Obscenely over priced wine list
A first in my dining life!
The food is outstanding.
Reservations are not honored. We had an 8:30 reservation and were not seated until 9:15. The staff was not at all apologetic.
When we were seated, we had a great table and the experience was excellent. Still, the experience was not what it should have been because the reservation was not honored.
Food quality has slipped
Spicy lobster was off today :/
Husbands B-day dinner.. Not impressed they over cooked his $70.00 steak .. then 2nd around steak was 1/2 medium and half rare .. sides nothing to brag about .. pesto nochi ap was heavy and drowning in sauce .. My seafood risotto was tasty .. Wait staff was almost overbearing ..Standing right infrount of us chatting the whole meal.. (uncomfortable ) ... I had booked via open table way ahead asking for a nice table . Upon arriving they tried to seat us at the very worst table facing the bathroom and kitchen with a busy walk way ...The restaurant was empty at that time . This sadly was a fail for us .. will likely not return...So many better choices for the $ ..
Everything was absolutely amazing A+++++ romantic beautiful decor delicious food one of my favorites.
Really mediocre very expensive. Wine list very limited on whites
It was pleasant from start to finish. Everyone who worked with us anticipated our every need and we wanted for nothing. I’ve been there many times and this is my go to spot for special occasion
The restaurant is good and the food is excellent but very overpriced.
Always delicious and food never disappoints - amazing veal parm. Pricey, for example $31 for 3 shrimp cocktail. They could use a makeover, looks medieval in there - time to bring the décor to modern times.
Food was ok compared to Manhattan and Sunny isles location where its excellent.
Great food in a well staffed restaurant
Amazing food and first class service. Wonderful wine list. Excellent for special occasions, date night or when you are looking for first-class service and phenomenal food!
Got the bums rush on arrival... at least 6 wait staff rushing us to get drinks and order food. We had to pretend we hadn’t read the menus to make them go away
Food was mediocre at best. Noise level, while ok at 6:30, was deafening by 8pm.
THe bill was ridiculous for the value received, with a total of 4 drinks for 4 persons.
You can do better, even in Roslyn
Very expensive and really the food and servings did not justify the price paid. Forced to buy a bottle instead by glass.
$740.00 for four people and one bottle of wine is a bit much.
Frank L Pepe
Awful service, arrogant staff & very poor food quality. Nothing was fresh. Salad greens looked tired & our expensive pasta dishes were mushy with very few of The listed ingredients.
everything excellent....very pricey so save for special occasions
Birthday celebration. Was a wonderful. fine dining experience.
I went to celebrate a belated Valentine's day. The atmosphere was very dark and romantic and the noise level was perfect. The food was very good if a bit pricey. However they do start you off with Brushetta, a small chunk of Parmesian , great bread and something else which I couldn't identify but was very garlicy and delicious. The drinks also were very good. With coffee they gave some of their homemade Grappa which was the perfect ending to a Special Occasion .
Wonderful meal - as always. My favorite Italian restaurant.
Took the family here for a birthday celebration. They start off with many goodies on your table, such as chunks of parmesan cheese, bruschetta, zucchini, and many varieties of delicious breads.
Pre dinner drinks were top quality. Portions are plentiful, and very delicious. Many choices for desserts, and we were offered grappa at the end of the meal.
This restaurant makes you feel very special.
Very Romantic Italian restaurant, the food is also amazing.
Great experience, impeccable service, excellent food!
Only comment I️ could make would be if they could expand their wines by the glass menu ever so slightly to include a few white wines at least. My wife doesn’t drink and I️ was driving so buying a bottle was a bit excessive.
The food was excellent and the service was extraordinary. It was NYC pricing on Long Island, aka a bit pricey, but I think it was worth for the quality and service.
The food and service were excellent. It’s a special place to go to for a special occasion.
Excellent food and service. We have been to a few of the Il Mulinos and I have to say my most recent one at the Roslyn location was the most memorable. Everything was delicious, I mean everything. The wait staff were on point. We even had nice chats with both of our “neighbors.” Such a great dinner experience.
Top notch service! Food was delicious and so we're the cocktails. Would definitely go back. Yes a little pricey but with that kind of service you don't mind paying a little extra.
We were greeted rudely. We made a reservation for 2:00 and arrived a few minutes late.
The maitre d' lied to us and said the kitchen was closing.
The prices were too high.
The food was very good, with some outstanding touches.
Staff was most accommodating food was properly prepared everything was delicious it was a very enjoyable evening
My spouse was disappointed that there was no Lemoncello, we found the flourless chocolate cake to taste like a brownie. The meals were very good but over priced.
I’ve been there several times. The food is good but the service is very poor. The waiters are inattentive, just stand around bored and could care less about you. Basically rude. Only for the fact that my wife likes the food, I would NEVER go there again. An ungrateful bunch of service staff
Fine Dining at its best!
Amazing food and wonderful experience. Perfect place for a date.
Wonderful dinner. The salmon and bronzino were perfection!
We have been going to Il Mulino for over a decade for apeciak occasions specifically my husband’s bday since its the day before Christmas Eve. This year we took our three daughters bc they are old enough to act properly and they did fine. The service was good as always but a bit slow. The biggest disappointment was the food. We ordered three specials and one carbonara pasta which is usually amazing and wasn’t incredibly greasy and fatty. I was very surprised as we have always loved going there. Im not sure we will spend that kind of money again with the food not being what it used to be.
It was a pleasant dining experience but for the money, I've had better.
My wife and I had a great time at Il Mulino. We have been planning to dine there for so long, but never had the time. Then we finally had a chance to go and had Sunday supper. The trip was sooo worth it. The food is amazing! The ambiance is great. The service is excellent and attentive. I think my wife and I have found our new go to Italian restaurant.
Service and Food and staff amazing ! Had a great date with a special someone ! Couldn't have been more perfect
We have been fortunate enough to go to IlMulino as our " special " dinner .
We have celebrated anniversaries and special birthdays since it goes hand and hand with having an always delicious dinner ...
Stuff was slow and unprofessional, food is okay but overpriced