Treat Dad to Something Special this Father's Day.
Sunday, June 17, 2018
really good food and service, great night out
the specials are always worth it
Another excellent experience! Although extremely busy for a Tuesday night, our server, Erin, was personable and attentive. The halibut was prepared deliciously.
Always great food! Never been disappointed! Love their food - very consistent!
Love this place. Never disppoints! Ambiance, food, wine and location are top notch! We usually go there for special occasions like birthdays but it was nice to go just because. I also had a coupon for $25 off so that was awesome.
Usually have exceptional service and food is nothing short of perfection. This time however, I sent my steak back two times, 3rd time out, the steak was cooked correctly. The restaurant was very understanding and were more than generous with making the situation right. However, I remain concerned as to future dining at this restaurant. I have ordered the same steak, cooked the same way for 11 years. On this occasion, I was informed that I simply do not know how I should order my entire. "this is well done here" really, still pink in the middle. My suggestion is J. Gilberts needs to Google what a steak should look like when prepared Medium plus.
It's nearly a 5 star experience every time. The food is delicious and fairly priced for what you get ($337 with tip for party of four this time). Service is top-notch more often than not . Filet and crab cake combo is bangin'. Shrimp cocktail, crab bisque, Caesar salad, king crab legs, scallops, asparagus, fries, mashed potatoes, and brussel sprouts were all delicious. Waitress had a genuine smile.
Celebrating my wife’s birthday. Food, service, everything was fantastic- as usual.
Great Halibut, as always!
Thanks for bday desert and coupon!
Great meal! The server and manager made sure that I felt taken care of on my birthday! Very grateful!
The service and the food were excellent
This my 2nd year in a row coming to J Gilberts for my birthday
This time I brought a business acquaintance
And our wives
All enjoyed the evening
Made reservations and was seated immediately upon arrival. Service was prompt, our waiter's recommendations were excellent. Everything from appetizers to dessert were exemplary. Would highly recommend J Gilbert's.
Always exceptional food and service. The servers are typically very attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. I highly recommend the chocolate cake and risotto. I constantly refer friends and family to J Gilbert’s and none have been disappointed.
My wife and I always come here for soecial occasions and sometimes just because...the steak is outstanding and the salmon is fine too.
Great experience. Love the food.
Great food and service!
It was my birthday. My husband said he has never eaten a more delicious steak. Great night for us!
Consistently great food and service. Great restaurant for special occasions.
Excellent as always
The halibut dish was so delicious. We wanted to return the next day. We are planning our next visit very soon!!
Service was wonderful. Food excellent. Just very pricey. Definitely a place for special occasions.
Food was wonderful as always. We left in a good coma
The flavor of the food was excellent. The ambience was also amazing and the customer service was exceptional!
The food, wine, and service were excellent. It was truly an outstanding experience. I’m very happy we spent our wedding anniversary here.
Food was awesome and so was our server. Very enjoyable evening.
Celebrating friends retirement - 1/2 price bottles + great filet combos. Service impeccable
My mother and I went for Mother’s Day and was hoping for a good meal. Most of the time you go to a restaurant on a holiday and get subpar food but not at J Gilbert’s! I got the 6 oz filet and my mother got the halibut. To say it was comparable to the best restaurants in NYC is not an exaggeration. We sat at one of the step up booths and were able to enjoy watching all the amazing food going to the other tables while deep in conversation. Matt G ( I believe that was his last initial) was the best server we have ever had! He was personable and accommodating without being too involved in our dinner. He made the suggestions of entrees and dessert... and was right on the money for choices! Please, have him train all new servers... oh, and keep the banana cheesecake all the time please!
A bit of a wait to get in due to a Mothers Day backlog. Once seated experienced the expected outstanding service and food. One of our very favorite restaurants.
Overall J Gilbert was well worth the reputation. Our server Sandy was phenomenal. She was attentive without being intrusive. Her knowledge and description was very good. The only reason I did not give a complete five stars was because we were told the Streaks are cooked slightly less then other places. So a medium would really be a medium rare elsewhere. I would expect this of a fine streak place like Lugars and J Gilbert. However the steak came out slightly over cook , more medium - medium wellish. That being said the steak was very flavorful. Lobster Mac and cheese was the best I have ever had. We happen to mention the steak to the server who immediately agreed and apologized. We were enjoying the steak and merely pointed it out. To the servers credit she notified the manger who addressed it as well. We were pleasantly surprised as we merely mentioned it as part of the conversation with our server. Everything was delicious. I highly recommend J Gilbert.
I had a great meal, everything was perfect. My server Nathan was phenomenal with service and description of specials and desserts.
This was my second time eating at J Gilbert's and this time was as good as the first. The good is so good and the service is great too!
Have been here several times before. It’s always a great experience.
Always great for all occasions. Staff is 100% on top. Food is always the same, great. Reservations
requests are always taken care of. The best around.
Food was great and service was outstanding! The waitstaff here is always very attentive. The food was well prepared and enjoyed by all.
Excellent experience. Outstanding service. The steaks, scallops and halibut special were perfect.
This is our favorite restaurant and has always been a nearly perfect experience. For some reason on this night 2 of the 3 steaks were not cooked as ordered. We did not want to go through the hassle of sending the steaks back so we ate them as prepared. This was the first time we experienced this with our steaks. Typically we are impressed with how perfectly the steaks are cooked as requested. Hopefully, this is not a sign of a decline in quality but rather an aberration .
My wife and I had a wonderful time here. The Food is excellent and the staff very friendly and knowledgeable.
Classy place, great service, generally good food.
My filet was VERY grissley; had to leave almost half on the plate. Flavor was good of what I could chew. Disappointing nevertheless.
Mixed cocktail list was too small, as were the size of the cocktails ordered.
Nice wine list.
Many birthdays celebrated that night which I believe cheapened the experience. All I could think about was Chuckie Cheese.
Would give it another try, however.
Amazing meal from appetizers through dessert. Even my ice tea was unique, along with wonderful service, and our great server (Donald - hope I’m spelling it correctly) who really took care of us! Perfect low key birthday acknowledgement. Worth every penny.
I’m on a cane and one of the servers took it upon himself to direct us to a much shorter exit. The servers in this restaurant are clearly superbly educated on customer service.
Love this restaurant!
Jgilberts is a restaurant I like to go for special occasions such as birthday, anniversary or just dinner. Both the food and service are great
I was very impressed with the way our special occasion was respected. There were fun decorations on the table and a free dessert!
We were seated 2 rows from the bar and I found the ambiance noisy. We did like the high barriers between the rows and we could not hear the couple across from us.
I was not a fan of the char broil on my steak, I found it to be drying to a beautiful cut of beef.