J. Gilbert’s – Wood Fired Steaks & Seafood - Worthington
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Mr. Joe's Steak Sauce
Kansas City style steak sauce to honor our roots on tables now
Steak + Frites*
flat iron steak, brown butter sauce, french fries, romesco sauce
Excellent steaks. My brother had the Kansas City strip and he loved it. I recommend the fixe prix menu as you get a lot of value for the money.
4 year anniversary was really nice food was good
Went to J Gilbert’s after the Ohio State University Football game. Great food - always a good experience!
I had 6oz filet - it was perfect! My husband had the maple glazed salmon & it was delicious! We are always pleased - have never been disappointed with our meals.
Steak was tender. Mashed potatoes were more like chunks. The green beans were cold, I asked for another batch and they brought them out hot the second time around. Crab cake was also dry and over cooked. The carrot cake was very dry but the icing outside was great! Service was really slow and there was open tables.
My wife and I have been to J.Gilbert's many times over the years. Usually about twice per year, with an additional carry-out order or two for the past couple of years. Food and prep was excellent as always. However, our waitress was fairly new, and seemed to be overwhelmed with her customers. She had a group of 8 or 10 that really bogged her down. She came to us quickly, and was friendly and pleasant with a good sense of humor. She took wine orders and delivered the drinks. We decided to wait a few minutes before ordering, but she didn't have time to take the order for 50 minutes after delivering our wine. Then, the salads came out and my wife's dressing was forgotten. We had to ask another waitress for the dressing. 1 or 2 minutes into our salad, and our food arrived. We set the salads aside and ate our food while it was hot, and the steaks and salmon were excellent. Not a very good experience for our wedding anniversary, and definitely the only bad experience at J.Gilbert's we have had.
Seth was exceptional ! We had a fabulous family dinner and it was wonderful to have such top of the live service and delicious meals. Not one complaint Thank you for another good experience.
2nd visit was just as good as the first. Service and food was excellent all around. Prices are on high side but generally worth it.
The food is to die for and the service is always outstanding.
Excellent food, service and just a great experience. Our server was really good and the dining experience was one of the best in recent memory
We’ve been celebrating our anniversary at J Gilberts since 2008. During those years The food and service have been consistently excellent.
Good food and service. Always enjoy an evening at J. Gilbert’s.
Anniversary dinner! Wow what a delicious meal!! I had filet with crab cake, whipped potatoes and pecan green beans started with crab bisque ate it before I could take photo. My wife had filet with grilled shrimp potatoes and grilled asparagus and both had cream brûlée for dessert And piece of carrot cake on the house to go!!
We love this place. The atmosphere is that of an old style steak house. The food is always good. The service is top notch. My steak this visit was over cooked but they immediately replaced it and my sides too. Highly recommend.
My wife and I love the atmosphere and service. We visit the Westerville location for every special dinner. The service is always exceptional, the food cooked to perfection and they always add a special perk to special date nights (I.e. birthdays and anniversaries). Be sure to join the email club to get all special dinning events.
Hands down outstanding all around. I 100% suggest trying the filet/crab cake combo.
I have been a J Gilberts patron for over 20 years. The reason is simple…..consistent quality of service and food prep.
Very nice nite out
We celebrated my husband’s birthday here. The food was good but it came out quickly. We were seated in a booth that had work station behind my husband. At one point someone dropped a glass behind him and he jerked (since he thought it was going to fall in him!). It wasn’t the best location to be seated for a special event. At one point we were done with dinner and had to wait a bit for our server. I would’ve liked another glass of wine but it was not offered. While the food was delicious, we would try somewhere else next time to celebrate.
Great food as always. Disappointed several items missing from menus but pleased the mushroom risotto is back!
Our food was excellent from appetizer to entree to desert. My filet mignon was perfectly grilled and it came with the biggest baked potato I've ever been served. Two sides were included with the price, a nice departure from other restaurants where sides are extra. My wife said her seafood mixed grill was excellent. One hostess was wearing a mask and one was not. Our wait person was wearing her mask covering both her nose and mouth. The other wait person in our seating area was wearing his mask only covering his mouth not his nose. Our orders were taken in reasonable time, and food was delivered by the back waiters in reasonable time. But our wait person disappeared for long periods of time without checking on us. It's a good thing nothing was amiss.
All was just as it should have been service,food,ect. Awesome
Filets melted in our mouths. Celebrated our anniversary…. Outstanding!
We have never been disappointed with anything at J. Gilberts! Burgers, pasta and of course the steaks, are amazing!
My husband and I have been to J. Gilbert’s a few times now and have not been disappointed. We had an especially good server tonight, Ryan, who made the experience even better than usual. The cocktails are delicious - the smoked old fashioned is great, but even just their martinis and manhattans are always tasty. I highly recommend the crab bisque, the filet with the lobster mac and cheese, and their chocolate velvet cake. We’ll definitely be going back.
Wonderful food excellent service. The steak grilled over wood very special. Had KC strip excellent. Mixed seafood grill was also excellent. Prix fixe menu good value
This was our second time to J. Gilberts. We brought some friends along for this visit. We enjoyed the atmosphere and the service.
Excellent deals on the menu, short of a pick 3 option. 1/2 prices bottles of wine in Sunday. Great bar and happty hour.
Great food and service!
Amazing experience! Very good food and server gave many helpful selections. We will definitely be back!
Our server was fantastic! Food and wine recommendations were on point. Hubby's steak could have used a bit more flavor but would not deter us from returning!
Our waiter was attentive and knowledgeable. Our food was cooked perfectly and tasted great. Haven’t had a bad meal here yet.
My favorite restaurant! Kim is the best server and our food is always delicious!
Food was great. Our server, Jackson, was exceptional. We’ll be back!
First time visiting J Gilberts. Usually frequent another steak house in town, but things appears to be off at that establishment. Trying to find another steak restaurant we enjoy. The service was great. The filets that I had were hot temperature wise, but not as tender as I like. I guess we would return again.
I hadn't been here in 20 years and I can't wait to go back! It was fantastic.
The atmosphere is quiet which is perfect for conversation. The food is consistently excellent. Carolina, as always, provides top-notch service!
My husband and I had great date night here and would definitely dine here again.
Loved this place! The service was so fantastic and the food was delicious! We went for my husband's birthday and had the nicest time.
Top end steaks. Enjoyed our appetizers also. The Cajun penne pasta was excellent. Salmon very good as well. We will go back for another special occasion.
J. Gilbert’s – Wood Fired Steaks & Seafood - Worthington offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (614) 840-9090.
J. Gilbert’s – Wood Fired Steaks & Seafood - Worthington is rated 4.7 stars by 5655 OpenTable diners.
J. Gilbert’s – Wood Fired Steaks & Seafood - Worthington does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.landrysinc.com/giftcards/default.asp.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.