Joey Gerard's - A Bartolotta Supper Club - Greendale
The menu at Joey Gerard’s features a variety of steaks, seafood and sandwiches, as well as traditional nightly specials such as fish fry, prime rib and more. Lazy Susans, a relish tray on every table, and classic cocktails and ice cream drinks add to the supper club experience.
Fabulous & great food in every detail. Awesome Easter brunch with everything you could desire.
I was blown away by our server, Alex. If every place had servers like him there would never be any complaints. The food was excellent and we will defiantly return!
Excellent early evening family gathering. Food and drinks were first class, and Joey our server provided perfect service without being overbearing. "We'll be baacck"!
A neighborhood favorite. Friday’s fish fry w/potato pancakes is consistently good, but I’m especially partial to their steaks. You can’t beat the popover appetizer and the Green Goddess dressing served with the relish tray is worth the trip. Service is always excellent.
We went to celebrate a Birthday of a friend. The food was excellent. The complimentary Birthday dessert with candle was really tasty and light...not heavy after a great meal. The old fashioned drinks are wonderful and we will be back to celebrate another occasion.
We have been coming here for several years now, usually for our wedding anniversary and birthdays. The food is wonderful. We just love the supper club atmosphere. We always come an hour before our reservation to sit at the awesome bar to have a drink or two before dinner. Have to have an old fashioned when at a supper club.
Outstanding old school supper club experience.
We enjoyed a couple drinks and a fish fry at Joey Gerards. The price of this meal is in the upper range for fish fries in the area. The fish and coleslaw were excellent, but we felt the french fries were pretty much average crinkle cut fries that you find everywhere that this type of meal is served. The mediocre fries are the only part of this Friday favorite that we feel could be improved a bit.
The food and service was spot on! We had a time set and we were sat at the scheduled time. We look forward to going again in the near future.
My birthday dinner with my family was amazing per usual!
I have trouble getting steak cooked well done at many upscale restaurants, but my steak was cooked to absolute perfection, well done and so tender. The schaum torte was just like my mom used to make. All around a fantastic dinner.
This was hands down the best dinner experience I’ve had in my life! The wagyu New York strip was the best steak I’ve ever had. The seasoning was perfect and the flavor was amazing.
Food is tasty but sometimes served Luke warm. Also I hate that I only have one Chardonnay to choose from! A nice restaurant like that I would think would have more choices. Our server rushed us quite a bit. When we are having dinner with friends we like to relax and chat awhile over drinks.
Beautiful place, delightful staff and very awesome food.
Fantastic dinner. Best duck I have ever tasted in town. Beautiful portions, quality, display and excellent staff.
We can't wait to dine there again!
We really enjoyed our visit. It was our 40'th wedding anniversary. We had our grandchildren with us and the staff welcomed them with open arms, which we really appreciated, since we wanted them to share in our big day. The strawberry schaum torte that was a complimentary dessert was amazing. It's these types of things that keep bringing us back.
Had 6 o'clock reservations and had to wait about 10 minutes to get seated.
Overall, the experience was good. Our waitress Brittany was excellent in explaining the menu and specials that were available. The issue came with the food. Every dish, excluding the delicious and perfectly cooked Shrimp Cocktail and Shrimp Scampi was incredibly salty. The steaks, asparagus, spinach, lobster, were all just so incredibly overpowered by salt. We did not complain as we were incredibly hungry and did not want to wait 45 minutes more for virtually every plate to be remade and we we’re celebrating two important events and did not want to cause an issue. Also, the person we were celebrating could not finish her steak and instead had to take it to go because it was not edible due to it being over cooked and incredibly salty. We LOVE Bartolotta Restaurants and the food, however next time we will most likely go to Lake Park Bistro or Mr. B’s as the food there is always prepared perfectly. Had our waitress not been a perfect 10/10 we most likely would have complained to the manager.
Love the supper club retro atmosphere. Great menu. Price on par with other Bartolotta properties.
