Book your next event with us
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Proof of vaccination required to dine indoors
100 Grass-Fed Beef & Ricotta Meatballs
meatball sauce, parm
grass-fed butter, parsley, lemon
Olive Oil Cake
raspberries, lemon cream
Thanksgiving Dinner Special Menus & Offers
Celebrate Thanksgiving at Hearth! We're offering a traditional Thanksgiving feast built with ingredients from the Union Square Greenmarket and our local farmer friends. $120 per guest, half price for kids. Optional wine pairing for $40 per guest. See you on Thanksgiving!
Wine list is incredibly overpriced. Food is good. Non-pasta entrees are on the smaller side.
Service was excellent! We had pork chops and pasta and sides. Everything was delicious.
The meatballs are the best. The fish was perfect. The beans were creamy and tasty. The greens, scrumptious. It's the only place to get Cecina. And the wine, a Perricone, was spicy, lively, delightful.
I hadn’t been to Hearth in years and decided to go for my wife’s birthday. We sat outside while it was pouring out and had the very best time. The meal was spectacular and the service outstanding. The food is so delicious and real. It was like we had driven around the Italian countryside and stumbled on the perfect restaurant with Nonna cranking out heartfelt and perfect dishes all night long with unbelievably knowledgeable and kind staff. Just such an amazing experience that could not recommend any higher.
Very limited menu, no lunch menu on a Saturday afternoon, only brunch menu available. 3 of us had the meatballs with polenta which was tasty but small plate size, 2 meatballs and very little polenta for $23. The egg sandwich was mediocre and also overpriced. The bloody Mary's were the worst I've ever had-tons of black pepper and no taste. $170 for 4 people for brunch and we were all hungry afterward.
Special seasonal and interesting menu, every bite is a party in your mouth!
You can never go wrong at Hearth! Every dish is well thought out and delicious and the staff is a delight.
Food was delicious, server was wonderful and the restaurant accommodated our chafed schedule. Loved it!
I brought my husband here for his birthday dinner but we’ve been here several times, and it never disappoints. The staff, the service, the ambiance and the meal are always fabulous. From the warm sourdough bread with softened butter and most flavorful Ribollita to the beautiful Cod with manila clams, olives, capers, tomato, basil and the meatballs over caciao e pepe polenta…YUM! Our server recommended the Reisling for an overall delicious glass of wine that paired with it all. And dessert..OMG…Olive Oil cake with raspberries, lemon cream and Marscapone cheese cake with blueberry, graham crackers, pine nut brittle..sooooo delicious. Only reason I gave 4 Stars is that our waiter forgot to serve us one of our dishes, and we ended up having to take it home…otherwise go and support this local restaurant. Worth every penny
We had wonderful service. The food was delicious. It was a lovely experience and I would go back there to eat the next time I’m in NYC
Easily the best Tuscan restaurant in NYC. I thought I was in Florence when I tasted the riboletta
Way too much fat on the sirloin minute steak. Besides cutting it off had to spit most of it out.
Service was ok some of the food was great some of the dishes came out cold
We loved our dinner…Christine is an awesome host…we came all the way from Ottawa, Canada and Hearth did not disappoint…we look forward to our next trip!
Delicious food. Small, thoughtful food menu. Lots of great wine options. Service was excellent. Perfect for a date night. Lovely and upscale without trying too hard.
Food was good, our server was amazing, I'm just sorry I didn't catch his name! We had a great time.
Been going to Hearth for 17 years and this is the first time I've been disappointed.
Pasta dish was gloppy and not heated throughout.
Partner's dish Strozzapretti same
Restaurant 1/2 full
Are you getting tired?
Best restaurant in the neighborhood. Consistently excellent.
I went before busy time so venue was quiet & uncrowded.
Zero welcome upon Arrival. Chaotic atmosphere, unbearably noisy main dining room. Delightful server and sommelier. Super limited menu choices haphazardly prepared. Amateur operation , very overpriced for the experience,
Always a great place for up scale food and wine
We had a wonderful experience. Our waitress was so friendly and delightful. The food was delicious. The best chicken I’ve ever had!!!
christine and our server were outstanding
The food delicious
One of our favorites!
Perfect evening meal. The chicken was perfectly prepared. The warmth of the decor and the cocktail elixirs added to the experience.
Very mediocre experience at top prices. When asking for chili or garlic oil for an Italian pasta dish you don’t expect the waiter to bring you Siracha?? That’s exactly what happened here. Otherwise, an amazing wine list, good service and fresh high quality ingredients but somehow quite bland entre dishes with very little spices detectable.
Vastly overpriced. Very small portions. My wife and I ordered the cod which was tiny (half the size of a deck of cards), had very little sauce, and the sauce was tasteless. My son and his partner did no better with what they ordered -- small portions, not much taste, overpriced. It took an hour and half to get our food, and the place was so noisy we had to shout during the entire dinner to be heard. There are so many better restaurants, more reasonably priced, with decent-sized portions, more tasteful, and with better service.
Great menu and delicious food. Great cocktail list, too!
Solid food and great ambiance. Great for small groups and sharing.
Small portions but delicious! Great drinks and vibe as well for a later dinner.
The food was excellent, as was the service. A couple of dishes (meatballs and halibut in particular) were overpriced for the portion. The strozzapreti and bunless burger were worth every penny. The cocktails were also pretty small for the $16 price tag. The inside was gorgeous but unfortunately we were sitting on 1st Ave which was pretty noisy. Overall, a great meal and we’ll definitely be back, hopefully inside next time.
We reserved outside seating, and it was ready when we arrived. Everyone on staff was welcoming and solicitous, and the food was delicious. The selection isn't huge, but all the dishes are winners, especially the meatballs and burger. The garlic bread, too, was a real treat, just dripping with butter.
Amazing food, atmosphere and wine list but quite pricey. The staff are attentive and informed which adds to the restaurants atmosphere.
Slow, discourteous service. Server was generally disinterested in serving our table on the rare occasion he made an appearance. Wrong dishes served to us. Food itself was fine, but certainly not enough to overcome the service (or lack thereof).
Hearth is the best. The service is awesome, the food is some of the best you’ll ever have, not to mention the incredible wine list and house cocktails.
Food was creative and delicious!
Once again we had a fabulous meal at Hearth. The food, service and ambiance were all perfect. So glad we chose to celebrate our anniversary here this year.
This has been one of our go-to restaurants when visiting the city. We’ve never been disappointed until this trip. It may be COVID related, but service was mediocre and food seemed to have slipped compared to prior visits. We are sad to take this off our list. We hope things improve..
First off-a person who served at the table needs to show a little bit of respect and empathy. When I asked for a couple of things to be moderated on the plate the immediate answer was no.
I don’t think the food choices were enough and left quite a lot short of imagination. I think the good days need to come back and quickly for you…
Sorry … but truth is difficult
Understated and relaxed atmosphere, great drinks, attentive service, proper portions and great flavors
Hearth has been my go to place for all types of meals for well over a decade. Solo at the bar, dates, family etc it’s always dope. Food is on point, staff is engaging, diligent and kind and their beverage program is one of the best in the country.
You can order delivery directly from Hearth using the Order Online button. Hearth also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (646) 602-1300.
Hearth is rated 4.6 stars by 2961 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.