La Trattoria Old Town
Cheese tortellini with fresh sweet Italian sausage, tomatoes, mushrooms, basil, onions and garlic
Tiramisu is Italian for Lift Me Up! Lady fingers dipped in rum and espresso are layered with sweet marsscapone egg cream and topped with chocolate
Spaghetti pasta with fresh basil, tomatoes, onions, garlic and eggplant in tomato sauce, topped with salted ricotta cheese
My wife an I were on vacation stopped in by happenstance the food and service was awesome. The wine was a little pricey. Other than that it was a fantastic meal.
Thank you Stephen! So happy you enjoyed your time with us! Thank you for visiting Key West and for choosing to dine with us at La Trattoria. We hope to see you on your next visit!
Very good food. Very good service
Thank you Terry! So happy you had a wonderful time!
It was very good food and atmosphere. I will go back if I get the chance.
Thank you for your kind words! We do hope to see you again!
Great food. Kids portions too large. No kid could eat that much.
Wonderful time and excellent food.
Happy we could send you home with fully bellies and left overs! See you next time!
We had a great time at La Trattoria. All of the employees were very kind. The service was great too. Our server, Ahmed, was knowledgeable and very attentive throughout our dinner. We will definitely be coming back to dine here!
Thank you so much! I will pass on your kind words to Ameth and the rest of the crew! See you next time!
Absolutely delicious! Great service, cleanliness and ambiance. Servings generous, we also enjoyed leftovers. A bit pricey, but worth it for a peaceful delicious italian dinner
Thank you Ann for sharing your experience dining with us with other OpenTable guests. Glad you had a wonderful night and we look forward to seeing you again soon!
We were very pleased. Delicious food, great service and menu. Fun drink menu, too!
Thank you Amy! So happy you enjoyed everything! We will see you next time!
Family dinner and it was fantastic!!
Thank you so much! We can't wait to see you again soon!
Great Italian Food in Key West! From the appetizer to the dessert this place will not disappoint. Made a reservation and were promptly seated. Drinks were reasonably priced and the food was amazing! Easy to find on Duval Street. Would highly recommend while in Key West!
Thanks Jason - We are so happy you chose to dine with us at La Trattoria! Glad you had a great time and we can't wait to see you again on your next visit!
The food was excellent as was the service. I would highly recommend this place!
Thanks! Glad you enjoyed your night with us! See you again soon!
Stopped here on a whim after making reservations the night before for our anniversary (we were slacking on making timely reservations). This was a decent spot on Duval (although we prefer places off the beaten path) with reasonably priced Italian food. It was busy for a Saturday but we were sat right away and the service was good. Decent food but nothing to rave about. Complimentary dessert was a nice touch!
Great Italian! Virgilios after, perfect night in Key West
A refuge of sanity in the Key West Hustle. Quiet, romantic, great food and service. Italian favorites music playing softly in background. Escargots, and Snapper dish were outstanding. Social Distancing measures were not intrusive. They were maintained but not distractive. Everything looked ",normal."
We dined in on Saturday 6/27th at Trattoria Old Town, they were having issues with the air conditioning! The restaurant was terribly hot on a 100 degree Summer Saturday night! We did not enjoy our dinner due to the hot environment indoors🥵it was way to hot and the food was not as good as we expected, too many issues to give Trattoria a better review
Love this place! Come everytime I come down to the keys
Eggplant appy was pretty good and the spinach and beet salad was nice. Didn’t really care for our pasta unfortunately. We loved our waiter Amar and enjoyed sitting in the window and people watching!
Great place to dine, all of the the staff went above and beyond, our waiter was excellent. Food was top notch. We were in key west for 5 days and made a point to return here for a second dinner. If your looking for a great spot for a delicious dinner with a friendly staff, this is it!
Excellent food and wonderful, attentive service! Will return.
Service was very good. Food was excellent. Will definitely return.
Thank you Becky! So happy you had a great time and enjoyed our food and had amazing service! We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Second time here and it did not disappoint! Some of the best Italian food. Will easily return next time we come back to Key West and would easily recommend to anyone searching for Italian food around the Duval St area.
Always consistent delivering the classics.
Glad you enjoyed! See you next time!
Food was very good but the service was lacking. Drinks were not refilled and we waited 45 min after our reservation to be seated.
