Overall food was good. My friend had one of their specials - halibut. It came on a bed of grilled corn. For the price of $44, she felt the price was too high for the lacking side although she did say the halibut was prepared perfectly. We both enjoyed the crab stack and I liked my cioppino. Service was good. Waited a little bit for check to be picked up since waiter was serving a huge party also.
Only snag was restaurant reported to Opentable that we didn't show up for our reservation. Don't appreciated that snafu when we spent $100+ on dining there.
This was the most expensive restaurant that we dined at during our 10 days in mammoth.
That said the food wine and service were very good
Wonderful meal and service with a stellar wine list. Having eaten at all of the go to places in Mammoth this is top 2-3 along with Lakefront. Did not get to Convict as the weather turned but what a treat!
The food was good, price was to be expected for a resort town. Service was good at the beginning and then our waiter just disappeared towards the end of our meal. Never asked about drinks once we received our first one. Had to wait for 30 minutes after we finished our meal before waiter came to check on us and to get the check.
Great food beautiful and not chaotic
Last night in Mammoth and we wanted a special meal. These guys delivered. We loved the flaming cheese, the 6 dipping sauces, the loup de mer - cooked to perfection. what a great night and meal. Only weird thing with all this excellent cooking my son's risotto was way undercooked. He ate the entire thing and said it was interesting to eat. I tasted it, it was only partially cooked. If they had cooked it correctly WOW!!!! The meal would have been perfection.
All was good except for my Mushroom Risotto which was not good at all. Specifically, it was dry, pasty and flavorless. I am still kicking myself for not mentioning this to our waiter at the time but I was trying to turn over a new less-grumpy leaf in my life. I guess it was my mistake for ordering it at a Greek fish restaurant but then I have found that not every restaurant offers it and when they do it is usually excellent. My order had the consistency and taste of "left over from yesterday". My mistake, as I admit, but all else was good - waiter, service, ambience, etc. - even the extra large round cheese wafer they jammed upright into the middle of the dish. It was Holy Week after all.
Always love coming to this place when we are in Mammoth. Our table ordered the Greek salad, poached pear salad, the halibut, and king crab legs. The seafood was fresh and delightful. The salads were awesome! We also finished with the chocolate flourless torte which was to die for. I definitely recommend this place! It is certainly our new favorite place in mammoth.
Greek salad was the only item that I can imagine going back there for. Halibut special was not a lot of flavor. Chicken was dried.
Unfortunately, our order was completely lost and we waited for well over an hour for entrées after everyone around us had been served, even those who came in very late after us. At the time my entrée arrived, it was cold and was not cooked through and was obviously hurried. I sent it back. The waiter did a good job accommodating us as did the manager by offering a free glass of wine, an additional salad, and we took a dessert home without charge. It ended up being a long pretty frustrating dinner. The food at Jimmy's is very good and I have eaten there before and will again but this was very disappointing as I brought special guests with me and touted the restaurant ahead of time as to how good it was.
Excellent dinner. The food and wine list are fantastic
Good food, solid wait service but owner needs to do something about barking and militant hostess even with a reservation, poor form.
The food was okay (particularly the flaming cheese, which was excellent). Service was fine. Nice decor. Restaurant was extremely quiet, but not too surprising for a Sunday night.
The menu listed on OpenTable is not the real menu. There is no burger, there are no gyros. Everything that remain is substantially more expensive; the cheapest entree was around $25. This felt like a bait 'n switch, particularly since I went with some price-conscious friends, carefully selected a restaurant that looked good, and proceeded to drag the group into a more expensive meal than anticipated.
That's the opposite of hospitality. Update your menu online.
A little gem that I've overlooked for the past few years. Great ambiance and even tastier food. Great place for dinner with your significant other or even a good sized group. Fresh fish, huge cuts of meat, and great wines. Portions run large; shareable with the addition of appetizers, or filling enough after a hard day skiing.
Great food & service. Lovely ambiance.
Great, fine dining in the heart of Mammoth that still retains that fun, cozy vibe you expect in a ski resort town. Probably the best fish you can get in Mammoth. Tons of tasty starters, salads and mains. You can eat heavy or keep it light. Highly recommend and will go back again.
We are from LA and don’t know many restaurants up here but this came up on open table and all of the reviews were great. Had some boarders on the hill suggest it as well and it was delicious!! The portions for some things are on the smaller side— such as the Spanikopita (spelling) — but so yummy! The lamb is a must have!!
