George Martin's Strip Steak
appreciate a true upscale steakhouse experience offering savory,
dry-aged steaks as well as a multitude of chops, seafood and house specialties that are sure to be palate pleasers.
Strip Steak is situated in a turn of the century house in Great River, a
stone's throw away from the Great South Bay. The sophisticated, rich
design is vibrant yet intimate with an art deco style that mirrors the 1920's,
which is evident in the period artwork as well as existing architectural
Gluten free options
Al fresco dining
Live entertainment weekends
Food was great!! Price was great to match! Our waiter was UNBELIEVABLE!! All around a 10! We do go to high end steak house and this was more laid back with a better all around experience
We were celebrating my son’s 9th birthday, as well as, my birthday (I will keep that number to myself) 😀 We had a wonderful experience even with other patrons. They were so nice to my son. I was worried that he may too young for your restaurant but it all worked out nicely. My husband also got a chance to see his high school principal, which was a pleasant surprise. Thoroughly enjoyed our meal and the atmosphere. Thank you for making my birthday so enjoyable!
Thank you so much for celebrating with us! We're so happy to hear you had a great time!
Had the Calamari for an appetizer. Just the rings, no legs and very rubbery. Made me believe it's frozen not fresh. The meal itself was fabulous! I had the special that night which was the boneless ribeye Delmonico with peppercorn sauce. Just a little too much peppercorn for me which I scraped some off no problem and the steak was cooked to perfection. My girlfriend had the seafood trio and loved it! Catherine, our server, was very sweet and courteous. I don't know if it's the design of the place but it was extremely loud. My girlfriend and I sat at a small table and had a hard time hearing each other. Having lived in North Carolina for 32 yrs, I just chalked it up to loud yankees! lol Overall, very good
We're glad you had a great time with us. Thank you for the wonderful review!
Everything was perfect. The bar area was nice with a great selection of wine. The menu was not huge. Less choices more perfection !!! The steak for 2 was the best steak I’d ever eaten.
We're so happy to hear that. Thank you so much for such wonderful praise!
I have been going to George Martins for many years and always recommend it to others. This last visit the food was not as good as it had been in he past. Service was good
The food was good and the service is always great.
Birthday loving dinner
Our server was excellent, very helpful and friendly. Great personality
Thank you! We love to hear that!
As usual, the service and food were both outstanding !!!
Thank you for such a kind review!
Always have a great meal here. Steaks are delicious, always have my drink made perfectly, love the ambiance. Very cozy.
Thank you so much! We're so happy to hear that!
The food was incredible! We went out to celebrate many happenings and had the best time! Thank you!
We love to hear that! Thank you!
Table of 9 , service was seamless , steaks and seafood outstanding ! Great place !!
That makes us so happy to hear! Thank you so much!
Excellent food. Would highly recommend this restaurant for a special occasion as the menu items are very expensive.
The food and service was amazing, well worth the money. The lightening however was so dark we were using candles and flashlights to read the menu.
Another stellar meal was enjoyed at George Martin’s Strip Steak to celebrate my birthday! From the masterfully made cocktails, the scrumptious bread puffs, the fresh and delicious shrimp; to the perfectly seasoned and cooked filet mignon, asparagus béarnaise and loaded mashed potatoes- our experience was beyond fantastic! A delectable apple crisp and rich birthday brownie sundae topped of this amazing meal! The cozy ambiance, and attentive server really completed the experience. I recommend George Martin’s Strip Steak without reservation! A+++
Thank you so much for celebrating with us and for such a wonderful review as well!
I’ve been here a few times and it’s consistently good. The food, the service always top notch. It’s our neighborhood go to spot for a good steak and a glass of wine.
Thank you, Jimmy!
Went there with friends and had a wonderful time. Waitress was awesome and food was excellent
Thank you so much!
Like many chefs who do not understand the use of pepper, this one seems to put pepper on everything in the name of SEASONING. The pepper shaker and mill we invented to just that....ADD PEPPER. Many people, like myself, do not like pepper, and resent its use on dishes that DO NOT CALL FOR IT.
