Dined here for restaurant week. While prices were a bit high for us (we don’t live in NYC) the food was delicious and plentiful. When asked if I wanted a second glass of wine I said “not yet” but was brought to me anyway. Waiter had a strong accent and was sometimes difficult to understand. Service was excellent though.

Excellent prompt service post theatre in delightful setting

Great food and Service! Very convenient to theaters and Times Square.

Although a bit pricey we had an amazing meal with wonderful service

Both the food and service were excellent. Meals were beautifully presented, drinks were ample size all enabling us to have a great dining experience. My only issue was finding out later that no Open Table points were given for this visit.

Great food and they checked vaccine cards which was good.

It was my 50th and my sons 20th. We made the trip from Rhode Island .

Went to La Masseria for a pre-theatre dinner. Absolutely delicious dinner, great atmosphere and service right on point! We can’t wait to come back!!!!

One of the most authentic Italian restaurants we've been to in the US. If you're looking for non-authentic dishes like spaghetti and meatballs or chicken parmigiano, this is not the place for you, instead go here for authentic orrechiette with broccolli rabe and sausage, homemade fettuccini with eggplant and fresh mozzarella, or the most succulent pork tenderloin with truffles. Great wine selection and delicious desserts as well!

The service was great. They didn't rush us. The food was delish. I highly recommend the Fettuccini Bolognese. As for noise level it is hard to answer as we were there for lunch and there were open tables. I plan on going back!

Nice dinner and great service! Thank you!

This restaurant has a great location for pre-theater dining. Their pastas are amazing and service professional yet friendly.

Love this place. Our 2nd visit in a month. Unusual for us. The food. Is delicious and service present but not intrusive. Place was a bit quiet so the noise level was fine. looking forward to being able to return..

The food and service were great. I’ll be back!

Celebrating my wife’s birthday and then Book of Mormon

Celebrated my sons Birthday. The gnocchi melted in our mouth!
Great cocktails too. Wonderful staff!

Great food and service. Presentation very nice as well

Always a wonderful experience!

after a show

La Masseria did not disappoint! The food was some of the best we have had. The service was outstanding. It is a bit pricey but I would happily pay anytime for the food and service they provided. We will definitely go back!!!

Food was wonderful. As was the service. The noise level was a bit too much.

Joel is the best waiter in the world!

I took my daughters for dinner before seeing Hamilton. Our waiter was fabulous! He was so friendly and attentive. Food was amazing! They had gluten free pasta for my daughter who is celiac. We had a delicious, relaxing dinner and walked over to see the show just a few blocks away.

We truly enjoyed our evening. Good food and service. We will be back!

Great > don't miss this restaurant if your in NYC and want great Italian cuisine, ambiance, and service.

Our server (don't remember his name, sorry) was attentive and fantastic, as were the bussers (special shout out to them, nothing was finished on the table for more than twenty seconds without them removing it, and they did it completely unobtrusively). Wine list was excellent, but could have used a few more by-the-glass offerings. Food ranged from good to outstanding. We will definitely be back.

Amazing service and food! Highly recommend to anyone looking for a romantic dinner!

Top notch service paired with the best of Italian music that we could sing along (while not being Italian). The menu is traditionally Italian but with some distinguishing regional flavors for sure.

Delicious food, great service. Spaced out the customers well.

Very good food. Service was very fast. Everything went very well in our news year night.

Service by Ronald superb. Whole environment welcoming and warm. Pre Theater dinner was served quickly and was excellent. Will return!

Expensive but delicious! Service was unhurried, but attentive.

Holiday celebration

Our Christmas Eve dinner was a success! Never ate here before but will definitely return on special occasions. A little pricey, but the food, drinks and service were truly amazing.

Christmas with the family. It was great food quiet intimate ambiance

Food and service outstanding! Would recommend for a family meal

Pasta was delicious and my family loved but the main entree is OK but it is not as good for the price I must say.

New favorite gem. Love everything about this place! Food is delicious and can’t get enough of Peach Bliss!

Always delicious and fabulous service.

Excellent food. The service was perfect— attentive-helpful-efficient and very courteous without being intrusive!!
We loved it and will be back