What a gem of a place...warm, friendly staff, charming decor and history, great food and service... I’m keeping this my little secret for now!
I made a reservation for 5:15pm. I was seated promptly and ordered off the prix fixe menu. I was brought bread and a salad, which were quite yummy! However, much time passed and I never saw my entree. In addition, my water was never refilled, and the bartender was stemmed overwhelmed/was more occupied with those ordering alcoholic beverages than his assigned tables. Two tables that were seated ahead of me with multiple peoples at their table received their entrees. I waited for an hour and finally left.
Update 4/20/18: The manager did call me to apologize which was greatly appreciated.
Decent food at reasonable prices, within walking distance of most theaters near Times Square.
Great at getting you to your play on time. Good, friendly service. Cool space with three levels. Bathrooms clean. Food is mediocre at best. Pork chop over cooked. Beef sliders over cooked. Mashed potatoes flavorless. They might have been instant. Wanted to love the place, but food needs help.
A gem in the theater district. Very well priced food and beverages. Great value and friendly staff.
If you're looking for a non traditional place to dine in the theater district..it is the Hourglass Tavern. It is hip and has a unique brunch pre theater menu. It is three floors, so if you have strong legs, the second and third floor are for you, otherwise stay on the first floor to dine.
Food was very good and reasonable for mid town west,good variety for all (we had one semi vegetarian diner). The waitress/hostess was great and extremely professional.
I'm not from NY, but this was way too cramped and hot. Food and service were acceptable but nothing to rave about.
Everything was wonderful. The food was great as were the drinks. The staff was extremely friendly, service great, made you feel very comfortable,
Lovely quant restaurant, New York style. Delicious food at reasonable prices. We will be going back to this little gem!
Low key and off the beaten path. Food, service and ambiance were very good. Would come again.
We had a good meal here with good service, it was my Mom's favorite on our trip. The value for the quality of food was great. A great place to eat before a Broadway show. It didn't feel like a tourist chain which was nice considering Times Square is full of them. I recommend it.
Great find - Service was really good and everyone was friendly. Food was unexpectedly really good. First time I had coconut rice.
Went here for a quick bite before seeing a show at Wilson Theatre. Wanted something closer to eight avenue side of Times Square that was north of 45th street. My niece and I were tired of the same old theater restaurants so we wanted to try something new and also fairly healthy. This was our first time here and we'd definitely go back. Please be aware, this is a very tight restaurant with three skinny floors and with no wheelchair access (that I saw) unless you're sitting in the front two tables. If your party is on the larger (literally both in the amount of people and size-wise) it might be difficult to squeeze in. My niece had the grilled chicken, broccoli, and mashed potatoes. I had the coconut rice, tilapia, and broccoli. Both dishes were delicious, came out in a timely manner, and were fairly priced considering portion-size and expensive midtown area. I would come back here again, especially because the service is so cordial.
Adorable place. Good food
Quaint and cute location; good specialty drinks; food ok -- nothing really special. Went post theater. The host seated us even though we were about 20 minutes earlier than our reservation. Main seating on first level tiny but cute; second floor bar looked like it could be fun; third level dinner seating elegant but not pretentious. Crafted cocktails were really tasty and different; server was animated, helpful, professional. Had two entrees -- neither was particularly good or bad -- average. Would I go back? Maybe for drinks and a bite, but probably not for dinner -- too many other good options both in the neighborhood and around town.
We've been going here for years. Always happy w/ the food & especially the staff.
Overall a pleasant experience with very good food at a reasonable cost.
We went here for lunch before a Saturday matinee. This restaurant is located on restaurant row in a narrow multi story walk up. Each level was narrow and accessed by stairs only. No ADA compliance here! Roomier on the third floor than the first. Second level is a bar setup not in use at the time we went. Each floor has its owner waiter and stocked bar.
Companion had a chicken Caeser salad she liked very much. I had the Benedict Florentine and enjoyed the mix of flavors and it was very well prepared.
Highly recommended for a nice, quiet meal.
Hourglass tavern was great. Very good experience dining before a show.
