See availability for bonus point tables
Fri - Sat 9:45PM - 11:00PM
We like Kefi because it’s a restaurant with something for everyone on the menu, and it’s multi-purpose like a Swiss Army knife. A date, lunch with moms, Greek Easter brunch, a night out with the ladies…it all works.
The service was very disappointing. The entrees took about 30 minutes to arrive after they cleared the appetizer. One of the meals was incorrect and sent back. The waitress said it would be a minute and then it took over ten minutes. They were not apologetic.
Had a great early dinner on Sunday evening.....food was delicious, good service, great time
Delicious food. Good service. Nice lively atmosphere.
Didn’t honor reservation. Had to wait 45 min past reservation time. Once we finally got seated it took forever to get our food
We ate at Kefi on Saturday night. It took 1.5 hrs to get our meal. We were about to walk out.
As always, great food, great service, but the whole place needs a face lift. It is too dark, no character, no ambience. we only go there for a consistently good food and quick service, but we wish it were a little bit more pleasant inside so we could come here more often with friends.
The food was ok, chicken was undercooked. My waitress wasn’t very attentive, nor polite.
The food was great and filling. We especially loved the steak and meatballs. The noise level was a little loud and it was difficult to hear.
The food was delicious--especially the ricotta dumplings and the mixed grill. The service was a little slow, but the place was packed, so it was understandable. Kefi was crowded but very cozy and welcoming--we would definitely come back when we're on the UWS!
Food is good, but not great. Service was terrible. It took forever for a waiter to come over to us, forever to order, and forever to get the check. Not in a hurry to return.
Greek Easter with my father was a lovely experience.
The food was VERY flavorful, staff friendly and efficient.
Granted this review is written when I was treated at Kefi both times. Still, the food is excellently portioned and of great quality for the price. Service is attentive and while atmosphere is a bit loud, it's not too hard to hear due the tables being a litter shorter in width.
Food was lacking flavor and price was extremely high for quality of food. I ordered the whole grilled Branzino, it was small with barely any meat on it. Martinis were a thumbs down
Wonderful dinner with friends at Kefi. The mixed appetizer and entrées were delicious, the service pleasant and prompt, the drinks well made and the price reasonable. I loved the seafood paella, my wife the branzino.
Second time to Kefi, and just as wonderful as the first. Our server was just excellent, and her wine suggestions were spot on. Will definitely be back.
Kefi always reliable. Excellent service and nice neighborhood feel.
We understand that they were busy and short-staffed but we got there before the rush and we had to ask for everything: for our order to be taken, for our food to come, to get the bill. It was a 2.5 hour lunch. It was embarrassing for me with my out-of-town company.
Sadly we had a horrible experience here. Waited over an hour for food. Obviously something amiss in the kitchen.
We had a 7:00 pm reservation and showed up a few minutes early. A man and woman were at the captain's stand, maybe two feet away. They pretended we didn’t exist. We stood there. And stood there. Eventually my wife said “Excuse me, we have a reservation”. Startled, they grudgingly took us to a nearby table.
We ordered Zucchini Fritters, two glasses of house wine, the shrimp with orzo for my wife and the Lamb Burger for me. The menu said that the Lamb Burger was made with ground pork. The waitress recommended I have the burger cooked “medium”. I agreed. She left.
We waited. After a half hour or so, the fritters showed up. We inhaled them. The plates were cleared. Then we waited for our entrees. And waited.
More apologies. The waitress offered us another glass of wine, on the house. Neither of us wanted more wine, but OK. The wine came. The food didn’t.
We had been in our seats more than an hour and twenty minutes when the entrees came. I tore into my “Lamb Burger”, and it was raw in the middle. Not rare, not medium, but raw. Pink and mushy. Raw pork.
I called the manager, who had already apologized for the delays. He asked if I’d like something else, and I said we’d already spent too much time there. I asked for the check and said I was not paying for the uncooked Lamb-with-Raw-Pork Burger. My wife ate her shrimp dish. It was good (though only four shrimp).
We waited in vain for a check. We were about to leave, when the waitress finally brought it. She said the manager had comped the appetizer and not charged us for the burger. I paid in cash and wrote on the check “You should be ashamed of the incompetent service”. We had been there over an hour and forty minutes. And still I never had dinner.