I visit steak houses every week. The lump crab cakes are my favorite and theirs was lack luster. Too much breading! The 12 oz filet for $55 order med rare came out med well?! They remade it for me but this should never have happened. Steak had good seasoning but the sides were boring. Everything seemed to be made with truffle oil. Overall average meal which cost the 4 of us $450 after tip. We will go back but not for years. Not worth the money.
Excellent meal and great service. Appetizers were outstanding (Calamari and Shrimp), Salad was plentiful (wedge and chopped salads). Main courses were top notch (Strip steak, loaded mashed potato, and pasta - broccolini was too crisp for our taste). Dessert was phenomenal (sundae and pina colada special). Highly recommend this restaurant. Comfortable, cozy, and a good noise level where you can actually have a conversation!
Thank you so much! We're so thrilled to hear you had a great time with us!
Loved everything but the staff seemed overwhelmed They did apologize. I understand sometimes things don’t go as planed and my night was a pleasure. Would definitely go back as it was my first visit
The only thing that I would like to see differently is to have an option for a vegetable with the Steak in the neighborhood Specials.
everything was fantastic including the stuffed olives with homemade blue cheese...
We love to hear that!
If you eat steak, this is a great place to go. Hidden gem in a quiet, beautiful neighborhood.
Thank you so much! We're thrilled you had a great time with us!
Attentive, courteous and friendly staff, excellent food, ambience, and menu.
Thank you for an awesome dining experience!
Thank you for such a fantastic review!
Good food, service is good, at times a little slow. Nice atmosphere. A nice local place for a good meal.
Always a great time and a superb meal, the George Martin Strip Steak is in my humble opinion probably the best on Long Island.
Great food, excellent wait staff and a truly interested Management team to insure a stellar dining experience.
I highly recommend The George Martin Strip Steak Restaurant In beautiful Great River, truly a hidden gem.
Thank you so much! We absolutely love to hear that!
Had a wonderful meal as we always do. Waitress was wonderful as well.
Thank you so much! We love to hear that!
Had a great time I had the cowboy excellent all the sides were enough for at four people
We're so happy to hear you had a great experience with us. Thank you for the fantastic review!
Everything was perfect. The servers were attentive and cordial. The meal was excellent. Could not have asked for anything better. Will definitely be returning there
Thank you! We can't wait to have you back!
Service was exceptional. Food is delicious, atmosphere is romantic. Great date place
Thank you for the wonderful review!
The service was great...accommodating and attentive. The food was excellent. Fresh lump crab salad, delicious chopped salad and the chicken dish was also very good. Cocktails were good too!
We love to hear that! Thank you so much!
Atmosphere is always very nice - waitress was patient and helpful. Disappointing they did not have the special I love which is the wagu steak with the ramen noodles. Have to wait for the fall and I hope they bring it back - this is our favorite steak house
We found it completely shocking how at a restaurant that considers itself above average that their fish special, would have as many Large sized size bones in it as it did. Any novice cook never mind a chef would’ve been able to filet that fish better if they tried. The restaurant could not have cared less what the situation was brought upon them. They simply bought us a drink. What a joke.
Hi Lawrence, we’re sorry to hear you had a negative experience with us. We always aim to deliver delicious food for all of our guests to enjoy and we do hope you’ll give us another shot in the future so you can experience a true Strip Steak evening.
The service could have been a little quicker. The choice for $39 special should have more appertizer offerings,
Hi! We’re sorry to hear you didn’t have a five star experience with us. Our service and food quality is always our top priority and we do hope you’ll give us another try in the future to further explore our menu that is always changing with the seasons.
Absolutely delicious - service was good - nice atmosphere - def would go back
Everything was perfect. Drinks, dinner and dessert were great. The service was outstanding.
Thank you so much for such an incredible review! We're thrilled to hear you had a great time with us!
Always a reliable experience. Food and service is on point.
Anniversary. Amazing place and always our favorite place to go! Amazing!!! Always....
We absolutely love to hear that! Thank you!