Book your next event with us
Instantly increase your points with dining rewards
See availability for bonus point tables
Fri 5:00PM - 10:00PM
Sat 12:00PM - 2:00PM 2:15PM - 3:00PM 5:00PM - 10:00PM
Our meal was very good and service was excellent. Prices are rather high for amount of food. Baked clams not good at all. I should have returned to the kitchen. Our main meals were very good.
I love Il Postino. The food is always consistently excellent. They have great staff and are very attentive to customers. My complaint is that on New Year's Eve, they jacked up the prices and provided a limited menu. The cost was double what dinner there normally is. I don't like the idea of taking advantage of people.
Mario is great
The service was outstanding and the food was great! Highly recommend!
The restaurant favors big spenders especially men. I was there with a lady friend. Big difference. The men were served lemon cello complimentary. The server didn’t even look our way just three feet away. I will not recommend the restaurant. Poor rating.
Fabulous place and food is out of this world. You do not experience this level of service very often.
One of the top Italian Restaurants iNYC with the very best staff! When dinner needs to be special, IL Postino is a great choice!
Fantastic dinner— everything we ordered was delicious! However, it was very pricey not so much for food but for alcohol/wine.
The room was busy on the Saturday evening of our dinner. The bar was very crowded and could hardly walk thru to reach our table.
The cocktails were well made.
Food was excellent. Not fancy and innovative, but exactly what one would expect of a well-prepared kitchen.
The Service was friendly, but a little slow - it was a busy night.
A little noisy for intimate conversation.
Overall enjoyable dinner.
Friendly, and food was very good.
Food was very good service was very good prices were very very high
As always, the food was great but the waiter, who has been there forever, was sporadically attentive and sporadically dismissive in attitude. In addition the heat was broken and 4 out of 6 of us ate wearing their coats.
Food was very good. Service was very spotty. Entrees came out piecemeal.
From the moment we walked in the door, until
The moment we left, everyone was friendly and wanted to make our evening special.
The bartender was the best, the food was great! Veal Parm with the bone on!
We could not have asked for a better experience. Thanks!
One of the best ITALIAN restaurants in NYC. Can't be beat and excellent friendly service. It's pricey but worth every penny! We go regularly and highly recommend it.
Great food with options for everyone. Food cooked perfectly.
The food was great. The staff is so lovely and always accommodating at Il Postino.
There was a group of people who showed up halfway thru our lunch and were so loud, we had to keep repeating ourselves to be heard. Sorry about that.
Seafood and vegetables are great here when dishes with meat are tragedy.
So delicious! So many wonderful specials - you don't even need the menu. Great choices of wine by the glass too.
Made a reservation thru open table for dinner at 10 pm. Just after the Broadway show we were attending.
Arrived at 9:55pm. Basically we were the only ones. Almost every employee there was upset that we got in at that time. Service was awful. Most employees were looking bad at us. Specially one of the leaders. We practically had to beg for the spoken menu. The experience was bad. They do not appreciate their job. You lost us a customer. My whole family!
A great gem. So glad we gave this a try. From the moment we were greeted by the lovely hostess, to the delicious food, the attentive wait-staff and energetic bus staff, this was a magical experience (despite a ridiculously rowdy table seated nearby). We will be back!
Fantasitc food, superior service. Highly recommended!!
Very good price fixe lunch- a neighborhood gem 👍🏼
3 people 1 bottle of reeasonably priced wine bill $800
I met a girlfriend for dinner and we both loved it! Delicious and expertly served.
The good is great, the prefix is value for money otherwise separately the means are pricey! The wine list is great although pricey!
Great. I’ve already recommended to friends. Great food, ambience, service.
Some of the best Italian food around. The service excellent. Just a great place to enjoy a true Italian dining experience.
Amazing meal - the best Italian food I’ve had. Authentic and creative pasta dishes. Service was impeccable !
Thoroughly enjoyed meeting our friends at Il Postino. Our table was near the front which had an opened window (more like a panel) with a cool breeze which was perfect. Ambiance was nice and the staff was friendly and knowledgeable. I highly recommend and look forward to returning to the restaurant.
A great place for lunch and dinner with great service and excellent food. The interior of the restaurant is very nice, friendly and fresh. They have a good selection of food, drinks and deserts with prices that are reasonable and gives a lot of value for money. I can really recommend this place for business and pleasure.
I went here with my son and we had a marvelous meal. We had to change our reservation time and the restaurant was very accommodating. They never rushed us. Our margaritas were terrific, not too sweet and fortified, the calamari was delicious as was the mussels and clams in sauce. The poached salmon was perfect, not overcooked. nicely seasoned and melt in your mouth delicious. Desserts were excellent. We can't wait to go again.
One of the best price fixe lunches in NYC. Great food with superb service.👌🏼
One of the best italian restaurant . Greatest food and service. On the expensive side
We did the prefix lunch special for $32. The calamari and Portabella mushrooms to start were pretty good. Bread was delicious. The main courses were a disaster. The pasta totally over cooked ,was like mush. The snapper, Maybe they gave you 4 oz and not very tasty. Accomplished by four string beans, small carrot, Small hard potatoe . gelato was tasteless.
I ate here several years ago and thought the food was delicious though very expensive. Today’s lunch was a total disappointment and Clearly the restaurant has gone downhill.
About as close as you can get to the UN and still find decent food. A 3 course lunch for $35 was excellent value. Good classical ITALIAN cooking. Well spaced tables. Oddly difficult to get a proper receipt they wanted to keep the itemised heavy card bill, and I was first offred only the credit card slip. Eventually they produced a poorly photocopied version of the detailed bill I needed. Frustrating after an otherwise good experience
We decided to try Il Postino during NY Resto Week, as it was more expensive than we normally spend for dinner out. It has to be the most delicious Italian food outside of Italy that I have ever eaten! It was a special birthday dinner for a cousin. We all thoroughly enjoyed our meals.
As they say, there’s a first time for everything and unfortunately for me this was the first time I had a poor meal here. Maybe it’s my fault for ordering from the summer pre-fixe. Or maybe the restaurant just isn’t what it once was, whatever the case may be the roasted veal w/truffles was a disaster from beginning to end. First, the veal was tough and stringy add insult to injury there wasn’t any truffles in the dish. When I was asked if the meal was enjoyed, I shared my concerns and to my huge surprise nothing further was said or done!! Additionally, my wife’s pasta was good but not great as it once was, Carlo where are you when we need you. Not sure if this issues can be linked to Carlo’s departure but I have a very hard time believing this would have happened if he were still there. “Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice shame on me!!”
This restaurant is great for a nice quiet romantic meal. The staff was very friendly and cordial. The food was really very tasty, the menu had a nice variety of food and wine.
I knew going in that it would be expensive and I don't have a budget when I come to a restaurant like this. I wanted to see just how good the restaurant was. The bill was absurdly high due to the incredible pricing for additional food/sides/drinks. Don't order "off" the menu and be careful about what drink you are asking for, they won't provide you with a price unless you ask.