Il Michelangelo Restaurant
We pride ourselves for being considered by our own customers as one the best Italian Restaurants in Morrris County NJ. The Menu selection is influenced by our Sicilian heritage and blending culinary flavors from many regions of Italy. Enjoy a true home cooking style experience that will have you wondering if your Italian Grandma is cooking in the kitchen !!!!!
Come and experience that our Motto "Eat Well-Live Well" "Mangia Bene- Vivi Bene" Holds True
Il Michelangelo Restaurant surely belongs in your Dining Agenda where the food and service are designed to "Make your Day!!!"
We've dined there many-many times over the years. I know the owner, and hes always been able to squeeze us in, even if we made reservations at the last minute. He staffs his place with excellent waiters, ( who know how to treat customers), and excellent chefs.
He comes around and visits all the tables, that's the, "Old World" way of doing things, kind of like how a, hand shake was all you needed at one time.....
He always personally calls to make sure your still coming. Again, its the way of doing, good business, the " Old Fashioned Way"!!!
Great service, the owner went from table to table and really made you feel like a special guest.
Everything was excellent from the properly made drinks at the bar (Hendricks martini w/splash) to the dining. Our waiter Gary was great. The food was delicious with a nice presentation. I had the French cut chicken Marsala as a special. It should be added to the regular menu! The bread pudding for dessert was also top notch. A nice touch was hot milk for our coffee. We plan on putting this restaurant on our rotation! Good job!
Great food, great service. We had 7 people and everything flowed perfectly.
Love Michelangelos! Always recommend! Had a wonderful time celebrating our 37th wedding anniversary!
Anniversary dinner. Everything was delicious and the service there is excellent! Very attentive and friendly staff. Our second time there and will absolutely go back.
Excellent food and the customer service from all the staff there is amazing. My family and I had a beautiful Easter dinner. Thank you!!
I come here often and have always enjoyed the food and excellent service!
I highly recommend this Great Restaurant!
The only issue I have is with the service. Our waiter was very personable when waiting on us but for the most part he was completely absent. He never checked in to see how our meal was going or if we wanted additional drinks. Luckily someone else was filling our water glasses. We waited 30min so I could ask for the check.
First time visiting the restaurant. We went for an early dinner on a Sunday afternoon. Ambiance and service was warm and attentive but the food was fantastic. Highly recommended
We were treated like royalty and will be back soon!
Food was top shelf. Service was good, but sometimes a bit slow. Atmosphere was upscale without being stuffy. I would recommend it.
Across the board my husband and I had an amazing experience. We will definitely be going back!
Food was very good. Service left a lot to be desired. It took us 20 minutes to get the check after flagging a server down 3 times despite having only 3 other tables with customers. They definitely need to work on service. Not sure if we'll return.
Always served excellent food. Never rushed by service. Relaxes atmosphere.
I celebrated my 56th birthday there and it was the perfect spot. The Owner was very charming and told my family some of his great meet&greets - many were shown in the pictures that adorn his hallway. The food was great - Calamari, Rice Balls, Pasta, Fish, all were amazing.
Impeccable service, great innovative specials and relaxing environment
When you walk into Il Michelangelo you are greeted by the executive Chef and pictures of numerous stars who have visited. Then you are seated and treated a a very nice evening and a very nice restaurant with a reasonably sized menu of expertly prepared food. The homemade pasta is excellent. The deserts and soup as special. The marinated seafood salad is probably the best I've ever had. If you are in the area or don't mind a small amount of travel for great Italian food, you should check it out.
Old fashioned ambiance and good service, which is much appreciated and often lost in today's dining options. Plenty of entree salad options and both were good. One entry very good the other was overly spicy and not noted as "hot" on the menu; it should be. Dessert Chocolate Lava Cake very good. The house Napa Cabernet Sauvignon ($10 by the glass) was excellent.
The food and service were excellent. Would definitely recommend to friends and will be dining there again.
Went for Valentine’s Day. Wanted try the restaurant. They had a $75 per person pre fix. The choices they gave we both felt where not worth $150 plus drinks and tip. So we left. We were very disappointed. Not sure we try again.
Valentines Day was a grand, thank you for an amazing dinner!
Even with the pre-fixe menu the staff was able to accommodate me being vegetarian and my wife’s allergies. We will definitely return.
We have dined here 4 or 5 times-never on a price fix menu night. So it was Valentine's day and the food was not very good and choices not great. Appetizers great, then only a beet salad, dinners tasted mediocre. If this was our first date I would have been in big trouble. If you do not want roasted potatoes and green beans-go somewhere else. It was mobbed and got noisy as I waited a long time to get our check.
We had such a nice experience dining here. We were greeted with a friendly and welcoming hello and were seated right away. The ambiance was very warm and inviting. Each server was so nice and helpful.
Started the evening with the stuffed artichoke and the beet salad which both were delicious. The beet salad was very uniquely prepared which was great. Then the Veal Saltimbocca was tender and sauce smooth and delicious the same with the Chicken Michelangelo. Followed by dessert which there were many to choose from. I recommend the Sicilian Zeppoli with the homemade fresh cannoli filling or any of the homemade gelatos. Perfect.
Looking forward to returning soon.
The food was outstanding. Eddie’s service was very good.
We enjoyed the cozy atmosphere.
very pleasant restaurant, quiet elegant -- but not too fancy atmosphere. food is good, liquor license. Staff is attentive. Great place to out with friends as you can dine on good food in a quiet place
Delicious Italian food & great cocktails. Very cozy room & service great. The four of us ordered pasta dishes that tased just like my nana,.’s homemade pasta from years ago. Will definitely be returning.
Loved the food, everything we ordered was delicious. Service was great too.
The Michelangelo experience has been consistently high for years and continues to impress over and over again. The family and the staff pay meticulous attention to the guests and each experience is of the highest value! We just enjoyed a night with some old friends getting back together and the ambiance, the food and the service was impeccable! Cheers - can't wait for my next experience to occur there!!
Authentic Italian meal! We enjoyed the ambiance, the wine and our meals very much. Dominic is always and warm and friendly host, and will ensure it’s a great meal.
Wonderful as always, the homemade pasta and sauces are amazing.
food and service were great. Everyone of the staff are friendly and helpful. I brought out of town guess and they loved it.
The food was amazing. The service was amazing. I would recommend this restaurant to everyone I know. I cannot say enough about the food. I bought there homemade sauce. The best sauce ever.
Consistent. Comfortable. Great wine list.
Owners have an eye for hospitality.
Great food and excellent service
Perfect. Place is great. Dominic is a great host.
Enjoyed Christmas Eve dinner with our 3 kids. Oldest is 8. Delicious authentic food, great service and lovely atmosphere. Made our eve special and the kids loved the food.
Delicious food, friendly, attentive service, good wine list, overall good value. Will definitely return. Note: an upstairs pair of rooms with bar is available for private parties.
Owner is present and engages with his guests. The outside seasonal decorations is what caught my eye to this restaurant.
Food was simple and authentic as it should be. Will be back.