Great service and a very good steak. Thank you.

We always like having brunch, but due to meetings we had to have a late lunch. I was happy because I was able to have the wonderful baked potato and my friends enjoyed their picks, as well. Since we arrive early, we had to stay at the bar and munch pretzel sticks, but our bartender was understanding and keep a vigilant eye on us so that we could have lunch on time.

Food was outstanding as always! We especially enjoyed the wild mushrooms.

Food was delicious. We were there for lunch and would definitely go back.

Great food and service . Nice seating with private tables .

Love this place!! Maria and Joan are the best!! Consistently good food and service.

I love the spinach with garlic, though this time it was a bit too salty. The green beans with pecans were delicious. The filet had excellent taste! The bread was wonderful. I also enjoyed mashed potatoes with garlic added!

Excellent as usual!
Pleased and happy once more.

J Gilbert's is always my choice for a pleasant setting and fine meal with a friend. Meals are excellent, service is good and setting is comfortable.

The atmosphere is welcoming, low key, with the rooms divided into private spaces. Our waitress, Natalia, was friendly and efficient. The food was good, though the steaks are a bit pricey. We enjoyed having a quiet conversation with our daughter.

Got seated at a table that didn't have any utensils or napkins. Once we got over that, it was a great expereince.

Great service staff and great food

The cowboy ribeye was outstanding, the seafood was average. The service was average, the waiter never took the plate away from either the bread or the plate when we were finish which is a big deal for me.

It was very good, except that my entree was served while I was still eating my soup. It was too rushed!

Outstanding restaurant and staff. Our server went above and beyond and the management is very present and involved at this place! The steaks are cooked to perfection, amazing sides and apps. It's our go to steak restaurant!

Filet was ok, scallops a bit overdone, too many potato options on the side would like more veggie options. Onion ring app was good. Alcohol was above average in price (one shot of goose was $13). Ambiance was ok, good HH scene. Marginal steak house - better value at Morton's.

Filet was perfectly cooked and very tender. Scallops were also good, but didn’t detect any lobster in the risotto.

My wife and I enjoyed a lovely anniversary dinner, with attentive and thoughtful service. Champagne on ice when we arrived, nice ambience and comfort, the food was well prepared, all in all a very good experience. Pricey, but we got what we paid for.

The prices are good and the food is excellent. The service is good but not quite great. If you want Mastro’s level food at a slightly reduced price (Not Cheap) but are not quite expecting Mastro’s level service, this is your spot.

Nice staff and lunch menu options were delicious.

Always our favorite in McLean. Great service and food.

Enjoyed the surf & turf special. Was disappointed with the Irish Coffee -- suggest that you offer as whiskey or Irish Cream & top with cream to be authentic.

Really enjoyed JGilbert’s. I will be back. The food, service and ambiance were great.

My companions always order the filet done medium-well and love it. I prefer the flavor of sirloin to filet myself, and on the last couple of visits to this J. Gilbert's, I've had some rather tough steaks. This time, going against the grain, I ordered the salmon, and other than for the fact that I prefer Pacific salmon over the farm raised that they serve here, I thought it was excellent. Grilled just right with a touch of smoky flavor. Next time I think I'll try the chicken.

Very nice!

The salads portion was generous. The filet mignonette was done perfectly as ordered but a bit too salty for my taste.

It went well

We had to wait for our table to be ready (reservation was for 8pm on a Saturday night). We were taken to our table, then just 2 mins later moved to a much better one by three fireplace. Service was good, steaks were cooked well. Overall it was good, but for just a few dollars more I think there are better places.

Overall a wonderful experience! The food and decor were what we expected however for a restaurant in this price point the service was lacking to say the least. I don’t even know where to start except to say that we could have served ourselves and had a better flow of food, sides and dessert.