The restaurant was historic and charming, food tasty, staff was extremely friendly and accommodating.
Great for before-theater dinner. Wait staff is fabulous. We had pasta dishes - shrimp and mussels and bolognese. Both were excellent.
Every aspect of the experience at Hourglass was amazing!
A friend and I dined pre-theater at The Hourglass Tavern. It's a busy place at that time of day but the hostess and our server were fantastic. Very friendly and helpful not only with our order but with little things like pulling out the table and helping with our coats. The food is a great value for the Theater District and darn good, too. The building is a classic and harkens back to the Golden Age of the Broadway theater...which is a wonderful thing in this age of tearing down and building up. There is a lively happy hour at Betti Bar (have enjoyed that previously). In the old days (when I was young and aspiring actress), we'd go there for blue fish and they would actually time your meal with an hour glass. That practice is no more but hence the name and hour glasses as decor. Always a solid, tasty meal that satisfies both deep pockets and struggling artists. Thanks so much to all!
Surprisingly good, and incredible prices. While the tourists are lined up for terrible food over at Times Square, this little gem on the old Restaurant Row dishes up really good cooking and caring service. Service is fast enough to get you to the play in time, while not feeling rushed. Strongly recommend -- try the penne mascarpone or the NY strip dinner.
I love Hourglass Tavern! I've been back four times now-and I've never been disappointed. My food came out so hot I couldn't even eat it-which is pretty spectacular. I'll be returning in May-no doubt about it!
Just a really enjoyable gem in the heart ofTimes Square! Our server, she was just lovely!
Bad service. The waitress was stressed out and made us feel like we were an inconvenience . Her manner was rude and we were made to sit and wait until she was ready for us to order... by the way she wasn’t busy with her job she was eating. We also sat forever with our empty plates in front of us.. We were seated on the third floor. Small , but cozy.. the food was ok. Entire experience was ruined by the mean, menopausal waitress.such a shame. Will never return.
Although our first time there the staff made us feel as if we were old friends. They were attentive warm and friendly. The food was delicious, plentiful and moderately priced. We will definitely recommend the Hourglass and look forward to our next visit
It was a great find! The ambiance was dark and cozy. Service was impeccable and I really enjoyed th Chicken Alfredo.
Good theater location. Curb appeal not very good. Limited menu but what we did order was good. Nice waiter and good service
We will go back. Two adults and four teenagers. Something on the menu to appeal to every taste. Told them what time our curtain was and they insured that we would be able to make it. The trek up the stairs was pretty tough for me but I would do it over again over again over again. Delightful servers excellent food -go there.
This was an ok experience. We went as a family before a show on Broadway. Food was ok, service was very good. The ambience was not great. We were seated on the main floor where the surroundings were VERY tight.
Great service and very good food in this “sliver” of a spot on restaurant row. Tight quarters at this 3 story eatery, so be prepared to get up close and personal with your neighboring diners. Good news is that the food is good enough that they might share!
AMAZING. 10/10. Nicest people went above and beyond to make sure we were enjoying our meal. A hidden, affordable gem in midtown! Already made a reservation for brunch this weekend
Tiny little place. Homey with very good food, reasonable prices and friendly service. Nice, non-touristy spot in the theater district.
Loved how quaint and cozy it is. The food was fresh and delicious and I had one of the best cocktails I've ever had. Service was great and friendly staff. Loved it!
Second time there and my mom and I got the same dishes as our first visit: shrimp entree and crab cakes. Both were just as delicious as we remembered. Our waitress was so sweet and even put our coats on for us. We love this place!
DESPITE THE SMALL FLOOR PLAN, tables were spaced appropriately, food selection was
good and different (BRUNCH). Food was kind to the palette and filling. Music was a little to loud for comfortable conversation.
Charming little "nook". Food was delicious. Service was great, waitstaff and hostess very attentive.
My husband and I went for brunch before a show. Ryan, our server, was excellent. Our food was very good and plentiful-eggs with short rib hash, salad with chicken. Mimosa was a great price. It was a pleasurable experience