We only saw the downstairs, sat in a cozy window nook. It was teeny tiny and charming! The waitress was lovely and the food was outstanding! That steak over Greek salad was very very good! Would go back in a heartbeat!
Always a good visit. Friend had the special...stuffed trout and he loved it. This was his first visit even though others had mentioned it to him. He'll be back.
Wonderful food and people!!! A wonderful New York Italian dining experience!
We’ve eaten here a few times pre-theater. The food is always good as is the service. It is a little noisy but tolerable. It’s on restaurant row, conveniently close to the theaters. The prices are surprisingly low for Manhattan. Overall, a great value.
My teenage daughter and I were lucky to get a table on the front porch area (only has 2 tables) which was very lovely. You got the vibe this was a date place based on other people dining around us. My daughter enjoyed her steak and I had a pork chop that was a bit overdone. We both liked our sides. Our server was very attentive and friendly as was other staff. Overall, it was a nice meal prior to our Broadway show.
Subtle delicious flavors in my smoked salmon, quinoa and dill entree. Even my children (12 and 15 yrs) enjoyed.
We had a nice meal before going to the Theater. We arrived late due to rainy weather, and sat at the bar for 10 mins waiting for a table. I was worried we were going to be unable to complete the meal, but they were pros at timing everything so we did not feel rushed. Pleasant waitress, nice bar area and friendly bartender. Would go again and hope to spend a more leisurely meal, but would prefer a table on upper floor rather than near the door. Food was good, 3 + stars.
Online menu looked really nice, so booked for dinner before a show. We let waitress know so we could manage our time. She was nice, but overwhelmed. And service was bumpy - ordered prix fixe but entrees came out without getting salads 1st. We pointed this out, so they took back entrees and brought salads, but no dressing. Seemed they kept our entrees on the warmer. Food was ok I guess. Also, very narrow and tight space, and so noisy we could barely hear ourselves talking. Oh well.
This is an excellent spot for a pre-theatre meal. Food was delicious and fast, and our server was incredibly attentive. Note—some of the searing is up a steep flight of stairs, so if anyone has difficulty climbing stairs, please let them know when you make the reservation. We really loved our meal here.
Food pretty good, service excellent... Still one of the best values in the city.
Absolutely zero wait for our 5pm reservation. Food was excellent, flavorful, and satisfying. Attantion and service was great. Desserts (flan and mousse) were really good. House champagne cocktail was excellent. I read reviews about the stairs, if you know the area and you read the restaurant website you know what to expect, no issues here felt like someones home.
Food service good. Location good a bit small where we sat. I’d go back. All ok and pleasant
We visited the Hourglass Tavern for a pre-theatre dinner. While the service was very good, the quality of the food varied. I had the pork chop with spinach. The chop was dry but the spinach was very good. My friend had a pasta and vegetable dish that was just boring. Dessert was nothing special. We did however make it to the theatre in plenty of time.
We travelled from Ireland and had a fantastic time at The Hourglass Tavern. I took my wife and daughter for pre theatre dinner and everything was perfect. Greeted by the gent at the door and looked after by a fantastic lady throughout the meal - I didn’t catch her name but her purple hair and bubbly professional manner left a great impression. Service was attentive but not in the least intrusive and we were never rushed - the 2 hours we spent over dinner flew by. Cocktails, wine and food were tremendous and excellent value. Planning a return visit next year with friends for a triple 50th celebration - can’t wait
Perfect right before Hamilton ❤️
This is a very sweet, unique, friendly place with great food. The only drawback was the two story climb.
A real treasure! Just love this place and always have a wonderful experience here! Highest praise to everyone at the restaurant!
Fun and interesting place, enjoyed the atmosphere and decor.
Awesome food as always! Service was excellent! The pre-fix menu is reasonably priced and good for an early evening meal. Downstairs is small but cozy.
A wonderful find in the theatre district. Cozy, romantic and the foed is good.
Low noise level.