Dover Sole Fresca
Pasta All "Icahn"
Very good service and excellent food in a nice and quiet setting.
Food is excellent, service of wine steward isn’t satisfactory.
One of our favorites. Good to be back after a year and a half. Still excellent food and service. Highly recommended.
Il Tinello is a true gem in NYC. The food is as good as it gets and the service is outstanding. Every time we go, we marvel at the diligence that the staff puts into making our dining experience unparalleled.
nothing but praise ...been here twice in last 2 weeks
Superb food service and atmosphere. Always recommend to people
Attentive service and great food. I’ve eaten at many places in NY and this was in the top 10. The focus is on fresh well prepared food. No gimmicks. Table side Caesar salad prep was a nice touch. Tender veal, great simple bread basket. I will be back.
Been going to Il Tinello for over 30 years. So great from both owners Mario to John the same great service and food.
The restaurant is always 10 out of 10 for all top quality food and service.
Never a request they cannot do for the guest!!
One of the best restaurants in NYC.
Also Willy and Nicky are always ready for giving all you need for a great night out!!
They make me so proud to be a customer for all these years!!
As usual, our dining experience at Il Tenello was superb. Wonderful setting, very attentive and friendly staff, and culinary delights that can’t be beat .
The staff really makes it a memorable experience as if one is truly eating in Italy - the calamari was the best we had in a while though soft shell crab was just okay
Fantastic. The service was spectacular.
A great Italian restaurant on west 56th Street.
Service was top notch and the food spectacular. Do not miss the table side zabaglione for dessert.
Food, service, atmosphere were all excellent!
Waiters were all very courteous and professional. Will go back for sure!
Amazing experience all around!! Celebrating daughters birthday all the way from Texas!!! Our compliments!!
Always wonderful ! Everything is delicious, and the service is perfect, very warm and attentive !
The food was outstanding the maître d’ was exceptional the waiters were great the wine was fabulous but there was a table of young people that were screaming and yelling that made the experience a little disappointing overall next time I would appreciate if the waiters could tell the people to table to tone it down a little bit because those of us who are eating there on a special occasion would like a little bit of less of a bar room type of volume of noise
Il Tinello is one of our favorites for a special dinner—in this case, Father’s Day.
Great traditional Italian with fabulous service.
Excellent food and service. Full menu is available which isn’t true at many NYC restaurants right now. True fine dining in midtown.
Il Tinello is always a delightful experience. This was our first time since the Pandemic and they haven't missed a step. The food is amazing; the service is exceptionally professional; and, the setting is perfect New York.
Great to have one of the very best New York has to offer, back!!!
We celebrated our 52 wedding anniversary lunch at this amazing restaurant. We were treated like royalty. The food was top notch. We had trouble deciding which happily means we will return again and again. The complementary zucchini fries started an amazing meal. The hot antipasto was perfect as was the special soft shell crab and soup. Our servers were attentive, knowledgeable, and fun. A not to miss delight
Great staff and food. Will come back.
We are SO GLAD that il Tinello survived the pandemic. Still a gem of a restaurant. We asked for a variation on the saltimbocca (try it with sage instead of spinach) and the kitchen had no problem with that. It was perfect! The Amaretto cookies with cappuccino at the end of dinner are amazing. il Tinello - we so happy you are still perfect!
The best Italian in the city, hands down! Every bite is delicious no matter what you order! Highly recommend! Also if you sit outside, and are there at the right time, it’s a beautiful spot to watch the sunset!!
The absolute best all the time!
Old style true Italian restaurant. The caesar salad is made at table side and is excellent! All the dishes can be adjusted or made to order. Definitely a must in midtown!
Wonderful evening of dining. The ambience and the service and the quiet make it a special evening. The food is a good match for the environment. After over a year of quarantine, it is a most wonderful evening dining experience.
best hospitality at a restaurant in new york city that i have experienced in 13 years living in this city
Great old school Italian, jacketed waitstaff, courteous and attentive service. They have not changed post pandemic with great food and made to order off the menu requests are no problem. Their table side warm Zagblione is the best and will keep us coming back.
Always awesome food, service and everything about it. can't wait to go back
Il Tinello is every bit as wonderful as when I first started dining there about 25 years ago. Elegant dining with a wide menu and the most delicious food outside of Italy!
We have been coming here for 35 years. Never disappoints. Get back out there!
The waiters were friendly and helpful. We had a lovely experience.
Went with family for Mother's day. Food was very good and service was great.
have been several times and will be back.
Service is great and food even better
The staff were excellent, very attentive to all our needs. The restaurant was very quiient and the food was most enjoyable
Always amazing at il Tinello. Consistent food and service... a must visit when in nyc..
Absolutely amazing from the moment we walked in! Server Willie and staff
outstanding! Baked clams, crab salad,
Calamari a must! Delicious dinner and desserts. They made my daughter’s graduation night so special! We will be back!
Il Tinello is rated 4.9 stars by 1509 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.