Celebrating 16 birthday very fun! Great food wait staff was awesome
Excellent spaghetti and meatballs and very good salad- fresh, variety of dressings with fresh veggies -tomatoes , cucumbers, etc. and served with a nice platter of warm bread with oil (yummy). Atmosphere was terrific and friendly staff. Server, Steven, was very friendly and efficient.
Good value for a group of six. Large pizzas provided plenty to eat and some to take home. Heated up great the next day.
Pizza — delicious!! Salads were excellent - nice and fresh! Server Sabrina was friendly, efficient and great!!
Quiet Monday evening get together with another couple at one of our favorite places. We had asked foor a booth for four close to the fireplace. The hostess either never read the Open Table entry or disregarded the request as she picked up two menues and asked us if we wanted a booth or table. Three of the four dinners were excellent. The fourth, which I ordered and was the special of the day, fish and chips not so much. The two generous portions of fish were processed fish pressed into a thin trapazoid shape and mostly breading. The ladies dinners were good, the only hang up was that both of them had ordered a salad which never appeared. The server brought the meals and when we asked about the salads it was obvious that they had been forgotten. The server offered to bring them but we declined since the main course was on the table. This restaurant used to bring a fresh hot italian roll and butter with the salads but this too was overlooked or no longer offered. When I asked for malt vinegar for my fish and chips the young man assisting the server brought the salad oil and vinegar service. When told that was not malt vinegar he went back to the kitchen and returned with the right vinegar. To the server’s credit at the end of the meal she offered the ladies a dessert which they accepted (carrot cake) and enjoyed. Attention to detail and training is obviously lacking at this restaurant. We will go back but be careful to order something that we have had before that we liked; no specials.
Fabulous food with outstanding service
Absolutely adore Giammarco's but was not impressed with their brunch at all. The bacon didn't taste like bacon, the potatoes were flavorless and while I loved the frittata sitting in alfredo, it was room temperature at best. Will be back for their regular menu, but probably won't do brunch again.
Brunch was very good. The omelet was nice and fluffy with very good redskin potatoes. Excellent Sunday choice.
New waiter was ugh! Rest was good as always! Great food and ambience!
The ambience is great and very appealing. The gentleman who showed us to our table didn’t have a smile at all. The server was very sweet and friendly. The lettuce wrap was way too bland and the calamari was very oily. Apart from that we liked everything we ordered
Excellent food and service. Chloe was a wonderful server who was very efficient and courteous. The entrees were prepared and served in a very appetizing flare. Wonderful place!
Great entrees and terrific service. Jess was great - efficient, friendly, and courteous.
The only issue was a large group was seated between our table. The table to the left was full of young children that paraded back and forth and about k Ocker over our baby sling several times. Quite annoying
Great place for Sunday Brunch. Always good food and good service.
We were visiting Columbus for shopping and decided to try this restaurant. It was amazing! We experienced wonderful service, amazing food, and a relaxed but elegant atmosphere. Impressive wine list and cocktail menu! Beautiful bar! The food was Beyoncé delicious. Very impressive AUTHENTIC Italian meals and desert menu. The prices are very reasonable and the owner (and his wife) and the staff are so friendly and pleasant. This was a great experience for us and we do plan on making the drive from Cincinnati for the amazing food and wine selection in the near future.
After a rough start of being forgotten by the staff for 25 mins, I notified the Host and he took responsibility and made everything Great!! Because of his quick fix we would definitely return. Their Chicken Alfredo pizza is so Good!
our sever was extremely pleasant and helpful. She poured our drinks from the bottle to the glass. She checked on us every 15 min to make sure everything was ok
Excellent food and service. Wonderful atmosphere, friendly staff and delicious food.
This was our second time at Giammarco's, this time with my family to celebrate my college graduation. Some of my family had never been there and they were very impressed. The food and service and worth more than money spent, plus the restaurant is beautiful. We will definitely be back!
