Food very good...service was spotty. Couldn’t find waiters

We popped in for a quick lunch and were very pleasantly surprised. We ended up ordering an appetizer, champagne and pasta. We lingered and visited. It was fantastic! Delicious food and great ambiance. We will definitely go back.

We ate here last year on our Spring Break trip and it was amazing! This year, however, was beyond disappointing. The gnocchi was truffle based instead of tomato based which gave it a bitter taste and the caprese salad was also changed...not for the better. My husband’s pasta was dry. Too many good restaurants in NYC to go here again.

Food was very authentic Italian. Wait staff knowledgeable and helpful. The fact that they spoke Italian as well made me feel back at home in Italy.

Creative menu, excellent food and dedicated service conveniently located near theatre district

We had a wonderful dinner with terrific service. We were late due to our show running longer than expected, and it was no problem. Have been here before and will return!

Daughter’s birthday....wonderful lunch and they were very, very good about the many food allergies she has. Can’t wait to go back.

It was good, but a little bit pricey for what you get.

this place is fantastic. Great service,professional but unobtrusive. The food was beyond wonderful. The salad was perfectly dresses with fresh ingredients. The pasta was lighter than air and so delicious this may be my new fave place. Alas the desserts looked wonderful but we had theatre tickets and could not try any. I will be back tho' for all these reasons.

Great authentic southern Italian food....great service!!!

Good restaurant but overpriced and that pasta overcooked

The service and food were great, especially the homemade pasta and daily specials.

Excelent for a romantic dinner, this is a superv italian alternative in NYC

Great restaurant ..... Not my first time dining at there. I love it.

Always a terrific experience. Great food and attentive service. If you can, go between 7:30 and 9:30 while everyone else is at the theater. It turns into a quiet neighborhood gem

Extremely efficient service. As per our request, both the salad and main course plates were divided between 2 of us in the kitchen- more than enough food (and very tasty). A little noisy, but a good experience overall.

I highly recommend this fabulous restaurant! We went pre-theatre and absolutely loved everything about our dining experience.
The buratta appetizer was sufficient to share between 4 people & we also had the carpaccio. The rib eye steaks were done to perfection and the vegetarian in our group had the prawns. Also amazing.
P.S. I also recommend the play we saw which was right across the street - Diana. David Bryan (Bon Jovi key board player and song writer for the musical Diana, wAs at the table next yo us with his family and friends for the opening night of previews)

The food was amazing. Wait staff was well versed and extremely accommodating in explaining the specials. Our experience was outstanding. We were served lunch and not rushed out. We had plenty of time to make our 2:00 play perform Highly recommend this lovely place and will be back soon

Excellent food and excellent service!

We did a post-theater dinner, arriving at 10:45 PM. It was a great experience for me and my guest. The servings were generous and absolutely delicious. We split the carpaccio and two pastas, with each of our plates having both pastas presented beautifully. The service was “standout” outstanding. I appreciated the fact that we were not rushed, even given the late hour. La Masseria is a gem!

Fantastic food. Lightest, fluffiest gnocchi I’ve ever had.

We have always enjoyed the food, the service, and the ambiance at La Masseria. Service is outstanding, and the value extended at this fine restaurant is excellent for a fine dining experience in the theatre district. We recommend La Masseria to all friends!

My husband and I enjoyed a late dinner here, post-theatre. I'd been wanting to try the restaurant for some time and happy I finally made it there. The place is beautiful -- a rustic warmth, great lighting and flora -- particularly lovely on a coldish winter night. The service was very attentive and professional and the food was uniformly excellent. I had a fantastic salad with beans and goat cheese and pasta bolognese. He had the fried zucchini and what he said was one of the best veal chops he'd ever had. The portions are actually fairly large. I would definitely share an appetizer next time. We also shared a excellent dessert -- apple tart with ice cream and raspberry sauce. The restaurant is pricey, but no more so than other midtown places of this calibre. And they pour a reasonably sized glass of wine, which is more than many other high-end restaurants do. We will definitely add this to our go-to list for the future.

Restaurant does an excellent job on positioning the tables so you are not sitting side by side next to another party. The gnocchi was delicious and light. The service was excellent ! Will definitely go back.

I had a few issues, overall if you in a hurry to catch a Broadway play, this place will get you out ASAP. I arrived a little early for my reso on Monday night ( theaters are closed) and had a drink with my party, only to be asked to pay the bill rather than move it to the table ( pet peeve), then we were told we had to order out appetizer with dinner at the same time ? Only after I insisted as we had not looked at the menu did the waiter relent and take the app order. Food was great and arrived promptly but no dessert or coffee was offered.

For Italian in NYC, there are many choices. Unless your going to a show nearby, you could do better.

The food is great, and the presentation is wonderful. I thought the service, all of it from the hostess to the wait staff to the bartenders to the servers, was exceptional. I left a big tip because they deserved it!

Excellent food, service and atmosphere. Would recommend to anyone.

Wonderful as always; food delicious, service superb, consistently good in all ways.

Food and service fabulous!
Very convenient location to theaters and Time Square.
The Salmon was the best I have ever had and my friends loved their pasta dishes.

We sat at the bar with Valentina. She is a delight. Food was excellent.

I have been to La Masseria several times when I visit NYC. We were seated upon arrival and the service was prompt. Our meal was very good.

I would definitely go back!

We completely enjoyed our dining experience. The meals were all excellent and the service superb. The waitstaff was attentive and unobtrusive. We spent a longer than normal time and did not feel pressured to finish. This was our third visit and was as outstanding as the first 2 times. We will definitely rerun when we visit NY.

Seemed a little disconnected. Staff was often bunched up chatting. Just not a locked in really good restaurant experience.

One of my favorites! Great place to go on a date or with a group. The grouper special was wonderful!

They told us we didn’t have reservations after a show.

Outstanding service, very good food! Had a late meal after a play.

Everything was wonderful! Our table was perfect, our waiter was attentive and the food was fabulous. Great wine list.

We had a tight schedule and the staff worked with us to meet our timetable.

Very enjoyable...great food and service!

Outstanding food and service. I will be going back soon and will recommend it to friends.