Best ribeyes in the city!!!!!
The food was as good as always and we were given a table as requested that was suitable for a handicapped person. Our server was Miles and after introducing himself, he became Houdini, with a great disappearing act. We arrived around 6:15PM for dinner and the restaurant was not very busy. Miles introduced himself and after that we had to keep asking for him and finding other servers to help us. At the end of the meal, Miles was quick to run our credit card. I told him how disappointed we were with his service and that for the first time ever we were not going to leave a tip. Miles neither apologized nor asked for specifics. He simply said “ You are not going to give me anything?”
On the way out, I met with the restaurant manager and gave him four specific examples of the poor service and the manager profusely apologized. We love Harry and Izzy’s, as well as St. Elmo’s. This will not deter us from future visits. It was just an “off” night there for us thanks to Miles.
Our waitress was awesome! The food was cooked perfectly and the first time I’ve seen my girlfriend eat a whole meal lol. The atmosphere looks great and was great pretty quit. On Sunday’s they have a 3 course meal for only $32 for grilled salmon or $40 for a fillet. Great deal since the fillet on the menu alone was $45.
Steaks were ordered M-MR they came to us charred and well done. I did not even finish my 14oz NY strip. The sauce on the H&I NY Strip is absolutely amazing. The steamed green beans were excellent, along with the wine choices. It was our first time in town, perhaps we had different expectations for how the steaks were cooked. Though the waiter said pink...they were not pink.
Originally reserved a bar table for dinner but realized after seating the location was not desirable. Without a fuss, we were immediately given a booth in the main dining area.
We love this restaurant and highly recommend it! We started with the appetizers of the classic shrimp cocktail and the Root Beer Maple glazed bacon - wow, we loved this one on our first try, sweet and then finished with a spicy bite! Will definitely order again! I loved my filet slider - also a top notch choice, the brussel sprouts with bacon were delicious, as were the potato pancakes. Our wine selection was unique and delicious. Our server was outstanding! Bravo, the consistency continues - always our favorite go to restaurant!
Awesome Service. Food was great. Dessert real.good😍
Eric was my server ! I was thoroughly impressed with his knowledge of the menu, and how swift his service was. Everything flowed like it should, and both my date and I recommend Harry and Izzy’s on the Northside! Make sure you request Eric as your server!
Excellent food and service.
Steaks were perfect and delicious
Salads were outstanding as were the apps.
Side dishes lacked a little seasoning but overall were very good (green beans and Brussels sprouts were the best and fried very good) potatoes needed a little more flavor
Very nice restaurant. Steaks were wonderful. The famous shrimp cocktail cleared our sinus cavities. Only complaint is the overall expense, but that is my issue.
Service was very nice.
No much virgin drinks options for someone who like non alcoholic coctail.
Food selection is limited.
Meat was over cooked so I suggest you go less than how you like it; get rare if you like medium rare.
While I've been several times, since we don't live near Indy, this was my first chance to take my family. Everyone enjoyed the experience as much as I hoped they would.
Our waitress was a bit slow with drink refills.
Waitress was horrible.... no personality . Will
Not be back
Outside of the shrimp cocktail, the rest of the meal was just average at best. Very over price for what was brought to the table.
Great Time. Great service. Alex took care of all of us with smiles and professionalism.
I was disappointed with some of the entrees but on the whole it was a good experience.
Great drinks and very nice bartenders!🍸
I was great!!! We we’re a half hour late and they accommodated us
Never a disappointment. File that melts in your mouth. Huge portion of mashed potatoes. The creamed spinach is amazing.
Best fries anywhere. Husband’s filet was wonderful, my ribeye had some unfortunate inedible areas and was undercooked, but our server took it for further cooking and it came back much better. As always shrimp cocktail made you glad you were alive, and made you hope you could continue to breathe to enjoy another bite.
Everything was perfect!
Great food and wonderful service. Lou took good care of us. I’m gluten free and the manager came over to walk me through their menu. Outstanding shrimp cocktail but be warned if you come upon two men crying together at a table it is solely due to the horse radish in the sauce.
We received a gift card and used it for our anniversary on Sun afternoon. Loved the place and the steaks were fabulous. Mashed potatoes & rolls were excellent. We felt chili, ravioli, and asparagus were good but overpriced. Our server, Jodi, couldn't have been more attentive and friendly. She brought us an anniversary card and offered a free dessert. Filet slider was outstanding. We will go back for the meat and potatoes for sure.
It took quite a while to get water. I was the only one at the table that didn’t order steak and when our food arrived my scallops were cold. I gather that it was waiting for three well done steaks to cook.
3 couples at a semi-round booth was not conducive to easy conversation. It was VERY loud. Next time I will be sure to request a table.
Wife really liked her shrimp alfredo. My filet mignon was average at best. I expected much better for the price of the steak. Environment and service was good. However, we probably wont be back due to the average to poor quality of the steak.
Fantastic food, fantastic service, great location.
Food was GREAT. Service was GREAT! I will return when i am in the Indy area again.
Love Harry & Izzy's. Service and food are always very good. Highly recommend.
Great lunch experience in the bar.
The drinks and food were very good and the bartenders were friendly and knowledgeable.
Harry and Izzy's is one of our family's favorites for special occasions and for everyday dining. Been there twice this week, and it never disappoints! Filet sliders were awesome as usual, and I was thrilled to see the Beet Salad back on the menu at lunch yesterday!
Delicious meal, impeccable service, sophisticated atmosphere. My salmon was perfectly cooked to a medium doneness. Great wine and alcohol selection
Selections very much.
Great lunch, prompt and smooth service. As always.
Amazing food and amazing staff. I can't speak highly enough about the staff.
We love Harry & Izzy's, even better than the downtown St. Elmo's. It's in our neighborhood on the north side, making it convenient. It's wine list is impressive and there are good beer choices, too. The famous shrimp cocktail is unique. We never order a meal without the shrimp cocktail first. The steaks--our favorites--are the best in town. Even side dishes, like the green beans, have a unique and wonderful flavor. Wish we had room more often for the desserts. They look fabulous. Treat yourself to this restaurant. It is in the pricey range, but even if you can only afford it once a year, you won't be disappointed.
Maxwell treated us wonderfully and the food was delicious, as always.
St Elmo's has FAR better service. We go to harry and Izzy's for the food quality and because it is closer. But every time we have gone the service has been lackluster at best. And when we have gone, it is not like the place is hammered and busy. The servers appear to be bored and not customer oriented.