Great good and service
Would be perfect with 2 or 3 less tables.
Met with friends before a Papermill show. Nice ambiance and attentive service but the food was a bit slow coming out. 6:15 reservations and we had little time to spare when we finished before an 8:00pm show. The food was good, but not great. Small portions for the prices.
Very good food and service; the only reason for 3 stars rather than 4 was the cost...a little pricey.
Great time. Easy to park. Food was delicious. Chef came out to speak with us after the meal. Fantastic Expeirence!
Going back for the lasagna, I have not tried it but apparently it’s incredible.
Tried to go for Valentine’s Day and had made reservations for 8:15. When I got there, there was a line of people just waiting to be seated! No hosts to greet any of us or to explain what the hold up was. Left after waiting for fifteen minutes. I’m sure food would’ve been decent, but just very unorganized overall.
We are SO OVER LaPergola. While some say the third time is the charm, in this case 3 strikes you are OUT of the Millburn restaurant rotation. With such wonderful choices such as Basilico, DaNico and Cara Mia, you no longer have to deal with the owners NOT honoring reservations, receiving the wrong check twice in one night, average meal ( used to be so much better) and then there is too many tables, lights too low, music on and off, and the wait staff trying their best but running around crazy.
They have NOT honored their reservation time 3 times, we received the wrong check twice, called over the owner, gave him our order and then he sent someone over with the correct check and asked us to pay quickly. The meals have been just ok, not their usual quality. The next night ate at Basilico and had a fabulous meal, great ambiance and courtesy after dinner drinks because our table was not ready. DaNico the week before: greeted like long lost relatives, the chef came out and spoke with everyone in the room and upon leaving, the waiter held the ladies coats!
Great service great food and hospitality
Every bit of food brought to the table was absolutely exquisite.
A great experience. Restaurant was lovely, service attentive but not too attentive. Thoroughly recommend. CAUTION...BYOB. Wine store down the block did not have a great selection.
We had their homemade pasta (squid ink and beet), which was very good. You can order half portions as an appetizer. Our entrees (fish and meat) were good, but not particularly notable. The restaurant was very busy on the Saturday night we were there. We did not wait long for our table, but we did not receive bread and bruschetta that other tables did and had to ask for it. The staff was very busy--everyone rushing around. This did not make for a relaxed setting.
All in all, food good and fairly priced, noise level fairly loud, service was fair.
Excellent flavor profiles in our salads and entrees. We will be back.
Almost all our plates including some chewy calamari and a veal special were woefully under seasoned. In addition, for a restaurant blocks from a playhouse you would expect them to know how to get the food out so everyone makes the show. Our apps arrived quickly but we then waited 45 minutes for our entree. We managed to make the show on time but couldn’t even consider dessert.
Seating was too tight- very crowded.
This is a traditional classy "white tablecloth" restaurant in feel and service. The food is excellent and the service too.
Very nice - food was excellent -looking forward to a return visit very soon.
I had the stuffed artichoke and seared tuna salad. Light, very flavorful, perfectly prepared. service is impeccable. lovely atmosphere. highly recommended!
La Pergola Is the best restaurant in Millburn. The competition is stiff, but La Pergola offers the most consistent and best balanced dining experience. I dine there for both lunch and dinner at least once or twice every month. Why drive into NYC when you can have comparable food and service, right here in downtown Millburn.
The place was way to loud . You could not hear the waiter and I had trouble hearing the person sitting right next to me .
Always enjoy the evening
Always consistently good food and atmosphere!