Excellent from start to end
Fantastic service with “Cookie”. She is the top server at Giammarco’s. Food was excellent and presentation was a 4star!! The freshness of the salads were terrific and the quality of the meat items were wonderful. The entire staff is great.
Fabulous pizza and salad. The atmosphere was terrific. The entire staff was friendly and courteous. The server, Nikki, was excellent. She was very efficient, knowledgeable, and friendly.
Luncheon menu - excellent choice. Food , salad and bread - fabulous!! Server Alex was great! What a wonderful experience. Entire staff was very friendly.
A great place for casual or formal dining. The food was authentic Italian and generous portions. Would definitely go there again and recommend to friends.
Very welcoming! Original reservations were for 8 people. We arrived with 12 (didn’t want to tell the others “no”). They were so accommodating and thanked us for coming. Food and service was great.
Great food! Took longer than expected, but the server made sure to check on us, and took care of us nicely.
Tried the eggplant parm. Rediculous! Have enough favorites I usually don't try anything new but I'm glad I did. Can't miss with fett Alfredo, pizzas and sausage (hot), peppers and onions. Wife says their ital wedding soup is the best she's ever had.
Excellent food, excellent service ( Allie), and excellent atmosphere.
My wife and I went to Giammarco's for the first time to celebrate Valentine's Day. What a mistake. The restaurant was very under staffed and over booked and we had to wait almost two hours for our order. To their credit, they did comp the food price but it really ruined our evening.
Well done all around.
It was Valentine’s Day so it was very busy but other than that it was a nice restaurant I will go again on a slower night
The food was great, prices were reasonable for the quality, and the staff was very friendly on the busiest day of the year - Valentine's Day. The meal too a bit longer than usual to come out, but they kept us happy with beer, appetizers and bread. We will absolutely go back.
We went on Valentine’s Day and despite being PACKED our service was excellent! As we waited for our table we were brought free small pieces of pizza. Once we were seated our waiter got our drinks quickly, answered my questions, and kept our glasses full all night. My fiancé and I even remarked that despite being so so busy, we didn’t feel any stress or hurriedness from the staff. It was still a sweet, romantic evening.
My only complaint would be that I wish I got more food! Next time I’ll skip some of the bread to get more pasta in my belly.
We normally love Giammarcos. They just didn’t seem prepared for the Valentine’s Day business .
We've been to the restaurant twice before and it was great. We decided to take our young girls out for a nice dinner for Valentine's day and ended up having a terrible experience. There were several issues that resulted in our kids pleading with us to never take them there again:
- I made a reservation for 4 people for 7pm more than a week prior. We arrived shortly before 7pm and we were not seated until 7:35.
- We ordered our food within 10-15 minutes of seating but did not receive our meals until after 9pm. Many tables around us were seated, had their meals and paid their checks prior to us receiving our meals.
- When we finally received our meals, they were poorly made and looked like they were just throw together. They tasted entirely different from when I've ordered them before. The side of broccoli, which in the past has been amazing, came with absolutely no seasoning or butter or anything on it.
- The food was disappointing at best but all of this together really ruined our experience.
It was a bad experience for Valentine’s Day dinner.
The food was highly overrated. The seafood stew was one of the most expensive items on the menu and the portion came out in a dinner salad bowl. It had 3 shrimp, 3 mussels . It took over 45 minutes for us to receive our food once ordered. Other table guests complained about the “long time to get their meals”.
The value for the food received was well over rated
However with all this drama, the waitress was very friendly and courteous and apologetic. Unfortunately this was out of her control.
People were standing all over the restaurant waiting for tables. Obviously the reservation system and staffing levels needed immediate attention .
We chose this because it had a 4.7 rating out of 5 and we wanted to try a new place for us.
We won’t be back. Please lower your rating for a more realistic one
With Open Table was able to get in immediately. Service was terrific and food was excellent.
Great food and service. Will be back soon.
They were very busy, always very polite and accommodating , food was excellent
One of my favorites place to eat. I hope to be back soon.