We can with many kids and the restaurant was more upscale than we had known. We were treated very graciously none the less.
Great location right in Mammoth - Food was great and the service was spot on - Great option while up in the mountains for seafood or meat dishes
We were rushed out since table was reserved for another reservation. Ok experience food was great.
Excellent Resturant. Service was at the highest quality from start to finish. Would highly recommend visiting here during your stay at Mammoth Mountain.
Amazing place, great customer service and the food was incredible . Five star all the way !!! Had an amazing time .
I absolutely love this place. From the greetings of the Maite d’, to the amazing servers— congratulations to Stewart on the birth of his son... Tonight while we waited for our wine to decant (recommended to us by the Sommelier on our last visit- Chip— a ‘98 Chateau Musar from the Bekka Valley in Lebanon( ( delicious, unusual, full-bodied, deep earthy tones, no tanniny bite... )) Stewart brought us a lovely brut champagne to keep us busy. The kumo oysters were simple and buttery- great with the champagne; as were the babaganoush and spicy feta and garlic dip. Their ceviche with shrimp, calamari, and sacallops— tender, fresh, and so juicy. My husband had the moussaka— fabulous, especially served piping hot on this cold winter day! I had their special... a Surf and Turf Oscarof filet done very rare the way I like with tender lobster on top. I had the bernaise on the side and it was difficult not to lick the bowl clean. And the mashed potatoes with black truffles— mmm!... served with tender perfectly prepared asparagus. The executive chef,
Jeremy, came to check up on us and we wound up having a wonderful conversation. He was completely available to answer our questions and take care of us. The place was busy, always seems to be... but we always feel like we are the only ones there!!! We arrived so early today that Chip, the Sommelier hadn’t arrived yet. When he did he came over to see us and “catch up”— what a smart, elegant, gentle-man!!! And to top it off, the bartender remembered us from our previous visit (we’ve been here twice but I feel like I’ve been coming here for years) and despite that we had been sipping a peach cognac with our goat cheesecake and berries, he came over to mention that he remembered running out of the peaty Scotch I had wanted and now wanted to present me with it— an Ardbergh!!!! The whole evening was fabulous from stem to stern. We’ll be back next week!!! Definitely 5-Stars all the way!!!!
My favorite restaurant in Mammoth. The fresh fish was excellent. The saganaki is a great appetizer choice.
Great food and excellent service!
A wonderful dining experience, amazing cocktails, fish and dessert!! We will definitely be back on our next trip to Mammoth!!
Great experience....sommelier had a nice list of hard to find pinots at a really fair price. My son enjoyed the 3....2....1....Opah! The food is probably best in Mammoth.
I love this place but there are two things which need to be addressed. No kids menu.... $2 charge for extra pita bread pieces which dont even make one whole pita...
The service was great....the food was delicious, it was a great evening with friends. My favorite was the octopus salad. And everyone loved the baklava.
The food was delicious, not strictly Greek but rather pan-Mediterranean with big delectable doses of Italy and Lebanon. I loved the muhammara. Prices are rather high but the food and service were great, so we're happy; we of modest budget will reserve Jimmy's for very special occasions. And we'll stand back when they ignite the saganaki. I think they were experimenting with flame height that night. Opa indeed!
We had the special for the evening and it was delicious with enough left over for another meal. However, it was a bit on the pricey side. The wait staff and owner were very friendly. .
Excellent food and service but definitely comes at a price.
It was closed and will be until mid-Jan 2018. They should t be currently listing on your site.
We had a reservation we made on open table and the restaurant was closed.
We made reservations on open table and got several confirmation emails with a confirmation text. Restaurant was Closed!!!
Terrible way to celebrate
My BD was awesome. The food was great.
Food was overpriced. Appetizer sauces were bad. Hummus and baba ganoush were awful despite being costly. All food was way overpriced for the quality.
We dined here on a week night. The service was perfect, including the wine sommelier, Chip,
who perfectly paired our meals with wine selection. The risotto was excellent, I have never had better risotto in my life, and I am from Chicago! My dining partner had the scallops, which were also excellent. Our appetizer of flaming saganaki was done perfectly! It was a very enjoyable evening.
What a night! An incredible meal, starting with flaming Saganaki cheese accompanied by super Grey Goose martini's. The meal that followed? Super. The staff was outstanding. Our anniversary dinner was an complete success.
We've been to Jimmy's a number of times, and everything we've had has been delicious. Atmosphere is very pleasant. One of the two best restaurants in Mammoth!