Wonderful restaurant with amazing food! I will definitely be returning

Never fails to meet and exceed our expectations. We've never had a bad meal here. Service is always as it should be. Have been here several times & will return again. Worth the drive from Dayton.

Food was wonderful. Service was amazing. One of my top overall restaurant experiences!

We had a amazing time as usual food service and everything was on point👍🏻

This restaurant was the perfect place for our 10yr anniversary.

Waiter was awesome. Food just as awesome!

Phil was very attentive and we had a wonderful dining experience.

We love this restaurant. One of our favorites. Can’t wait to return.

Everything was delicious, and the service was fantastic

Awesome The food was excellent and live the quiet environment!

Great evening out with my husband!!

Always enjoy eating at this restaurant.

We decided to try J Gilbert's for our special first anniversary dinner and we were definitely NOT disappointed. What a wonderful mean in an intimate setting. My husband and I both had the 6oz filet with scallops, grilled asparagus and mashed potatoes. The wedge salad was amazing! The creme brulee was heaven. To top it off, they gave us a complimentary glass of champagne to top off the dinner and a free dessert (we had to take it home) to celebrate our special day. Our waiter was top notch. Had great recommendations and was on the spot with everything we asked. He was so professional. Can't wait to go back!

We love going to J GIlberts for dinner, it is a nice romantic place to take your date or significant other....the food has always been delicious, and the service impeckable!1

I have dined at some the best steakhouses in the area but I always come back to J Gilbert's. It's our goto place for special occasions and just for a evening out.

J Gilbert's is consistently great and this was no exception.
The food was prepared exactly as described, the meat cooked to perfection.
Their dinners include 2 nicely sized sides that are also creative and fabulous.
Our waiter was knowledgeable and friendly without being obtrusive.
All employees were masked, we kept ours on except when food was on the table.
Also Sundays are half price on most bottles of wine, with a good list.
So glad we went back here.

Our waiter Phil was simply amazing!! Great conversation, recommendations, and service! Thank you so much for a wonderful great experience! I’ve told my friends to check you out, and ask for Phil!!!

One our favorite places! Steaks are sooo good!! Also have the best salmon I've ever had! Request Karolina... great server.. great attitude.. she makes our dinners perfect!

If ever in the mood for just a burger.. they have a really good burger on a pretzel bun with sweet potato fries!!

Server was tardy in greeting us and MIA for long pros of time. The food was good, however not what we ordered.

Steaks were subpar...my wife’s ny strip was tough and my bone-in ribeye was “string”...calamari was marginal at best...we did have a Duckhorn Merlot which was the highlight of the evening...not sure if we’ll ever go back...disappointing!!!

Another great visit to J. Gilberts. We have never been disappointed there. Great food, Great service, only thing wrong this time is they didn't have a beer I wanted, so I got something else. Our Favorite Restaurant (well except for the one at the Merrion Hotel in Dublin...Ireland not Ohio!)

All around a great experience! Great food with Great service

Overall was good. Waiter was attentive. Food was tasty!

The food quality was great and the service was outstanding. We had the seafood mixed grill which was extremely flavorful.

The food and atmosphere is amazing. One of my favorite restaurants in town!

Not the best meal we've had there. Our steaks were dry and tough. Service was ok but not great. For a $200+ meal, it was not up to par. We've eaten here many times and always had exceptional experiences, so I'm chalking this up as an outlier.

Everything was exceptional except for the carrot cake which I found lacking. I am sure others may like it but it was not what I would expect a true carrot cake to be. It was too dense and lacking flavor. Not the end I expected to a perfect meal.

Anniversary

Always a great dining experience!

The steaks were melt in your mouth perfection. We loved the pretzel coated onion rings. Baked potatoes were cooked to a great tenderness. Loved the sourdough bread.

Awesome server. Just the best! She was very patient with my 88-year-old Mother....she loves to chat. Thank you for a great evening.

Food was great but service was awful. This is one of our favorite places. If we are gonna spend $150+ on a meal, the service should be spot on.
Our waiter seemed to be high or drunk (maybe both). Didn’t want to listen as I was placing my order. Messed up multiple items despite being told multiple times.
This was just a very disappointing experience.

Always great food and service

As always, the service and food were excellent. We have been dining regularly at J GILBERTS for over 10 years, and we are never disappointed.

This is by far one of the best restaurants in the Columbus area, we have been there many times and never disappointed.
The staff has always been top notch, and food top quality I highly recommend J. Gilbert's.
PS, the carrot cake is the best I have ever had give it a try!

Fantastic!!

Wonderful evening. Delicious food and atmosphere. All Covid precautions were taken.

J Gilberts is always consistently great. The food and service are amazing. Never disappointed. Was able to social distance and felt totally safe there.

The food was unbelievably tasty. Only had the seafood and I devoured it all, plate clean, belly full and completely satisfied. Thank you!

We arrived a bit early for our reservation and we were happily accommodated which was great. Upon getting seated, it took over 10 minutes for a waiter to acknowledge us which I am not used to at a fine steakhouse. Food was great and steaks were cooked perfectly. We asked for more bread and were never given it. Would have been a 5/5 experience if the service was a bit more up to par.