From the minute we walked in, the staff were inept. The greeters rudely ignored us. The floor staff showed up once in a while, while the food never did. And then, when it did, to serve raw pork on top of it all?
We won't go back.
Super slow service! Won’t be back!
The waitress was so friendly and attentive. The food was hot - and almost too hot but that's not a complaint. I will definitely come back here
At Feki we can find a very good Greek food in a very good venue of Manhattan. Very good bear too.
Kefi is always wonderful, the food special and the service excellent. But we 'fell' into the timing for a little publicized prix fixe menu which gave us some of the really good items for a low price. We hadn't planned on it, actually added a zucchini fritters mezze and it still was a bargain.
Always excellent - this time a better deal than even during Restaurant Week!
The food was good in respect to the price. The ambience was fine and not too noisy at the time we went. It took awhile for us to get our drinks. We had good service ultimately but the dessert description was misleading.
Kefi is a nice neighborhood restaurant whose Greek/Mediterranean menu is a welcome departure from the more typical Italian/American restaurants that predominate on Columbus Ave. Food is thoughtfully prepared and service is attentive. Nice wine list, including by the glass.
Great happy hour at the bar.
Met up with special friends. Wanted to enjoy terrific conversation and company with great food and drinks in a great setting. Kefi is all of that and a wonderful value at that!
We were excited to experience Kefi. We sat in the front bar room as the lighting in the upper mezzanine dining room was very bright. The food was good, especially the fish. Unfortunately the service was very poor. It may have been because our waitress had the back dining room as well as our table and did not check on us often. Both times we wanted additional drinks we needed to ask a busser to get our waitress.
Another unfortunate problem is the restaurant front doors were open as we were told the A/C was not functioning. Right next door is a bar and the smoke from their partons smoking out front entered the restaurant and was irritating.
Grilled fish was excellent. Service was attentive yet unobtrusive.
Fantastic service in a beautiful space and a short walk from the American Museum of Natural History. Tsaziki was awesome as was baklava, margarita, and chicken souvlaki. Fresh, beautifully prepared food.
Kefi is one of the best restaurants in the area and always delivers consistently fresh, delicious food with friendly and professional service. The mezze are authentic, and the menu is creative with offerings such as sheep milk dumplings with merguez, or braised rabbit with pappardelle. I usually choose from the "simply grilled" section, either a fantastic whole trout, or an impeccable piece of center cut salmon filet (though lamb and beef are also offered in this category). I don't usually like broccoli rabe, but Kefi's chef does a beautiful version that is delicious, smooth and mellow to accompany the grilled item. The wine selections are well differentiated and the staff really knows the varieties. Great spot. Kefi has been consistently excellent for the seven or eight years we have eaten there.
shared mezzes - beets, zucchini pancakes and warm feta cheese. all excellent followed by branzino, superb. terrific friendly service
Enjoyed Kefi for a date night on valentine's day .
It was our first time at this restaurant and it was absolutely delicious. We had the potato salad, the sea bass and the lamb chops and it was full of flavor cooked perfectly.
Great service and good drinks as well!
I can’t wait to come back.
I always enjoy a meal at Kefi and recommend it often. An UWS gem!
I didn't realize how large Kefi was! I was seated immediately, and was allowed to wait for my friend to arrive at my table (it's always annoying to have to wait for the whole party to get seated for a reservation). We were seated downstairs, which was equally as busy as it was upstairs and the atmosphere was arguably even better downstairs as well. The food was absolutely delicious and was prepared very quickly. Our server was really helpful with both food and wine recommendations. I'll definitely be coming back!
Food was greasy and bland. Salt and pepper didn’t help much. There are so many great Greek places in NYC. There is no need to revisit this one. I won’t be back.
I have been to Kefi many times and this time it was not as good as previous times. The service was a bit off. It took a long time for us to get our food and appetizers came out at various time, some with the main courses. Some main courses came out when most of us were finished. The chips that are normally so delicious we just ok. Any place can have an off night. I hope that the next time I go, it will be back to normal.