Thank you for the feedback. We are so sorry you did not experience the service that we are known for. We are trying our best to continue to honor reservation times, but it can be a challenge at our current COVID restrictions. We are trying to improve every day! We hope to see you again soon!
Best Italian restaurant in town! Strongly recommend! You will enjoy authentic Italian food in Key West!
Thank you Kasia for the kind words! We are so happy you enjoyed your time with us! Thanks for joining us for dinner and we look forward to seeing you again soon!
Everything was great! Nice to see the full menu available. The waiter was a bit over worked but we were fine, knowing they just opened. Thank you for a very nice meal!
Thank you Nancy for sharing your experience. We are doing our very best to adhere to the current COVID guidelines and working daily to improve our operation. Thank you for being understanding and so happy you enjoyed your dinner with us. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Nice place for dinner. Our server was fantastic. Space was nice. Chicken dish was small, but good. Tortellini was good, though sauce was a tad watery. Overall, four stars (5).
Thank you Sean for dining with us! Glad you had wonderful service. We will note the suggestions on the food! Hope to see you again soon!
Great food as usual!
So happy you enjoyed! We will see you next time!
The food is always amazing! The service is always just a great! Consistently fantastic!
Thank you so much for the kind words! So happy you had a wonderful evening with us! We look forward to seeing you again soon!
The food was great, drinks were great and we had wonderful service. What a nice experience. Tortellini was amazing.
Good, not spectacular, Italian fare.
Thanks for joining us for dinner Tom! I hope you enjoyed our service! See you next time!
Very clean. Everyone was wearing protective gloves and menus were disinfected every time they were returned to the hostess stand.
Thank you for dining with us and for noticing the steps we have taken to ensue everyones safety! We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Wonderful waitress, great food and wine. One of our favorite places in key west.
Thank you for the kind words and for choosing to dine with us again! We look forward to your next visit!
The food is good and some item are very good. It is very loud which makes conversation difficult. The wait staff is terrific.
Thank you for dining with us! Glad you enjoyed your dinner and the service! We are a tiny spot, so when it's crowded, the noise level can get a bit loud. Thank you for sharing your feedback!
We have eaten here 3 times in the last 2 months. The first two were quite good, but last night the fish special was only average at best. It was slightly overcooked and did not have the flavor that the other meals I have had there had. My wife's Zuppa di Pesce was very good.
Thank you Mike for sharing your feedback. Thank you for dining with us on several occasions. We do hope you to see you again soon!
We had a reservation made several weeks before. We arrived on time. We were nicely dressed 70-year-olds. The hostesses led us to a table in the back by the entry and exit from the kitchen and viewing the staff workstation. There were many other empty tables. We asked if we could have a nicer table and they said they were very booked so we said we would leave. They were difficult but then decided they could find us another table which they did. Still near the entry to the kitchen but at least with a pleasant view towards the restaurant instead of looking at at the messy work area. As we watched people come in they sat other parties of two at tables for four in much nicer locations. Some of these people were wearing T-shirts and shorts and not at all nicely dressed. We did have a very good waiter and the food was good but I doubt we would return.
Thank you Larry for choosing to dine with us at La Trattoria. So happy you enjoyed your meal and the service. We do our best to accommodate all reservations and their seating requests to the best of our ability. We are Key West Casual and welcome everyone regardless of their choice of attire. We do hope you join us again for our delicious food and amazing service.
Red snapper was delicious.
$$ to $$$ pricing
Bread and olive oil was wonderful.
Thanks for the kind words! So happy you enjoyed everything and we look forward to seeing you again soon!
Thanks so much! Glad you enjoyed!
Nice atmosphere. Friendly staff. Food was average....Snapper was overcooked. Salads were so-so
Thank you for dining with us at La Trattoria! So happy you enjoyed your evening. We look forward to seeing you again on your next visit!
Consistently excellent food - homemade bread and pasta are like your Italian Grandmom used to make. Excellent martini and wine optional. Outstanding service. Busy, relaxed ambiance. One of our go-to and favorite Key West restaurants!
So happy you enjoyed your time with us! We can't wait to see you again! Thanks for the kind words!
Food was good but the ladies room was a disgrace.
Thank you Louie! So glad you enjoyed your meal. We are working on renovations on all restrooms down the road :)
La Trattoria Old Town offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (305) 296-1075.
La Trattoria Old Town is rated 4.6 stars by 1402 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.