Il Postino

Had an outstanding prix fixe lunch. Excellent food and service.

Delicious! Amazing service! Very expensive but worth it.

Excellent food and service. Casual and relaxing I would high I recommend.

Excellent food, gracious service- very accommodating.
Perfect for business dinner

Love the experience to Luigi the staff impeccable service

Authentic Italian food in an intimate atmosphere with exceptional service. Great all around experience.

Absolutely the best food and service. Antipasto serve at being seated were grand.
Prosciutto and strachelli ( not correct spelling) cheese are a fabulous starter.
Pasta and fish were outstanding. The best have had in New York!
Service was excellent

Great Italian restaurant. Traditional

A perfect early dining experience before church on Christmas Eve. Food and service were outstanding!

Excellent food and service. Should not add the tip on the check themselves though.

As always, outstanding. mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

The service was odd. No menus for a good 10 minutes after wine order and bread arrived. The the menu arrived and we were told that we could order anything that we wanted and they would make it. Odd. The free appetizers were the best part of the meal. The entrees were just okay. Better than Olive Garden but barely. The other reviews posted must be relatives. No recommended for anyone.

Favorite NYC Italian restaurant!

Crazy prices but the best restaurant/food in new york

Excellent place with spectacular food!

My friend loved it and I plan to return. The food is delicious, each course. Our waiter waited patiently while we made up our minds. We'll definitely be back.

Pricey but special anniversary dinner

Excellent service and food! This place is a hidden gem.

My wife and I rarely thoroughly enjoy a dinner out. IL Postino delivered in every way.

Great food, excellent service. Expensive but worth it.

Delicious neighborhood dining - very professional accommodating staff.

Price fixe lunch was very good . A neighborhood gem

Superlative service and food. Very friendly staff.

Not as good as its sister restaurant and much more expensive. Slow service and food serviced cokd

Always an amazing experience from the variety of the "specials" to the impeccable service from the staff. Il Postino has always been my #1 restaurant in NYC. Been going there for 2 decades and the staff is still young!

It was amazing! Certainly going back

As always, Il Postino was great.

Food was good. Served a little to quickly but overall service was very nice.

We celebrated our 35th anniversary and the staff was fantastic! Even brought us a beautiful dessert and sang to us, very special

Just like in Capri, the food is wonderful, delicious and light. This might be the best Italian food in town - hidden gem. Elisabeth, our hostess, Arnie, Dario and Giovanni our waiters were very attentive. Alfio Rocco, the host and owner - also of Scalinatella - a real Caprese truly knows how to do it - "Come a Capri.."

Great food as always.

Amazing service in this darling neighborhood restaurant. The gnocchi, which the chef made special for us were like little potato pillows. Absolutely delicious. I would for sure go back next time we are in New York!!

You can never go wrong with II Postino. The food is always great, the service is always friendly and knowledgeable. The restaurant has a great vibe and the hostess is friendly and inviting.

We got there and the staff asked us for our order almost before we took our seats. We were trying to make a romantic evening but felt rushed and not welcomed by the wait staff, almost as if we were an inconvenience. I enjoyed the food, though everything was overpriced. The kitchen did a supurb job but the front of the house was full of a wait staff that seemed like they were ready to go home.

Enjoyed the service and staff was very attentive and knowledgeable. The food was excellent and well prepared.

Loveeeee this place Food is great and service wonderful. The kitchen will make you anything you want.

What ruined the experience for me was the service. Service was overlooked, when acknowledged it was poorly timed and rushed, and lastly left me with a very impersonal experience. Should they had stronger service, it would be a great place. The pasta special was delicious, but due to the service, I was eager to leave and did not stay for dessert. I would not recommend this location; prices are high and with high prices come higher expectations. They don't hit the mark for me, no matter how tasty their food may be.

Excellent food!! Wine list was rather pricey.

Best authentic Italian restaurant in NYC. Great food, nice atmosphere, friendly staff.

In general I think that the food in this restaurant is amazing, but their prices are outrages.
As much as I love eating there, we go there only on a very very special occasions.