Don't use OpenTable to book here. Although the reservation showed on my list and I received the usual reminders, they had no record of my reservation when I arrived and didn't even seem to know what OpenTable was. As it turned out, they did have room for our party of 5, but we were seated at a back row corner table, and the stage crew ran by us frequently in the show using flashlights, so it was kind of distracting.
It was a nice evening, but I probably would only recommend it for somebody who is highly interested in magic. We went because it gets excellent reviews on TripAdvisor, and they said it was very funny, so we thought it might have wide-spread appeal. There are definitely some funny parts, and the food was reasonably good. The magic show was good, and they get kids 11 and under involved at one part. We just aren't all that into magic though, so for the money, I would have preferred a really nice dinner at one of Maui's excellent restaurants.
Ths food was quite good given the large amount of people that had to be served at the same time, I was pleasantly suprised.
This was not about the food though, this was about the magic show. The show was thoroughly enjoyable and a night well spent. My wife and I had a great evening and clearly the rest of the audience enjoyed it as much as we did.
The food was surprisingly tasty, and courses came out so fast. magic was not David Copperfield level but still entertaining never less. Would recommend this show to anyone visiting Maui!