We went to Joey Gerard’s in Greendale to celebrate my birthday. We were pleased to be treated to a complimentary bread basket and relish tray. Our host and server were very friendly. The latter invited us to join Bartolotta’s loyalty group online, which we did. Although the prices are not inexpensive, the food was terrific, and it’s good to know we can now save money with our loyalty card. The chicken marsala and garlic spinach were wonderful. The consistency of the mashed potatoes seemed to be on the verge of liquid but were still tasty. A bigger plate would have helped me feel more at ease while cutting the chicken, as I had to be very careful not to push any of the spinach, (almost runny) mashed potatoes, delicious marsala sauce with mushrooms or the chicken itself off the edge. My partner’s full rack of ribs were large and tasty. I would have liked the ribs to come with a vegetable side, but I guess he could have ordered one and paid more if he wanted. He said that the ribs weren’t the best he’d ever had (although they may have been the most expensive), but he enjoyed them, nevertheless. I was treated to a complimentary dessert of hardened merengue, vanilla ice cream, whipped cream & raspberry drizzle for my birthday. Although most of it was quite yummy, the consistency of the hardened merengue wasn’t really to my liking, so my partner was treated to a portion of it. I look forward to to trying the Bananas Foster for dessert during my next visit to Joey Gerard’s.
Wanted someplace special for our 37th anniversary. We found it at Joey's. My Kansas City Strip steak was fantastic, perfectly done (medium rare) my wife's Scallops were also perfect. Our waiter was very helpful and attentive. When the meal was served, there was spinach on my plate instead of the asparagus I ordered, he apologized and there was a side of asparagus delivered within a minute. It was a 45 minute drive to get there, we have a couple places closer to home, but I wanted someplace special and found it at Joey's. It is not the place I can do on a weekly basis, but I definitely will be back. I will look for more special occasions. Joey's has set a new standard of what I look for in a Steakhouse.
We had a wonderful time and the meal was delicious.
Thanks so much!
Overall a very pleasant experience celebrating a family birthday. We will return.
We had a delicious fish fry. Wait staff professional. Joey Gerard's never disappoints us!!!!!
The food was good. But not a lot of it for the price. 4 scallops for 35 dollars.... Not good. But they were good. My wife had salmon , which she loved , she ate the whole thing , which was a very small portion. Not good. The food was very good but very , very small portions for the high prices!!!
Attentive service without feeling pushy or rushed. Friendly supper club atmosphere. Steaks were spot on but overly salty as was most of the food. Could use updates to appetizer and dessert menu.
We always have such a positive experience at this restaurant! Great bar and drink specials!
I love the super club atmosphere. The food was great, but food was rushed as we had not finished our salads when our main course arrived. Table was really too small to comfortably handle our salad plus the main course. Overall though, a lovely and intimate dining experience. We will return...
Ashley was our server and she was great! We used a $20 birthday card my wife had received and a $20 gift certificate that I had received when I bought a hundred dollar gift card for a friend last year. She and the hostess corrected an error that charged me for the gift card in November. Fantastic service as always!! And of course- the best food!
The steaks were delicious and cooked perfectly.
Best place for a fancy upscale Wisconsin Supper Club experience.
Food is awesome! Could not stop eating it! Food is at the Chef Ramsey level... your taste buds explode!
The food and the service is what's expected of a Bartollata ResTo. A bit too dark for a supper club and not so comfy chairs and table, given we were on a booth. The plates could ba a tad bigger for their serving so you can eat it better. Overall, good experience.
Filet was sent back twice because it wasn’t
This was our first visit to Joey Gerard's and based on the delicious food and impeccable service courtesy of our waitress Kim we will definitely be back!
Food as always was good. Took awhile for our waitress to come see us. Once she did come to ask about drinks, we were ready to order. Food came quick, but we felt rushed as we were leaving 30 minutes after our reservation. Did not seem relaxing, more rushed to move in the next couple.
Staff was very informative and attentive . Food was exceptional and timing was great. Not rushed overall was very enjoyable . will be back.
Excellent modern version of a Wisconsin supper club.
Server was extremely attentive.