Hy's Steakhouse - Winnipeg

Fabulous dinner and evening at Hy's! Service, Food & Wine was EXCELLENT!!!

As always Hy’s is outstanding. A warm greeting, excellent service and fantastic food.
As there isn’t a Hy’s in our hometown of Victoria, we always seek out Hy’s when in Winnipeg, Calgary or Vancouver.

We dined in for our 38th anniversary. It was great food, excellent staff and a great place to spend a quiet evening with the love of my life. We will return. Thanks to the server (Andrew) and the cooks for great food!!

Great place. Expensive, but wonderful food and service.

An excellent meal and a great waitress (wish I could remember her name to add here... sorry). The prices at Hy's are expensive; however, the food is great. Steaks were made to order perfectly.

Service was exceptional. Steaks were slightly off what we ordered but tasty none the less. Side dishes were plentiful. Drinks were beautifully crafted but pricey. Worth the money? Not really sure honestly. You pay for the experience here more than the actual platings in my opinion but it a very pleasant time!

Food was very good as well as the service. I did notice how poorly most people were dressed considering it is considered a high end restaurant. Would like to see a bit of a dress code.

Service was excellent, food was terrific, great atmosphere, friendly staff. We will be back!

Lovely dinner, excellent service! Wishing all the staff at Hy's Winnipeg all the best for 2019!

I would have to say that I was quite disappointed with hys this year. My wife and I have booked hys for new year's for the last 4 years, and its become a tradition for us. This year was probably the last.
Not only was the food subpar, the service wasn't what it has been in the past,and price all play a huge roll.
Let's begin when we arrived. Staff confusion at the coat check, customers trying to obtain their coats as with us trying to check them. The hostess rushing me to my table, while I'm waiting for my wife to change her shoes.
The server was more attentive to one of my guests ( she remembered him from a retail shop) instead of addressing the table, she seemed to be focused on him.
Wasn't asked how the meal was or if we required anything extra.
The meal was just not what we were use to for hys. Scallops were undercooked. When charging $21 for 3 scallops, I would expect perfection! My wife order the half chicken, bland and uninspired. Our bill was close to $200 with tip. We could have gone to Earl's, had a better experience and paid half with drinks. Like I stated, we not be back!

We used our gift certificates on New Years Eve. Decided to stay away from steak because the last time that experience was not good. This Time we went with the salmon special ( delicious!), the seafood dish( awesome!), an amazing Caesar salad, prepared at our table, escargot to die for!!! And cheese toast. Our server was superb! Very helpful, patient and friendly.

Wonderful ambience, excellent meal and outstanding service as always!

Excellent Caesar Salad prepared as requested “light on the anchovies, heavy on the garlic”, table side. Both steaks were excellently prepared and as ordered medium rare, lobster perfectly cooked not overdone. Service professional attentive and responsive. Will be back even though the prices are a bit steep, but food fresh,excellent as expected and ordered.

My husband and I were celebrating the end of my first round of chemotherapy, New Years' and my " last supper" before low anterior resection. We loved our evening so much, we are planning on celebrating our 30th anniversary this spring with all our friends at Hy's!

Outstanding in every way, has become part of our Christmas family tradition. Memorable for everyone, a true must to do! Thanks again Hy’s..

Untrained waiters and servers
Food not done to request

Manager was able to recover evening

Christmas eve - Excellent. Beautiful surrounding a understated but beautiful. Appies, wine, main courses - all perfect. Bananas Foster at the table - showstopper. Professional & friendly server. Expensive but worth it. 51 steps to the basement bathroom helps burn calories but challenging in heels.

Fantastic! Excellent food, fabulous service. Was a lovely experience.

It was lovely. Impeccable service as always.

24th wedding anniversary

Great meal. Unbelievably expensive. $20 for a martini! Shame on you for price gouging Hy’s!!?

Christmas with family

The cheese toast is a must when you visit Hy’s. The food I found more bland than it should be (burger this time).

Lunch was great. Steak frites done just the way it was ordered, frites excellent. Rest of the table had steak salad (excellent), halibut and chips - great, steak sandwich( fantastic)...

Everything was excellent, the food, the drinks, the service, the ambiance. Will definitely go to Hy's again in the future and recommend it to all.

My filet was rare, I asked for medium-rare.

We were at Hy’s for a significant birthday. It was a wonderful evening!!

Fiancé took me for a special birthday dinner and everything was impeccable. The meal was amazing and you can’t find better service anywhere.

We asked for a table for 4 in a quieter area.
Table was ready at requested time and in a quieter area.
Excellent menu selections.
Waiters really friendly and did vg job of explaining options and specials.
Excellent wine selection from side variety of regions.
Wine waiter Kaitlyn was very knowledgeable about wines and pleasant to visit with about wine selection.
Food was great and prices, while on higher side were in line with food. ambience and service.

Great good. Excellent service. Helped make the anniversary special

The food was average, some potatoes I had were cold, the asparagus was slightly undercooked. Prices were high and I felt there was lack of detail to the food quality and temperature. The desert was very good. Overall I felt the quality was poor relative to the price and that is why I wouldn’t recommend. The service and ambience was excellent. Thank you.

Always a pleasure dining at Hy’s. My first time to this location and the staff were outstanding.
Steak was under done, but it was taken care of immediately. No fuss! I happily sipped my delicious cocktail. Definitely a splurge, but totally worth it.
Thanks Jason and staff!

Have been coming here for years. We got engaged here and love this restaurant

Overall is was a good experience but personally we were expecting a little more, we asked for a steak medium rare and it came totally rare, then it went back to the kitchen but it was still very red and rare from the inside. The mashed potato was very dry, my husband couldn’t finish it, he needed to drink water all the time to swallow it. The appetizers and the dessert were good

Went for lunch and thoroughly enjoyed it. Food came hot and was very tasty. Server Stephanie was fantastic. Will come back.

My Colleague and I took 3 important customers for Dinner Monday night. I found our Waiter to be a bit pompous. He seemed to always be in a big bloody hurry and it was a Monday night and the place was very empty. No need to be spinning around like he was.
He got my Drink wrong, My steak (Striploin) was so tough I actually had to send it back, and the Tenderloin he then brought me wasn't a whole lot better. I KNOW MY MEAT, and this was crappy!
For what you folks charge for everything, it has to be perfect to justify the experience.
I will not recommend this restaurant to anyone.

The service was perfect. Place is a little expensive, but the food is so good.

Excellent service, our server Laurence was attentive, fun made the meal very enjoyable! Great food!

Our server Kelly was amazing. Food was fantastic. Nice touch to provide a glass of champagne for our special occasion!

My wife and I go here for her birthday. Always enjoyable. The steaks are great and well prepared. Service is attentive and enjoyable. I really enjoy the table side food services they offer - Ceaser salad, bananas foster.