at The Old City House many times since we lived in St Augustine for many years. It was our go to place with our out-of-town friends. The restaurant never failed to be excellent. On our most recent trip back to see the Nights of Lights we knew where we wanted to dine. There are so many great restaurants in St. Augustine and this is one of the best. It is intimate. The food is always very good and the service is impeccable. Don’t come to St Augustine and pass this little gem up.

I wanted to enjoy a Thanksgiving dinner while on vacation with my wife and mother. After checking the options online, Atlantic Grille looked like the best move. I’m glad to say it 100% was the best decision I could have made. Perfect service and excellent food. Everyone form the hostess to our waiter was fantastic and very welcoming. The waiter even took the time to get some pictures of us on the deck. Great experience, we’ll be back when in town.

Hidden Gem. Frank the owner & chef extraordinaire is a character worthy of a reality series. He delivers a dining experience bar none. Has the gift of flavorful innovative dishes & the art of beauty in plating. Fantastic meal with many specials not on the menu each more wondrous than the next. French onion soup oo la la ; addictive seafood pasta special, bread garlic dip from heaven…and Franks a hoot- icing on the cake. Reasonable pricing! Highly recommend you make a reservation direct or open table. As Arnold says “I will be back!”