My husband and I had Valentines Day dinner. Everything was awesome.
Excellent food and service. Sammy is a wonderful host. This restaurant never disappoints!
I’m not one to usually write reviews but I felt the need to for this restaurant. Upon arrival for our reservation there was plenty of seating downstairs where the ambience and overall setting was very nice and very traditional Italian. We were told that our table was upstairs and that we will be sitting upstairs. When we got upstairs it was very outdated and not nearly as nice as downstairs. The downstairs area had nice music playing and a live singer which could not be heard upstairs. The service was subpar to say the least however I blame that on the fact there was only one server to handle seven tables and also take care of the bar. This was for Valentine’s Day and there was a set menu $75 per person which came with four courses. The food was good But I believe overpriced given the environment and service that we received. I would be willing to try this restaurant again on a regular night and sit downstairs.
The tables are too close together for comfort, the food takes forever on more than one occassion and its ok
not sure why this place is highly rated
The best veal from any restaurant. All the specials are fresh and delicious.
Can’t go wrong with anything off the menu. Authentic Italian close to home.
As always the food and the service is excellent
Yes the food was delicious. The service was excellent. Definitely recommend this restaurant.
Great welcoming atmosphere as soon as entering the restaurant. There was a DJ playing oldies and everyone seemed very happy. Sammy always greets everyone with a smile and walks you to a comfortable table. We ordered cocktails which were perfect, a delicious shrimp cocktail and a generous calamari appetizer. I tried and loved the branzino special prepared in a delicate wine sauce, and my husband thoroughly enjoyed a pasta dish with mushrooms, peas, shrimp, and a very flavorful red sauce. (Capellini Tuto). An after-dinner drink and a shared carrot cake completed this lovely dinner. We will always come back to Goodfella’s.
Just amazing service
Great ambiance and excellent food
Great food and generous portions.
A most amazing dining experience. Food, drinks and service were all outstanding! I will make it a regular when in the area.
Service was attentive and mindful to not interrupt our dinner conversation. Food was excellent, both the regular menu items as well as the specials we tried. Sammy, the host ,was very cordial sharing interesting stories and his apparent love for the business.
Fantastic lunch. Everything we had was delicious. Loved the shrimp and avacado salad. Excellent service too
Sam and his staff are the reason we are regulars! Food is amazing, especially for gluten free needs!
ALL AROUND EXCELLENT FOOD, SERVICE, AND ATMOSPHERE ! LOTS OF “GOODFELLAS” MEMORABILIA ! WE STARTED WITH COCKTAILS AMARETTO DI SARONNO ON THE ROCKS FOR ME, AND A FRENCH MARTINI FOR MY WIFE. WE THEN HAD CALAMARI FRITTI, AS OUR APPETIZER. FOR OUR ENTREE MY WIFE HAD THE LOBSTER RAVIOLI, AND I HAD LINGUINI FRUTTI DI MARE. FOR DESSERT MY WIFE HAD CARROT CAKE AND A CAPPUCCINO, I HAD A DOUBLE ESPRESSO AND A CANNOLI. WE THEN FINISHED WITH A CHOCOLATE MARTINI FOR MY WIFE AND A FRANGELICO ON THE ROCKS FOR ME.
Food tastes great and at a good value! Highly recommended.
Food and people just awesome!!
Amazing place! My team always chooses to eat there
Dinner at Goodfellas is always amazing the food is perfect the service is amazing, Sam is the best host ever and when Leah his bartending there's always a good time to be had! The Wold Worm DJ tops off a perfect evening!
I love this restaurant. The food is always delicious and the service excellent
Overall, quite a lovely night.
The food was excellent. Very friendly staff. The waiter was excellent worked extremely hard but I felt he had too many tables to focus on so the service could have been better.
The manager Sam and the wait staff and bus staff are second to none.
This place is the best kept secret anywhere!
We are treated like royalty whenever we go!
Out first time, definitely not our last.
Goodfellas has “ Carácter”, good hardly Italian food, a great Italian wine list and great Italian personality. The service is good . We will be back soon.
The halibut special was one of the best fish dishes i have ever eaten!
Love this place! I'm never disappointed. Very attentive. Plenty of food. I think prices are reasonable. Looking forward to another visit sometime in the future.
Fabulous food. Service was top notch!! Sammy, Tony and the crew do an awesome job making all 15 of us feel right at home
We met a very important client on site and the client was very pleased with the food and dining experience which made us extremely satisfied. We ended up closing the deal which is always a positive sign.
Had my wife’s birthday dinner at Goodfella’s. They were amazing. Sammy took great care of us and we had a blast. DJ was playing free style music so we ended up staying there till 1:30am!! (80’s babies who love freestyle!)
Great place to dine with friends.
Great customer service.
Will definitely be back!
We came here for Thanksgiving from the moment I called to confirm our reservation I felt welcomed the person on the phone was friendly and polite. We got there a little early and they greeted us and accommodated us right away. The place is beautiful and clean. The bathroom spotless. The staff above and beyond friendly. The food was amazing, fresh and tasty. I was worried to spend a holiday at a restaurant but we definitely felt at home. We will be coming back.
This place is a "hidden gem." The pasta and fish dishes are fresh and delicious, but the pork chop special is the absolute best I've ever had!!!
Great local spot, Sam our host was incredible. The food is always fresh and delicious.
I love Goodfellas have eaten here numerous times great waiters, wonderful food
Outstanding food at Goodfellas. Restaurant was loud on a Saturday night. Appreciated the attentive waiter keeping our drinks coming, because dinner was a little slow.
This was the second time in two weeks that we have dined at Goodfellas. The first time was so good that we had to come back again, and this time bring friends with us. We live in Westchester County, NY, so this is not a local eatery for us. The food from start to finish was the best Italian food I can remember having. It was so good that I felt compelled to sit down with the manager and let him know that he and his staff were doing all the right things. This restaurant is about a 40 minute drive for us, but when we want great Italian food, Goodfellas will be the place!
Not only is the food amazing but the success of this place is all due to Sam the manager and the entire staff!!!!
Very impressed by the service and meal
Goodfellas Ristorante offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (973) 478-4000.
Goodfellas Ristorante is rated 4.6 stars by 121 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.